Cancro, la psico-oncologia e la Nuova Medicina Germanica ® di Geerd Ryke Hamer
Psiche e cancerogenesi: le ipotesi e i nessi che si conoscono attualmente in medicina
Natura sanat, medicus curat
Introduzione:
Da molti secoli gira in medicina
il sospetto che fattori psicologici, sociali e comportamentali
giocherrebbero un possibile ruolo in una eventuale psico-genesi
del cancro e per la sopravvivenza di una tale patologia (rif 45 e
51). Il sospetto che traumi psichici potrebbero
avere un importanza nella genesi del cancro è radicato in una
parte della popolazione, anche se oggi si sa che un tale rapporto
è solo debole (vedi rif 6, 15, 17, 18, 59, 102), ma sembra di
esistere, almeno per alcune patologie neoplastiche. 40% dei
australiani sono convinti che lo stress sarebbe la causa del
cancro al seno (rif 51), e nel Canada il 38% delle donne lo pensa
(rif 50). Tali supposizioni sono argomenti in TV e in riviste non
scientifiche o libri non scientifici. Bisogna distinguere tra una
eventuale influenza diretta tra cervello da un lato e un organo
bersaglio: lo (dis-)stress, la vita emotiva, possono influenzare
lo stato di attivazione del sistema immunitario con consequenze
possibili sulla genesi e la crescita tumorale. E dall'altra parte
le influenze indirette: la nostra psiche determina le nostre
abitudini quotidiane, il consumo di tabacco (essendo
cancerogeno), il consumo d'alcool (un fattore di rischio per
alcuni tipi di cancro), la dieta (anch' essa gioca un ruolo nella
cancerogenesi), il numero delle visite mediche, il numero delle
visite mediche di controllo e di previsione, le nostre attività
fisiche, la nostra vita sociale, le nostre emozioni cosi via (rif
47). La psiche influenza percio anche le nostre esposizioni verso
fattori cancerogeni o fattori protettivi contro il cancro. Cè
chi arrabiandosi, o in uno stato di depressione o di
disperazione, fuma o beve di piu e influenza cosi il proprio
rischio per il cancro. Però: spesso è difficile di distinguere
tra le consequenze psichiche della malattia cancro ed il profilo
psichologico individuale basale.
Oggi la ricerca si orienta anche ai legami tra psiche e sistema
immunitario (e secrezione ormonale), con una probabile importanza
per la cancerogenesi e la crescita tumorale da parte del sistema
immunitario. Le diffese immunitarie giocano un ruolo determinante
nella cancerogenesi (esempio: AIDS/sarcoma di Kaposi o virus HPV)
e si sa che uno sforzo psico-sociale influenza paramentri del
sistema immunitario, un tipico esempio è il herpes delle labra
da HSV-1, che molti conoscono nella fase di preparzione per un
esame difficile o in occasiono simili. La psiconeuroimmunologia
di oggi non è pero in grado di spiegare in un modo incontestato
lo sviluppo di cancro a partire da processi psichici. Non esiste
una accetata teoria psicosomatica della cancerogenesi. E non
esiste una prova scientifica di una realazione diretta
causa-effetto tra sistema immunitario e sviluppo del cancro (rif
126). Le teorie attuali sul cancro si basano su un concetto
multifattoriale, anche con fattori psico-sociali di ordine
secondario.
|
|
Uno dei primi a formulare una ipotesi per una psicogenesi del cancro era il medico greco Ippocrate di Kos (nato 460 a.C. morto 377 a.C.) che introduceva una classificazione del cancro in maligno (denominazione di Ippocrate: karkinoma ) e benigno (rif 127). Il medico Claudio Galeno di Pergamo (129 - 219 d.C. il medico del imperatore Marco Aurelio) ipotizzò piu tardi nel 200 che donne melancoliche sarebbero piu vulnerabili e riscontrerebbero piu facilmente cancro rispetto alle donne ''sanguiniche" nel suo libro "De tumoribus praeter naturam". |
A l'inizio del settecento appaiano
i primi testi scientifici che tematizzavano il legame tra cancro
e lo stress (distress). (rif 1) Nel novecento si pensava che lo
stress (nel senso di distress) o ''l'esaurimento nervoso''
sarrebbero eventualmente a l'origine del cancro. Circa 50 anni fa
nascevano anzi diverse ipotesi di una particolare
"personalità cancrosa'' (personalità a rischio
neoplastico), anche denominata del tipo C
(typus carcinomatosus o cancer prone), che faciliterebbe
l'insorgenza del cancro, un esempio per uno studio che va in
questo direzione e il lavoro di Wirsching del 1985 (rif 94). La
persona di tipo C sarebbe caratterizzata da una abondante
gentilezza, un elevato grado di addatazione sociale, sarebbe
spesso depressivo, altruista con tendenza al sacrificarsri, e
mostrerebbe una inibizione dell'agressione e una mancante
espressività emozionale. Un contributo viene data da Kissen e
Eysenck (rif 90) nel 1962 per uomini affetti dal cancro ai
polmoni. Una tipologia (6 sub-tipi) particolare veniva sviluppata
da Ronald Grossarth-Maticek, filosofo di origine ungarese. Il
personaggio carcinomatoso secondo Grossarth-Maticek (tipo 1)
sarebbe una persona che si esponesse spesso a sostanze
cancerogene, farebbe spesso uso di farmaci, si riposesse poco,
eviterebbe conflitti e sarebbe invece particolarmente vulnerabile
per offese e eventi traumatici. Le idee di una ''personalita
cancrosa'' o tipizzazione psichica del paziente con cancro erano
tra di loro contraditori e studi scientifici non hanno potuto
dimostrare l'esistenza di un tale personaggio, e di consequenza
le corrispondenti ipotesi sono stati abandonati e hanno solo un
ruolo storico nella medicina di oggi. (vedi rif 2 e 13). Lavori
che contradicono la ipotesi dell'esistenza di una ''personalita
cancrosa" sono: (riff 2, 9, 10, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 23, 127)
Secondo i ricercatori Gruhlke e Faller 1996 (rif 72), le
caratteristiche psichologiche attribuite al personaggio ''tipo
C'' sono piutosto da considerare la consequenza di una patologia
traumatizzante invece di essere alla loro origine.
Nel secolo passato sono stati eleborati in psicologia (psicologia
dinamica) anche modelli nevrotici della cancerogenesi
(intasamento della libido, cancro come una forma del suicidio
voluto, paragoni col parto e cosi via). Esistono anche legami tra
alessitimia (incapacita di poter esprimere i
propri sentimenti) e le ipotesi di un presunto personaggio
cancroso. Un rapporto tra nevroticismo e cancro appare invece nel
lavoro di Nakaya (rif 8) nel Giappone, che viene pero contradetto
in Danimarca da Hansen (rif 10) nel 2005. Faragher (rif 35) vede
nel 1990 un possibile legame tra distress (personaggio tipo A) e
cancro al seno. Jasmin, nel 1990 (rif 56) vede nei suoi 77
soggetti una relazione tra prognosi psicosomatica e il rischio
per il cancro.
La depressione non sembra facilitare la
cancerogensi, potrebbe invece influenzare negativamente la
mortalità (Wulsin rif 75 e vedi anche Chorot nel 1994 rif 54).
Lo (di-)stress prolungato sembra avere un effetto sulla
cangerogenesi (rif 38) nel caso del cancro della cute. Stress
chronico sembra pero anche avere un effetto prottetivo
nel cancro al seno a causa della sua influenza ormonale (rif 79 e
91).
Nel corso del ultimo ventennio la prospettiva psicosociale in oncologia prende corpo come ambito di studio a sé, anche se sviluppatasi già a partire dagli anni 50 quando, negli Stati Uniti, si costituiscono le prime associazioni di pazienti laringectomizzati, colostomizzati e di donne operate al seno. Presso il Memorial Sloan-Kettering Center di New York nasce in questo periodo il primo Servizio autonomo finalizzato all' assistenza psicologica del paziente affetto da cancro. La psicooncologia vera e propria e nata negli anni 70 e 80 del ultimo secolo. In Italia, le prime tracce risalgono agli anni 70, nel 1980 viene istituito presso l' Istituto nazionale per la ricerca sul cancro di Genova il primo servizio di psicooncologia. Ricercatori prominenti sono per esempio Jimmi Holland (New York).
Il 25-30% delle persone colpite da cancro presenta problemi di ordine emozionale, che nella maggior parte dei casi non vengono colti e presi in giusta considerazione. Circa 20% dei pazienti di cancro mostrano sintomi di una depressione, che spesso non vengono diagnosticati (Secondo Faller). Il psico-oncologo tedesco Volker Tschuschke lo conferma nel suo libro (rif 25). Tali problemi influenzano in maniera negativa la qualità della vita dei pazienti, l'aderenza alla terapie e i rapporti interpersonali. Si possono aggiungere sentimenti di colpa verso la famiglia o altri.
Argomentazione del oncologo italiano Prof U. Veronesi nel 2006 a questo proposito e in relazione alle ipotesi di Geerd Ryke Hamer: Caro (omissis), non conosco il caso di Hamer ma mi fa piacere confrontarmi con lei sulla natura del cancro, anche se non voglio farlo ideologicamente ma scientificamente. Ho già avuto modo di esprimere su questo forum che io credo che tanto il benessere psichico come il suo opposto, la depressione profonda che porta ad una rinuncia alla vita, possono avere un'influenza sulla cura e sulla risposta del malato alla terapia. Sono anche d'accordo con lei che spesso i farmaci anticancro sono poco efficaci, tant'è vero che con il mio team ci stiamo impegnando nella ricerca di nuovi farmaci molecolari meno tossici per l'organismo e nella messa a punto di combinazioni di farmaci tradizionali che permettano lutilizzo a basse dosi. Tuttavia nella cura del cancro anche il "poco" è importante. Sull'origine psicosomatica del cancro però non abbiamo alcuna evidenza scientifica e dunque, anche se la psicanalisi può sicuramente in alcuni casi far molto bene psicologicamente al paziente, io non mi sentirei mai come medico e come scienziato di considerarla un'alternativa alle cure che, pur con i loro limiti, oggi hanno dimostrato una qualche azione antitumorale. Ciò detto, io sono un gran sostenitore dell'importanza del lato psicologico e soggettivo della malattia, anche e soprattutto quelle più gravi e non mi stanco di ripetere che oggi vale al guarigione ma anche la qualità della guarigione e che la scienza medica non deve mai dimenticare l'attenzione "amorosa" alla persona. (citato da rif 62) Vedi anche rif 125.
maggiori ''life events'' / momenti traumatici: possono scattare il fenomeno cancro ? Smentita della asserzioni rigide di RG Hamer e della ''leggi'' della sua nuova medicina germanica da parte della ricerca internazionale.
L'impatto possibile di cosidetti ''life events'' traumatici (p.e. morte di un familiare/amico nel passato) e specialmente eventi traumatizzant imprevisti come l'attacco allo WTC del 11.9.2001 erano oggetto di ricerca per molti anni (rif 24 e 71) e continua ad essere (rif 119). Sapendo che circa un caso di cancro su 6 è causato da un virus (esempio HPV, HSV, HIV...), la ipotesi immunitaria di life events traumatici sull'insorgenza del cancro appare possibile (attraverso la modulazione del sistema immunitario).
Forsen (rif 5) ha analizzato 87
persone aventi cancro al seno e no (gruppo controllo) per un
eventuale rapporto tra eventi traumatici e cancro. Il suo lavoro
retrospettivo mostra un numero piu grande di eventi traumatici
nel gruppo delle persone con cancro rispetto al gruppo di
controllo nei 12 mesi precedenti la diagnosi. Ramirez vede nel
1989 un rapporto tra life events e ricadute nel caso del cancro
al seno (rif 19), viene pero smentito da Barraclough (rif 21) nel
1992 e nel 2002 da Graham (rif 20) che aggiunge che donne non
dovrebbero avere paura da eventi traumatici come causa di una
eventuale ricaduta. Chen (rif 11) trova una relazione tra eventi
traumatici e cancro al seno in Cina (in contrasto con Protheroe
rif 51). Roberts (rif 4) ha analizzato una eventuale relazione
tra ''life events'' e il cancro al seno e nel suo studio con 872
persone nel 1996 non ha potuto trovare una tale relazione e ha
trovato stranamente un numero maggiore di persone che hanno perso
una persona cara nel gruppo delle donne non
aventi cancro. 1999, McKenna trova un rapporto debole tra eventi
stressanti e cancro al seno (rif 17). Anche Chorot (rif 54) pensa
a una relazione tra psiche e cancro nel 1994. In un review del
2000, Butow vede solo un rapporto debole tra alessitimia, eventi
stressanti e cancro (rif 6), con correlazioni positive solo in
studi con un numero ristretto di soggetti. L' Australiano Price
(rif 7) paragonava nel 2001 donne con processi benigni e donne
con malignomi al seno. E dallo suo studio su 514 donne risulta un
rapporto positivo da eventi stressanti e malignomi (cancro) in
assenza di un aiuto sociale. Questo lavoro contradice invece
quello di Maunsell nel 2003 (rif 50) che non trova nessuna prova
per una tale asserzione nel caso del cancro al seno, e i lavori
di Protheroe del 1999 (rif 51), di Lillberg (nel 2001 rif 52) in
Finlandia, e di Duijts (rif 53) in Ollanda lo confermano. Dal
review di Dalton (3) del 2002 appare che non si conoscono studi
scientifici che mostrano un relazione causale tra ''major life
events'' (eventi traumatici), la depressione, o un particolare
tipo individuale e il rischio di avere cancro. Dalton afferma che
studi scientifici in questo campo contengono spesso un design
metodologico debole. Kvikberg, riferisce dalla Norvegia nel 1995
in un indagine su 14231 donne che la morte del marito o il
divorzio non modifica il rischio per il cancro, con alcune
eccezioni (rif 92), lo stesso autore notera nel anno successivo
1996 nessuna differenza del rischio per cancro in donne che
avevano perso un bambino in precedenza (rif 93). Lillberg afferma
nel 2003 una relazione positiva tra eventi traumatici e cancro in
Finlandia (rif 22), Pereira (USA) afferma che tali eventi sono da
considerare fattori di rischio nel 2003 (rif 24) a base di una
influenza del sistema immunitario sulle difese del corpo contro
virus ongogeni, nello suo studio su pazienti affetti dal HIV.
Il crollo delle due torri dello World Trade Center a New York il 11.9.2001
fu un disastro imprevviso e molto traumatizzante per circa
400.000 persone (con almeno 188 donne incinte nel WTC), 71.000 di
queste persone sono elencati nello World Trade Center Health
Registry (WTCHR) per una osservazione della loro salute. Secondo
le "leggi" della nuova medicina precisamente questo
evento avrebbo dovuto scattare molti nuovi casi immediati di
cancro, e visto che non si sa niente di una terapia tipo NMG per
queste persone non si puo ipottizzare che loro avessero potuto
evitare in questo modo lo sviluppo di cancro. Sono stati fatti
alcune centinaia di studi dopo il 11-9 e alcune tematizzano un
eventuale rapporto tra 11-9 e cancro. La ricerca di Rayne (rif
124) mostra che dopo 4 anni dalla catastrofe, nella zona
l'incidenza di cancro era solo leggermente superiore dopo
l'attacco rispetto al "fondo", e questo si puo anche
spiegare con l'effetto di sostanze cancerogene che furono
liberati nelle polveri dissipati durante la catastrofe ed i
giorni consecutivi. (furono rilevati nelle polveri composti
cancerogeni di idrocarburi policiclici, amianto e cosi via)
E da ricordare pero, che i periodi di latenza tra iniziazione e
promozione di tumore e l'apparizione di sintomi puo essere molto
lungo. Normalmente si tratta di periodi di latenza 2 a 30 anni
(rif 126), in media dura 8 anni. Nel caso di un adulto, e nel
caso del mesotelioma puo estendersi fino a 70 anni. I periodi di
latenza piu brevi che si conoscono sono periodi di circa due anni
nel caso di bambini con una leucemia. Chen riferisce un periodo
di cinque anni tra sintomo clinico del cancro al seno e prime
modifiche osservabili al microscopio a luce (rif 11), in verità
il periodo completo tra inizio e sintomo sara ancora piu lungo.
Ma in teoria un effetto psichico potrebbe anche influenzare in
senso positivo la crescita di un tumore gia esistente e
asintomatico, un contributo per una tale ipotesi danno le
osservazioni di Pereira (rif 24) nel caso del carcinoma cervicale
nel 2003. In queste condizioni il rapporto temporale potrebbe
essere piu breve di 5 anni nel caso di adulti. Eventi traumatici
influenzano anche il comportamento: ce chi si cura meno, e evita
il contatto con servizi sanitari nel caso di elevato distress,
con possibili consequenze sulla patologia stessa. In queste
condizioni un intervento professionale puo essere positivo.
In modo riassuntivo: eventi traumatizzanti non sembrano avere una importanza rilevante nella genesi del cancro, vedi conferma nei riferimenti 20, 40 e 73. Risultati da studi fatti all'inzio della psico-oncologia non potevano essere ripetuti e sembrano parzialmente essere ''contaminati'' dalle aspettative dei ricercatori. La ricerca attuale si concentra a partire degli anni 80 di consequenza di piu sulle possibilità di migliorare la qualita di vita (parole riassuntive di Jimmie Holland e Uwe Koch). Da questo punto di vista si spiega la speranza in una nuova psico-oncologia orientata di piu verso quello che si puo fare in pratica per migliorare la qualità di vita dei ammalati di cancro.
fattori
neuro-endocrini con una possibile importanza nella cancerogenesi
(l'asse HPA / "asse dello stress")
Psiconeuroimmunologia e cancro, il concetto di ''controllo immunitario del cancro'' di 'Burnets. Tra ormoni coinvolti troviamo: cortisolo, prolatina, melatonina, GH, VIP e la sostanza P. Attualmente si conoscono sopratutto studi fatti su animali, e per l'uomo si conoscono quasi solo correlazioni tra stress e la crescita tumorale, e solo pocchi studi prospettivi.
Le cellule NK (natural killer cells): le cellule NK sono importanti nella difesa del corpo contro il cancro, sopratutto nelle fasi iniziali, ma anche nel caso delle metastasi. Lo stress influenza il numero delle cellule NK circolanti (rif 114), e questo effetto sembra essere sotto controllo ipotalamico. Una stimolazione simpatica determina un abbassamento della concentrazione di cellule NK, betabloccanti possono impedire questo effetto. La morfina (e altri oppioidi) inibisce le cellule NK, d'altro lato si sa che la morfina ha un effetto protettiva nel caso dello stress causato da un intervento chirurugico (rif 115 e 116).
Rapporto tra infiammazioni croniche e cancro: vedi Basak (rif 106).
La communicazione della diagnosi cancro: le consequenze per il paziente
Oggi, al contrario del passato, di solito viene communicata la diagnosi al paziente, anche se una diagnosi infausta puo provocare uno scioc profondo. Nei migliori casi, il paziente viene considerato un partner al quale si communica la verità e non una bugia, perche viene preso al serio. (vedi anche Ipocrate rif 98) Questo perche spesso il paziente ha gia un sospetto da tempo e vuole sapere ''la verità'', e questa sua volonta è da rispettare in una relazione rispettuosa e onesta tra medico e paziente. Ci sono medici che hanno il vizio di mandare prima una infermiera dal paziente mentendo e pretendendo di non conoscere la diagnosi e chiedendolo cosa pensa di avere. Un metodo non compattibile con una relazione onesta tra paziente e terapeuta. Ma, spesso nel inzio del rapporto paziente-medico, quest' ultimo esitera per qualche tempo di communicare i suoi sospetti o anzi i primi risultati di un indagine, si parla nel gergo della "bugie della misericordia". Viene spesso ''concesso'' al paziente di cancro un periodo del ''non-sapere'' che puo creare gravi problemi di onesta nel rapporto e puo avere un effetto molto dannoso per il paziente (rif 97), e che conduce ad una lenta communicazione a diversi passi successivi. Al contrario del passato, le speranze di vita media sono cresciute e in alcuni casi (tumore ai testicoli) questa, dopo una terapia causale, potra essere uguale a quella di persone di stessa età, in altri casi invece la situazione puo essere molto diversa. In Germania, il redditto medio dei medici è in calo rispetto a altri redditti e di consequenza e cambiato anche il rapporto medico-paziente, anche per altri motivi (medicina basata sempre di piu sulle prove e strumenti-apparecchi e meno su interventi suggestivi / cambiamenti politici e sociali) il ruolo del medico e cambiato (forse anche come quello del prete) e questo sta di meno ''sopra'' il paziente. Con la mancanza attuale dei medici (nel 2007 in Germania), la situazione potra cambiare pero.
I pazienti non sono uguali pero: ce chi chiede energicamente di essere informato su tutti i dettagli e dopo una diagnosi molto infausta reagira come un ragioniere organizzando la fine della sua vita scivendo un testamento e cosivia. Altre persone invece chiedono (spesso con un linguagio non-verbale) di non essere informati direttamente a proposito del esito probabile della patologia, e dal medico silenzioso capiscono la diagnosi, o come se questo parlasse in una lingua straniera. Nel silenzio si possono communicare tante verità. Si possono anche vedere diverse reazioni del rinegamento e del rifiuto della diagnosi. Una situazione difficile avviene quando il medico di famiglia ipotizza "qualche infezione" o "tumore benigno" e in un centro specializzato viene diagnosticato il contrario, o se un esamine ha un esito positivo falso.
curando il
cancro: interventi psicologici per pazienti e i loro ambiente
le differenti coping style
e il loro effetto
La terapia convenzionale del cancro è di solito una terapia con una primaria orientazione somatica. Da partire dalle conoscenze moderne della psico-oncolgia (a partire dalla fine degli anni 70, partendo dagli stati uniti) tale terapia somatica viene piu spesso affiancata da interventi psicologici da psico-oncologi o psicologi con l'intenzione di migliorare la qualita di vita del paziente, ma anche per avere un eventuale effetto possibile sull'esito della patologia. Tutti i grandi centri ospedalieri hanno oggi un servizio psico-onlogico, almeno negli USA.
Esistono molte "coping style": lo "figthing spirit" - il spirito di combattimento da parte del paziente ma anche da parte dell' ambiente. La reazione attiva, orientata alla risoluzione razionale del problema. La reazione della disperazione, del sentimento di essere disarmato, fino al fatalismo e all' aresa. Il rinnegamento, si evita di voler sapere dettagli della proria patologia. La reazione depressiva, la paura in continuazione. La sopressione dei propri emozioni, la alessitemia. Spesso, con l'andamento della malattia, il paziente mostrera reazioni diverse in diversi momenti.
Lavori prospettivi (non retrospettivi) in questo campo: influenza della situatione psicologica sul andamento della patologia:
Studio scientifico |
paese |
numero soggetti |
follow-up |
relazione |
| Lillberg 2001 (rif 52) | Finlandia | 10.519 | 20 anni | uguale / non esistente |
| Helgesson 2003 (rif 78) | Svezia | 1462 | 24 anni | aumentato |
| Kroenke 2004 (rif 91) | USA | 69886 | 4-8 anni | uguale / non esistente |
| Nielsen 2005 (rif 79) | Danimarca | 6689 | 18 anni | piu basso |
I lavori di Nielsen e di Kroenke tra l'altro mostrano indipendentemente che elevato stress prolungato e quotidiano potrebbe avere un effetto protettivo contro il cancro al seno nel caso delle donne di età media perche questo gruppo mostra una incidenza minore per questa patologia, forse a causa di una secrezione diversa degli ormoni estrogeni. Qui si possono osservare due fenomeni con un effetto opposto: elevate concentrazione di cortisolo a causa di una attivazione del'asse HPA (con un effetto di promozione per il cancro a causa delle conosciute consequenze per la reattività immunitaria) e l'abassamento contemporale dei ormoni estrogeni con un abassamento del rischio per il cancro al seno e sembra prevalere l'efetto prottetivo su quello di promozione. Stress acuto e stress cronico possono dunque avere effetti diversi sulle probabilità di ammalarsi di cancro.
Relazione tra coping psicologico attivo e periodo di sopravivenza nel cancro del seno:
Studio scientifico |
numero soggetti |
stadio |
effetto |
| Greer 1979 (rif 80) | 69 |
I - II |
positivo |
| Hislop 1987 (rif 81) | 133 |
I - IV |
positivo |
| Spiegel 1989 (rif 88) studio retrospettivo, durata 1 anno |
86 |
- |
positivo |
| Morris 1992 | 88 |
I - III |
non esistente |
| Buddeberg 1996 (rif 82) | 107 |
early stages |
non esistente |
| Giraldi 1997 (rif 83) | 95 |
I - II |
non esistente |
| Watson 1999 (rif 84) | 578 |
I - II |
non esistente |
| Reynolds 2000 (rif 85) | 847 |
I - IV |
non esistente |
| Goodwin 2001 (rif 86) | 235 |
- |
non esistente |
| Goodwin 2004 (rif 87) | 397 |
I - III |
non esistente |
Si vede che i rapporti positivi si trovano sopratutto nei lavori piu vecchi, la qualità di vita è da distinguere dallo outcome / periodo di sopravivenza.
Dal lavoro di Tschuschke (rif 76): L' impatto dello fighting spirit nel caso della terapia causale della leucemia (adulti) dopo trasplanto del midollo osseo:

Le remissioni spontanee (RS)
Le remissioni spontanee RS sono guarizioni con nessun legame con una precedente terapia causale (rif 34) e che si verificano spontaneamente. La prima RS che e diventata famosa nella storia della medicina è quella di Pellegrino Laziosi di Forli (1265 - 1345 detto anche Pellegrino da Forlì, in inglese Saint Peregrine) che si ammalò di cancro alla tibia e guari completamente senza intervento medico. Pellegrino Laziosi è diventato nel seguito Il Santo protettore degli ammalati di cancro, secondo la fede cattolica.
L' incidenza di una remissione spontanea nel caso di cancro (solo malignomi) è purtroppo un fenomeno molto raro e occorre soltanto una volta su 60000-100000 dei casi (Bashford, Hirschberg). Nel 1992, Stoll (26) ipotizza che in tutto il mondo si possono verificare circa 20 nuovi casi all'anno. In tutta la storia della oncologia si conoscono solo all' incirca 1200 casi corrispondenti e pubblicati in tutto il mondo. Ulrich Abel (biologo e esperto di statistica di Heidelberg) stima che sarebbe molto difficile di stimare le probabilita per una RS. Oggi si sa che le RS possono verificarsi in tutti i tipi di cancro che si conoscono, sono pero piu frequenti nel carcinoma renale, neuroblastoma, melanoma maligno e nel caso dei linfomi e delle leucemie (rif 33 e 63). Le RS sono anche piu frequenti nei bambini. In Germania esistono due gruppi di lavoro che si sono concentrati sulle RS (per esempio Klinikum Nurimberga). Queste remissioni spontanee rarissime non sono inducibili da una terapia conosciuta, anche dal punto di vista della psiconeuroimmunologia moderna. RS sono spesso stati osservati dopo infezioni con elevata febbre (rif 29), e si hanno osservato tempi di maggiore sopravivenza nel caso di una malattia contemporale. Queste osservazioni hanno condotto a tentativi terapeutici immunologici o terapie che inducono la febbre, e hanno stimolato la ricerca dell'ipertermia terapeutica del cancro. (oggi praticamente abbandonata per mancanza di successi, è rimasta in discussione e uso sola la ipertermia locale con-adiuvante e la ricerca continua). Tra i tentativi terapeutici della febbre è da nominare la terapia di Coley con tossine di batteri, ora abbandonata (rif 49) o tentativi terapeutici con una infezione artificiale della malaria. La vaccinazione BCG (Bacille Calmette Guerin), usata nella prevenzione della tuberculosi viene considerata tuttora efficace in modo co-adiuvante in certi tipi di tumori (tumori della vescica urinaria) (rif 67). Studi e meta-analisi retrospettivivi storici delle remissioni spontanee sono quelli di Rohdenburg nel 1918 (rif 64) con 185 casi citati, Fauvet nel 1960/1964 (202 casi), Boyd W (rif 66) nel 1966 (98 casi), Everson e Cole (rif 68) nel 1966 (182 casi), Challis nel 1990 (rif 69 - 489 casi), O'Reagan e Hirschberg nel 1993 (216 casi). Le ricadute dopo una RS sono purtroppo frequenti (rif 49 e 65). Di consequenza occorre aspettare anni dopo una tale remissione per essere sicuro del successo, esattamente come nel caso di una terapia convenzionale del cancro. Il caso del paziente Wright (rif 27) suscitava clamore nel mondo medico: nel suo caso farmaci placebo (causalmente inefficaci) erano efficaci contro linfomi per alcuni mesi, anche se il paziente è decesso dopo la terapia.
Quali possono essere la cause della RS ? Esistono due spiegazioni: le ipotesi somatiche-fisiologiche e le ipotesi psicologiche. Le correlazioni delle RS con malattie infettive danno un contributo alle ipotesi somatiche, anche se non si sa con precisione quale è l'influenza del puro caso. Un contributo alle ipotesi psicologiche danno le osservazioni che lo ''fighting spirit'' (lo spirito di battaglia dello paziente, la "grinta") e un ottimismo e un ottimo sostegno sociale/familiare (con consequenze sulla qualità di vita) avevano un effetto positivo in una minorità degli studi scientifici sulla terapia del cancro - un tale effetto psicologico sembra essere debole, e nella maggioranza degli studi corrispondenti non poteva essere dimostrato o ripetuto, vedi review di Petticrew del 1999 (rif 73) e di Faller nel 2004 (rif 74).
La prevenzione psico-sociale ed ambientale del cancro: esiste un stile di vita che potrebbe essere efficace a diminuire il rischio di riscontrare cancro ?
A scanso dei fattori a rischio ambientali e delle sostanze con conosciuto effetto cancerogeno, fattori psichici come causa di cancro non sembrano invece avere una importanza rilevante. E di consequenza non esiste una "ricetta psicologica" nella prevenzione del cancro. Nell' assistenza psicologica del cancro, la ricerca ''life-event'' da sostegno alla ipotesi che una vita caratterizata da un sufficiente sostegno sociale avrebbero un effetto protettivo nel caso del cancro (rif 44 e 60). Un tale rapporto sociale stabile puo avere un effetto positivo sul sistema immunitario con consequenze sulle difese del corpo contro virus che sono associati a patologie neoplastiche, sapendo che circa il 15% dei tumori sono da vedere in associazione con una infezione virale. Tipici esempi sono il carcinoma cervicale, sarcoma di Kaposi e alcuni tumori del fegato. Pero: una elevata reattività da parte del sistema immunitario, d'altro lato puo avere effetti negativi nel caso di malattie autoimmune come la poliartrite rheumatica. Rafforzare la reattivita immunitaria non è sempre da consigliare. Evidenze che un cambiamento radicale dello stile di vita o il "pensare positivamente" potrebbero curare una patologia neoplastica non esistono.
Conclusione:
Le ipotesi di Ryke Geerd Hamer e
della sua nuova medicina germanica ® non sono compattibili con
questa revisione della letteratura scientifica fatta a l'inzio
del 2007. Hamer sostiene che il cancro, che non suddivide in
maligno/benigno, sia il tentativo del cervello di
riparare (e quindi di guarire) un trauma psicologico
inaspettato subito in precedenza. E che basti individuare il
trauma sotto acusa e di disfarlo (attraverso una
cosidetta soluzione) perché il cervello receda dalla sua azione
riparatrice, arrestando quindi la proliferazione
delle cellule neoplastiche una volta per tutte, visto che
metastasi non esisterebbero secondo Hamer. Tutto questo ommetendo
terapie convenzionali (a parte una minorità degli interventi
chirurgici) ed evitando una terapia analgetica effetuata con
morfina o farmaci analoghi, esponendo i pazienti a soffererenze
in buona parte evitabili con terapie moderne del dolore. Secondo
Hamer, una tale sua strada terapeutica avrebbe un successo del
95-98%. Non è in grado pero di dimostrarlo, scusandosi con
interventi presunti da parte di loggie massoniche e dalla
organizzazione B'nai Brith ebrea e da un complotto da parte della
"medicina ufficiale". Dai numerosi lavori elencati non
si puo trarre la conclusione certa di una psicogenesi per tutti i
tipi di cancro. Una tale psicogenesi sarebbe inoltre non
compattibile con i diversi tipi di cancro che hanno una accertata
origine virale, origine genetica o una origine dal ambiente
(raggi UV / radioattivita naturale) o da sostanze cangerogene
(p.e. il fumo / amianto) o da radiazioni ionizzanti man-made.
Anche l'esistenza dei tumori trasmissibili (nei animali) non è
compattibile con le "leggi" della Nuova Medicina
Germanica". Da quello che si sa oggi, processi psichici
possono solo avere un ruolo come fattori deboli facilitanti o
protettivi, in alcuni estremi rari casi sono forse a l'origine di
remissioni spontanee. A l'inzio degli anni 80, a l'epoca della
nascita della NMG, la situazione non era cosi chiara come appare
oggi. Si sapeva meno, ed erano in discussione modelli di una
possibile psicogenesi del cancro. Il diffetto non scusabile di
Hamer è da cercare nella sua incapacità di adattare le sue
ipotesi-leggi progressivamente a quello che si puo
osservare/misurare, di rispondere a nuovi risultati scientifici
(anche a risultati deludenti propri), di non basarsi su lavori
fatti e pubblicati in precedenza e riferirsi in un modo
non-critico a racconti e aneddotti scelti, e di aggrapparsi alle
sue leggi, in grande parte scurile. Altri errori non-scusabili
(la questione dei artefatti TAC, asserzioni sbagliate nel
argomento della lateralita umana e embriologia) si aggiungono a
l'odore di antisemitismo (e vicinanza per movimenti di estrema
destra come la NPD tedesca) che non è compattibile con un
rispetto fermo del essere umano (di ogni razza e confessione) e
che deve per forza essere a la base della professione medica
pratica. Le sue affermazioni di non essere razzista non
convincono un lettore neutrale leggendo le sue lettere pubblicate
o interviste, che di piu hanno indotto molti a pensare ad una
mania con valore patologico in un uomo invelenito e racchiuso nel
suo modo di pensare chiuso ermeticamente dal mondo 'esterno.
L'esito fatale nel caso di numerosi pazienti che hanno creduto in
un modo cieco alle promesse del medico o ex-medico charismatico
con la sua voce rassicurante-simpatica e che presentavano gravi
patologie e la contemporanea mancanza di prove per i presunti
successi miracolosi del cancro non lasciano dubbi che la sua
strada diagnostica e terapeutica non è idonea per pazienti
affetti da una grave patologia.
Pazienti affetti da cancro dovrebbero cercare aiuto competente e professionale e stare lontani dalla terapie della NMG !
La si puo considerare invece come alternativa nel caso di infezioni blandi o disturbi psicosomatici banali, per chi le convinzioni anti-ebrei di Hamer non sono un argomento da stargli lontano.
riferimenti:
(1) LeShan L, psychological states in the development of malignous disease: a critical review. J nat cancer inst 1959:22 1-18
(2) Schwarz R, Die Krebspersönlichkeit, libro: 1994 Schattauer Stuttgard New York.
(3) Dalton SO, Mind and cancer. Do
psychological factors cause cancer? in: Eur J Cancer. 2002
Jul;38(10):1313-23
We have reviewed the evidence
for an association between major life events, depression and
personality factors and the risk for cancer. We identified and
included only those prospective or retrospective studies in which
the psychological variable was collected independently of the
outcome. The evidence failed to support the hypothesis that major
life events are a risk factor for cancer. The evidence was
inconsistent for both depression and personality factors. Chance,
bias or confounding may explain this result, as many of the
studies had methodological weaknesses. The generally weak
associations found, the inconsistency of the results, the
unresolved underlying biological mechanism and equivocal findings
of dose-response relationships prevent a conclusion that
psychological factors are established risk factors. However,
certain intriguing findings warrant further studies, which must,
however, be well conducted and large and include detailed
information on confounders.
(4) Roberts FD,
Self-reported stress and risk of breast cancer, Cancer, 1996 Mar
15;77(6):1089-93
BACKGROUND: Many women
attribute the development of their breast cancer to psychosocial
factors such as stress and depression. Yet investigations of the
relationship between breast cancer and stressful life events have
had inconsistent outcomes, due in part to studies with small
sample sizes and reliance on hospital-based populations. METHODS:
As part of a population-based, case-control study of breast
cancer etiology, we evaluated the association between stressful
life events and the risk of breast cancer among 258 breast cancer
patients and 614 randomly selected population-based controls.
Information on 11 stressful life events was collected in
telephone interviews with women aged 50-79 who were participating
in the ongoing study. RESULTS: Breast cancer patients and
controls experienced the same number of stressful life events in
the five years prior to diagnosis or an equivalent reference date
(controls), averaging 2.4 and 2.6 events, respectively. After
adjustment for known breast cancer risk factors, there was no
association between weighted stressful life event scores and the
risk of breast cancer (odds ratio [OR] = 0.90 per unit increase;
95% confidence interval [CI], 0.78-1.05). Only one life event,
death of a close friend, was significantly more often reported by
controls (OR = 0.72; 95% CI, 0.52-1.00). Other life events were
inconsistently and nonsignificantly associated with breast cancer
risk. CONCLUSIONS. The results of this retrospective study do not
suggest any important associations between stressful life events
and breast cancer risk.
(5) Forsen A,
Psychosocial stress as a risk for breast cancer, Psychother
Psychosom, 1991;55(2-4):176-85
Life events, important
emotional losses, difficult life situations, and psychological
characteristics were investigated in a case-control study of 87
breast cancer patients and their controls. In a second part, the
effect of stressful life events preceding cancer diagnosis on
survival was studied in an 8-year follow-up of the breast cancer
group. The control group was selected from the general female
population and matched for sex, age, number of child-births, and
language. The findings showed that breast cancer patients had
significantly more life events, important losses, and difficult
life situations prior to the discovery of the breast tumor than
controls. The analysis indicated that important losses during a
6-year prodromal period and life event scores prior to
examination on both the 12-month and modified 6-year Social
Readjustment Rating Scale were associated with subsequent
development of breast cancer. The association persisted after
adjustment for marital status, education, and social class. The
findings of the survival analyses indicated that life events in
the 12 months preceding the onset of breast cancer and lower
social class were associated with a smaller chance of
disease-free and overall survival after controlling for clinical
factors.
(6) Butow PN,
Epidemiological evidence for a relationship between life events,
coping style, and personality factors in the development of
breast cancer, J Psychom res, 2000 Sep;49(3):169-81
OBJECTIVE: Review empirical
evidence for a relationship between psychosocial factors and
breast cancer development. METHODS: Standardised quality
assessment criteria were utilised to assess the evidence of
psychosocial predictors of breast cancer development in the
following domains: (a) stressful life events, (b) coping style,
(c) social support, and (d) emotional and personality factors.
RESULTS: Few well-designed studies report any association between
life events and breast cancer, the exception being two small
studies using the Life Events and Difficulties Schedule (LEDS)
reporting an association between severely threatening events and
breast cancer risk. Seven studies show anger repression or
alexithymia are predictors, the strongest evidence suggesting
younger women are at increased risk. There is no evidence that
social support, chronic anxiety, or depression affects breast
cancer development. With the exception of
rationality/anti-emotionality, personality factors do not predict
breast cancer risk. CONCLUSION: The evidence for a relationship
between psychosocial factors and breast cancer is weak. The
strongest predictors are emotional repression and severe life
events. Future research would benefit from theoretical grounding
and greater methodological rigour. Recommendations are given.
(7) Price MA, The
role of psychosocial factors in the development of breast
carcinoma: Part II. Life event stressors, social support, defense
style, and emotional control and their interactions, Cancer, 2001
Feb 15;91(4):686-97
BACKGROUND: The evidence
supporting an association between life event stress and breast
carcinoma development is inconsistent. METHODS: Five hundred
fourteen women requiring biopsy after routine mammographic breast
screening were interviewed using the Brown and Harris Life Event
and Difficulties Schedule. Other psychosocial variables assessed
included social support, emotional control, and defense style.
Biopsy results identified 239 women with breast carcinoma and 275
women with benign breast disease. Multiple logistic regression
analysis was used to distinguish between breast carcinoma
subjects and benign breast disease controls based on these
psychosocial variables and their interactions. RESULTS: The
findings of the current study revealed a significant interaction
between highly threatening life stressors and social support.
Women experiencing a stressor objectively rated as highly
threatening and who were without intimate emotional social
support had a ninefold increase in risk of developing breast
carcinoma. CONCLUSIONS: Although there was no evidence of an
independent association between life event stress and breast
carcinoma, the findings of the current study provided strong
evidence that social support interacts with highly threatening
life stressors to increase the risk of breast carcinoma
significantly.
(8) Nakaya N,
Personality traits and cancer survival: a Danish cohort study, Br
j cancer, 2006 Jul 17;95(2):146-52. Epub 2006 Jul 4
We conducted a
population-based prospective cohort study in Denmark to
investigate associations between the personality traits and
cancer survival. Between 1976 and 1977, 1020 residents of the
Copenhagen County completed a questionnaire eliciting information
on personality traits and various health habits. The personality
traits extraversion and neuroticism were measured using the short
form of the Eysenck Personality Inventory. Follow-up in the
Danish Cancer Registry for 1976-2002 revealed 189 incidents of
primary cancer and follow-up for death from the date of the
cancer diagnosis until 2005 revealed 82 deaths from all-cause in
this group. A Cox proportional-hazards model was used to estimate
the hazard ratios (HRs) of death from all-cause according to
extraversion and neuroticism adjusting for potential confounding
factors. A significant association was found between neuroticism
and risk of death (HR, 2.3 (95% CI=1.1-4.7); Linear trend P=0.04)
but not between extraversion and risk of death (HR, 0.9
(0.4-1.7); Linear trend P=0.34). Similar results were found when
using cancer-related death. Stratification by gender revealed a
strong positive association between neuroticism and the risk of
death among women (Linear trend P=0.03). This
study showed that neuroticism is negatively [corrected]
associated with cancer survival. Further research on neuroticism and cancer
survival is needed.
(9) Nakaya N,
Personality and the risk of cancer, j natl cancer inst, 2003 Jun
4;95(11):799-805
http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/95/11/799?ijkey=79f30310e4da10c9c341265b0cecde7e0f4cee4d
BACKGROUND: The role
of personality in the causation of cancer has been controversial.
We examined this question in a large, prospective study. METHODS:
From June through August 1990, 30 277 residents of Miyagi
Prefecture in northern Japan completed a Japanese version of the
short form of the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire-Revised and a
questionnaire on various health habits. There were 671 prevalent
cases of cancer at baseline, and 986 incident cases of cancer
were identified during 7 years of follow-up, through December
1997. We used Cox proportional hazards regression to estimate the
relative risk (RR) of incident cancer (total, stomach,
colorectal, breast, and lung) according to four levels of each of
four personality subscales (extraversion, neuroticism,
psychoticism, and lie), with adjustment for sex, age, education,
smoking, alcohol use, body mass index, and family history of
cancer. Statistical tests were two-sided. RESULTS: Multivariable
RRs of total cancer for individuals in the highest level of each
personality subscale as compared with those in the lowest were
0.9 for extraversion (95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.7 to 1.1;
P(trend) =.32), 1.1 for psychoticism (95% CI = 0.9 to 1.3;
P(trend) =.96), 0.9 for lie (95% CI = 0.7 to 1.0; P(trend) =.19),
and 1.2 for neuroticism (95% CI = 1.0 to 1.4; P(trend) =.06).
There were no associations between any personality subscale and
risk of specific cancers. Neuroticism showed statistically
significant positive, linear associations with prevalent cancer
at baseline (P(trend)<.001) and with the 320 incident cancer
cases diagnosed within the first 3 years of follow-up (P(trend)
=.03); however, it showed no association with the 666 cases
diagnosed during the fourth through the seventh years of
follow-up (P(trend) =.43). CONCLUSION: Our
data do not support the hypothesis that personality is a risk
factor for cancer incidence. The association between neuroticism and prevalent
cancer may be a consequence, rather than a cause, of cancer
diagnosis or symptoms.
(10) Hansen PE, Personality traits, health
behavior, and risk for cancer: a prospective study of Swedish
twin court, Cancer, 2005 Mar 1;103(5):1082-91
BACKGROUND: The
authors conducted a prospective investigation into the relation
between personality traits and the risk for cancer. METHODS: The
study cohort consisted of 29,595 Swedish twins from the national
Swedish Twin Registry who were ages 15-48 years at time of entry.
In 1973, the twins completed a questionnaire eliciting
information on personality traits and health behavior. The
Eysenck Personality Inventory was used to measure neuroticism and
extroversion as two personality dimensions. A Cox proportional
hazards model was used to estimate hazard ratios and 95%
confidence intervals for extroversion and neuroticism separately
as well as for their joint effect, and conditional logistic
regression analyses were conducted to estimate the relation
between personality traits and risks for cancer in twin pairs who
were discordant for cancer. All analyses were conducted for six
etiologically different groups of cancers: hormone-related organ
cancers, virus-related and immune-related cancers, digestive
organ cancers (excluding liver), respiratory organ cancers,
cancers in other sites, and all cancer sites. RESULTS: Follow-up
in the Swedish Cancer Registry for 1974-1999 revealed 1898
incidents of primary cancer. The authors found no significant
association between neuroticism, extroversion, their joint
effects and the risk for any cancer group. CONCLUSIONS: The
current results did not support the hypothesis that certain
personality traits are associated with cancer risk. 2005 American
Cancer Society.
(11) Chen CC, Adverse
life events and breast cancer: case-control study, BMJ, 1995 Dec
9;311(7019):1527-30
OBJECTIVE--To
investigate the strength of association between past life events
and the development of breast cancer. DESIGN--Case-control study.
A standardised life events interview and rating was administered
before a definitive diagnosis. SETTING--Breast Cancer Screening
Assessment Unit and surgical outpatient clinics at King's College
Hospital, London. SUBJECTS--119 consecutive women aged 20-70 who
were referred for biopsy of a suspicious breast lesion. MAIN
OUTCOME MEASURES--Odds ratio of the risk of developing breast
cancer after life events in the preceding five years after
adjustment for confounders. RESULTS--41 women were diagnosed as
having malignant disease while the remainder had benign
conditions. Severe life events increased the risk of breast
cancer. The crude odds ratio was 3.2 (95% confidence interval
1.35 to 7.6). After adjustment for age and the menopause and
other potential confounders this rose to 11.6 (3.1 to 43.7).
Multiple logistic regression analysis showed that all severe
events and coping with the stress of adverse events by
confronting them and focusing on the problems significantly
predicted a diagnosis of breast cancer. Non-severe life events
and long term difficulties had no significant association.
CONCLUSION--These findings suggest an aetiological association
between life stress and breast cancer.
(12) Bleiker EM,
Personality factors and breast cancer development: a prospective
longitudinal study, J natl cancer inst, 1996 Oct
16;88(20):1478-82
http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/88/20/1478?ijkey=ba8a8b7de087a2eb6604b0724ae2f4276bc33545&keytype2=tf_ipsecsha
BACKGROUND: It has been
estimated that approximately 25% of all breast cancers in women
can be explained by currently recognized somatic (i.e.,
hereditary and physiologic) risk factors. It has also been
hypothesized that psychological factors may play a role in the
development of breast cancer. PURPOSE: We investigated the extent
to which personality factors, in addition to somatic risk
factors, may be associated with the development of primary breast
cancer. METHODS: We employed a prospective, longitudinal study
design. From 1989 through 1990, a personality questionnaire was
sent to all female residents of the Dutch city of Nijmegen who
were 43 years of age or older. This questionnaire was sent as
part of an invitation to participate in a population-based breast
cancer screening program. Women who developed breast cancer among
those who returned completed questionnaires were compared with
women without such a diagnosis in regard to somatic risk factors
and personality traits, including anxiety, anger, depression,
rationality, anti-emotionality (i.e., an absence of emotional
behavior or a lack of trust in one's own feelings),
understanding, optimism, social support, and the expression and
control of emotions. Conditional logistic regression analysis was
used to identify variables that could best explain group
membership (i.e., belonging to the case [breast cancer] or the
control [without disease] group). RESULTS: Personality
questionnaires were sent to 28 940 women, and 9705 (34%) were
returned in such a way that they could be used for statistical
analyses. Among the 9705 women who returned useable
questionnaires, 131 were diagnosed with breast cancer during the
period from 1989 through 1994. Seven hundred seventy-one
age-matched control subjects (up to six per case patient) were
selected for the analyses. Three variables were found to be
statistically significantly associated with an increased risk of
breast cancer: 1) having a first-degree family member with breast
cancer (versus not having an affected first-degree relative, odds
ratio [OR] = 4.05; 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.76-9.31); 2)
nulliparity (i.e., having no children) (versus having had a child
before the age of 30 years, OR = 2.67; 95% CI = 1.26-5.68); and
3) a relatively high score on the personality scale of
anti-emotionality (versus a low score, OR = 1.19; 95% CI =
1.05-1.35). CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: With the exception of a
weak association between a high score on the anti-emotionality
scale and the development of breast cancer, no support was found
for the hypothesis that personality traits can differentiate
between groups of women with and without breast cancer. We
recommend that this study be continued and that other studies be
encouraged to explore possible relationships between personality
factors and the risk of breast cancer.
(13) Sampson W,
Controversies in cancer and the mind: effects of psychosocial
support, Semin Oncol, 2002 Dec;29(6):595-600
In the last decades
of the twentieth century, interest in effects of consciousness on
health and illness generated several lines of investigation into
effects on cancer. Animal studies showed sensitivity of some
cancers to hormonal and stressful influences. However, those
findings did not translate into effects on humans, nor did they
lead to advances in understanding of human cancer. The proposal
that emotional state or stress, mediated through
psycho-neuro-immunologic mechanisms would affect cancer
generation or growth, resulted in conflicting information. Major
surveys found no relationship. The proposal of a cancer
personality (Type C) also was not confirmed. Initial observations
that depression and stress affected human cancer seem to have
best been explained by misinterpretations of cause and effect. By
the mid 1990s, a remaining thesis--effect of psychosocial support
on longevity and the course of cancer--was yet to be resolved.
Initial positive results, especially findings in two popularly
quoted studies, were not confirmed; they seem to have been due to
inadequate numbers (chance) or to artifacts in study design or
implementation. Psychosocial support may result in better
adjustment and quality of life, but it does not directly affect
the evolution of human cancer.
(14) Schwarz R,
Social and psychological differences between cancer and noncancer
patients: cause or consequence of the disease? Psychother
Psychosom, 1984;41(4):195-9
83 female patients with breast tumors were interviewed
prior to biopsy. The interview contained a psychological
instrument measuring action control as an indicator for the
patients' reaction to stress together with questions about the
expected diagnosis. Using multiple-regression analysis we
estimated the explained variance of the variables relating to the
histological result of the biopsy. Since most of the patients
gave a correct prognosis of the nature of their disease-this
variable proved to be very important-most of the social
psychological findings have to be interpreted as consequences
rather than causes of cancer.
(15) Garssen B,
Psychological factors and cancer development: evidence after 30
years of research, clin psychol rev, 2004 Jul;24(3):315-38
The question whether
psychological factors affect cancer development has intrigued
both researchers and patients. This review critically summarizes
the findings of studies that have tried to answer this question
in the past 30 years. Earlier reviews, including meta-analyses,
covered only a limited number of studies, and included studies
with a questionable design (group-comparison, cross-sectional or
semiprospective design). This review comprises only longitudinal,
truly prospective studies (N=70). It was concluded that there is
not any psychological factor for which an influence on cancer
development has been convincingly demonstrated in a series of
studies. Only in terms of 'an influence that cannot be totally
dismissed,' some factors emerged as 'most promising':
helplessness and repression seemed to contribute to an
unfavorable prognosis, while denial/minimizing seemed to be
associated with a favorable prognosis. Some, but even less
convincing evidence, was found that having experienced loss
events, a low level of social support, and chronic depression
predict an unfavorable prognosis. The influences of life events
(other than loss events), negative emotional states, fighting
spirit, stoic acceptance/fatalism, active coping, personality
factors, and locus of control are minor or absent. A
methodological shortcoming is not to have investigated the
interactive effect of psychological factors, demographic, and
biomedical risk factors.
(16) Zander E,
Cancer--a psychosomatic disease?, Z Psychosom Med Psychoanal,
1983;29(4):363-79
Taking psychoanalytical
aspects of psychologically caused symptoms into consideration it
is discussed, whether in a narrower sense human cancer can be
regarded as a psychosomatic disease or not. Research results in
molecular biology including genetics are taken into account. It
is held that psychogenesis as a primary cause explains only a
minor part of the incidence rate of human cancer.
Psychological--or neurotic--influences on the course of the
disease are regarded as relatively well proved, but not as
specific to cancer. Against hasty psychological explanations of
cancer should be warned.
(17) McKenna MC,
Psychosocial factors and the development of breast cancer: a
meta-analysis, health psychol, 1999 Sep;18(5):520-31
A meta-analysis
examined the relationship between psychosocial factors and the
development of breast cancer. Average effect sizes (Hedges's g)
were calculated from 46 studies for 8 major construct categories:
anxiety/depression, childhood family environment,
conflict-avoidant personality, denial/repression coping, anger
expression, extraversion-introversion, stressful life events, and
separation/loss. Significant effect sizes were found for
denial/repression coping (g = .38), separation/loss experiences
(g = .29), and stressful life events (g = .25). Although
conflict-avoidant personality style was also significant (g =
.19), the effect size was less robust, and a moderate number of
future studies with null results would reduce the significance.
Results overall support only a modest association between
specific psychosocial factors and breast cancer and are contrary
to the conventional wisdom that personality and stress influence
the development of breast cancer.
(18) Edwards JR, The
relationship between psychosocial factors and breast cancer: some
unexpected results, Behav med, 1990 Spring;16(1):5-14
A growing body of
research suggests a link between psychosocial factors and breast
cancer. Research in this area often contains methodological
problems, however, such as small sample size, inadequate
comparison groups, omission of important control variables,
inclusion of only a few psychosocial variables, and failure to
analyze moderating effects. To overcome these problems, the
present study examined the link between breast cancer and
multiple psychosocial variables (life events, coping, Type A
behavior pattern, availability of social support) among 1,052
women with and without breast cancer. After controlling for
history of breast cancer and age, we found very few significant
relationships between psychosocial variables and breast cancer.
Furthermore, the relationship between life events and breast
cancer was not moderated by coping, Type A, or availability of
social support. Methodological and substantive reasons for these
findings are discussed.
(19) Ramirez AJ,
Craig TKJ, Watson JP, Fentiman IS, North WRS, Rubens RD. Stress
and relapse of breast cancer. BMJ 1989;298:291-3
To elucidate the association
between stressful life events and the development of cancer the
influence of life stress on relapse in operable breast cancer was
examined in matched pairs of women in a case-control study.
Adverse life events and difficulties occurring during the
postoperative disease free interval were recorded in 50 women who
had developed their first recurrence of operable breast cancer
and during equivalent follow up times in 50 women with operable
breast cancer in remission. The cases and controls were matched
for the main physical and pathological factors known to be
prognostic in breast cancer and sociodemographic variables that
influence the frequency of life events and difficulties. Severely
threatening life events and difficulties were significantly
associated with the first recurrence of breast cancer. The
relative risk of relapse associated with severe life events was
5.67 (95% confidence interval 1.57 to 37.20), and the relative
risk associated with severe difficulties was 4.75 (1.58 to
19.20). Life events and difficulties not rated as severe were not
related to relapse. Experiencing a non-severe life event was
associated with a relative risk of 2.0 (0.62 to 7.47), and
experiencing a non-severe difficulty was associated with a
relative risk of 1.13 (0.38 to 3.35). These results suggest a
prognostic association between severe life stressors and
recurrence of breast cancer, but a larger prospective study is
needed for confirmation.
(20) Graham J,
Stressful life experiences and risk of relapse of breast cancer:
observational cohort study, BMJ, 2002 Jun 15;324(7351):1420
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/picrender.fcgi?artid=115851&blobtype=pdf
OBJECTIVE: To
confirm, using an observational cohort design, the relation
between severely stressful life experiences and relapse of breast
cancer found in a previous case-control study. DESIGN:
Prospective follow up for five years of a cohort of women newly
diagnosed as having breast cancer, collecting data on stressful
life experiences, depression, and biological prognostic factors.
SETTING: NHS breast clinic, London; 1991-9. PARTICIPANTS: A
consecutive series of women aged under 60 newly diagnosed as
having a primary operable breast tumour. 202/222 (91%) eligible
women participated in the first life experiences interview. 170
(77%) provided complete interview data either up to 5 years after
diagnosis or to recurrence. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Recurrence of
disease. RESULTS: We controlled for biological prognostic factors
(lymph node infiltration and tumour histology), and found no
increased risk of recurrence in women who had had one or more
severely stressful life experiences in the year before diagnosis
compared with women who did not (hazard ratio 1.01, 95%
confidence interval 0.58 to 1.74, P=0.99). Women who had had one
or more severely stressful life experiences in the 5 years after
diagnosis had a lower risk of recurrence (0.52, 0.29 to 0.95,
P=0.03) than those who did not. CONCLUSION: These data do not confirm an earlier finding from a case-control study that
severely stressful life experiences increase the risk of
recurrence of breast cancer. Differences in case control and
prospective methods may explain the contradictory results. We
took the prospective study as the more robust, and the results
suggest that women with breast cancer need not fear that
stressful experiences will precipitate the return of their
disease.
(21) Barraclough J,
Pinder P, Cruddas M, Osmond C, Taylor I, Perry M. Life events and
breast cancer prognosis. BMJ 1992;304:1078-81
OBJECTIVE--To
determine whether psychosocial stress, in the form of adverse
life events and social difficulties, depressive illness, or lack
of confiding relationships, shortens the postoperative disease
free interval in breast cancer patients. DESIGN--Prospective
follow up of a cohort of newly diagnosed breast cancer patients
for 42 months after primary surgical treatment, using a life
events and social difficulties schedule (LEDS) and assessment of
depressive symptomatology (DSM-III). SETTING--Patients recruited
from breast clinics in Southampton and Portsmouth were
interviewed in their homes. PATIENTS--204 women (83% of 246
consecutive cases) treated either by mastectomy or wide excision
followed by radiotherapy interviewed four, 24, and 42 months
after operation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Hazard ratios for relapse
of breast cancer in relation to various measures of psychosocial
stress. Relapse was defined as local recurrence or distant
metastasis, or both, with histological or radiological
confirmation and timed from the month when clinical symptoms
began. RESULTS--After adjustment for age and axillary lymph node
involvement, the hazard ratio associated with severe life events
or social difficulties (excluding "own health" ones),
or both, during the year before breast cancer surgery was 0.43
(95% confidence interval 0.20 to 0.93); for those during the
follow up period it was 0.88 (0.48 to 1.64). For prolonged major
depression before surgery and during the follow up period, hazard
ratios were 1.26 (0.49 to 3.26) and 0.85 (0.41 to 1.79)
respectively. For absence of a full confidant the figures were
0.93 (0.42 to 2.09) and 0.86 (0.38 to 1.93). CONCLUSION--These
results give no support to the theory that psychosocial stress
contributes to relapse of breast cancer.
(22) Lillberg K,
Stressful life events and risk of breast cancer in 10,808 women:
a cohort study, Am j epidemiol, 2003 Mar 1;157(5):415-23
http://aje.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/157/5/415?ijkey=0b9693306207f4d2e7dd1f46e798450a51bc7ead
The authors
prospectively investigated the relation between stressful life
events and risk of breast cancer among 10,808 women from the
Finnish Twin Cohort. Life events and breast cancer risk factors
were assessed by self-administered questionnaire in 1981. A
national modification of a standardized life event inventory was
used, examining accumulation of life events and individual life
events and placing emphasis on the 5 years preceding completion
of the questionnaire. Through record linkage with the Finnish
Cancer Registry, 180 incident cases of breast cancer were
identified in the cohort between 1982 and 1996. The multivariable
adjusted hazard ratio for breast cancer per one-event increase in
the total number of life events was 1.07 (95% confidence interval
(CI): 1.00, 1.15). This risk estimate rose to 1.35 (95% CI: 1.09,
1.67) when only major life events were taken into account.
Independently of total life events, divorce/separation (hazard
ratio (HR) = 2.26, 95% CI: 1.25, 4.07), death of a husband (HR =
2.00, 95% CI: 1.03, 3.88), and death of a close relative or
friend (HR = 1.36, 95% CI: 1.00, 1.86) were all associated with
increased risk of breast cancer. The findings suggest a role for
life events in breast cancer etiology through hormonal or other
mechanisms.
(23) Lillberg K,
Personality characteristics and the risk of breast cancer: a
prospective cohort study. int j cancer, 2002 Jul 20;100(3):361-6
Various personality
characteristics have been suggested to increase the risk of
breast cancer but reliable epidemiologic data on this issue are
limited. We prospectively investigated the relationship between
personality characteristics and the risk of breast cancer in
12,499 Finnish women aged 18 years or more. In health
questionnaires in 1975 and 1981, these women completed at least
one of the following personality scales: Eysenck extroversion,
Bortner type A behaviour and author-constructed measure of
hostility. They also reported about other potential breast cancer
risk factors. From 1976-1996, 253 cases of breast cancer were
identified by record linkage with the Finnish Cancer Registry.
Proportional hazard models were used to estimate hazard ratios
(HR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI). The multivariable HRs of
breast cancer for women with intermediate level (scores 3-6) and
high level (7-9) of extroversion in 1975 were 1.18 (95% CI
0.87-1.60) and 0.97 (95% CI 0.64-1.47), respectively, compared to
those with low level (0-2). These results remained unaltered when
the level of extroversion was determined as the average of the
1975 and 1981 reports. There was also no increase in breast
cancer risk in relation to type A behaviour and hostility.
Furthermore, we observed no substantial joint effects of
personality characteristics on the risk of breast cancer. In
conclusion, our data do not support the existence of an important role for
personality in the aetiology of breast cancer. These findings are
reassuring to those who have believed the contrary.
(24) Pereira DB, Life
stress and cervical squamous intraepithelial lesions in women
with human papillomavirus and human immunodeficiency virus,
Psychosom Med, 2003 May-Jun;65(3):427-34
http://www.psychosomaticmedicine.org/cgi/reprint/65/3/427?ijkey=0bd20bb958e7d5a62e1589bb41f88f55d0892e95
OBJECTIVE: Human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected women are at risk for
cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and cancer due to
impaired immunosurveillance over human papillomavirus (HPV)
infection. Life stress has been implicated in immune decrements
in HIV-infected individuals and therefore may contribute to CIN
progression over time. The purpose of this study was to determine
whether life stress was associated with progression and/or
persistence of squamous intraepithelial lesions (SIL), the
cytologic diagnosis conferred by Papanicolaou smear, after 1-year
follow-up among women co-infected with HIV and HPV. METHOD:
Thirty-two HIV-infected African-American and Caribbean-American
women underwent a psychosocial interview, blood draw, colposcopy,
and HPV cervical swab at study entry. Using medical chart review,
we then abstracted SIL diagnoses at study entry and after 1-year
follow-up. RESULTS: Hierarchical logistic regression analysis
revealed that higher life stress increased the odds of developing
progressive/persistent SIL over 1 year by approximately
seven-fold after covarying relevant biological and behavioral
control variables. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that life
stress may constitute an independent risk factor for SIL
progression and/or persistence in HIV-infected women. Stress
management interventions may decrease risk for SIL
progression/persistence in women living with HIV.
(25) Tschuschke V: Pschoonkologie - Psychologische Aspekte der Entstehung und Bewältigung von Krebs. Stuttgard Schattauer 2002
(26) Stoll BA,
Spontaneous regression of cancer: new insights, Biotherapy,
1992;4(1):23-30
Suppression of oncogene
expression and of host- or tumour-expressed growth factors and
receptors may precipitate spontaneous regression or dormancy in
human cancer. Loss of oncogenes necessary for progressive
proliferation can lead to differentiation changes. Both natural
factors and chemical agents can trigger such a change, and of the
naturally occurring agents, growth factors and immunological
factors have been most studied. We may find new clues to
biological methods of prolonging arrest of cancer, by looking for
cytogenetic abnormalities, alterations in oncogene expression and
immunocytological composition, in patients showing prolonged
dormancy of cancer.
(27) Il caso Wright
del 1957: Cancro e l'effetto placebo. "Psychologist Bruno
Klopfer was treating a man named Wright who had advanced cancer
of the lymph nodes. All standard treatments had been
exhausted and Wright appeared to have little time left. His
neck, armpits, chest, abdomen, and groin were filled with tumors
the size of oranges, and his spleen and liver were so enlarged
that two quarts of milky fluid had to be drained out of his chest
every day.
Wright heard about an exciting new drug called Krebiozen, and he
begged his doctor to let him try it. At first the doctor
refused because the drug was being tried on people with a life
expectancy of at least three months. Finally the doctor
gave in and gave Wright an injection of Krebiozen on Friday, but
in his heart of hearts he did not expect Wright to last the
weekend. "To his surprise, on the following Monday he found
Wright out of bed and walking around. Klopfer reported that
his tumors had 'melted like snowballs on a hot stove' and were
half their original size. Ten days after Wright's first
treatment, he left the hospital and was, as far as his doctors
could tell, cancer free. When he entered the hospital he
had needed an oxygen mask to breathe, but when he left, he was
well enough to fly his own plane at 12,000 feet with no
discomfort. "Wright remained well for about two months, but
then articles began to appear asserting that Krebiozen actually
had no effect on cancer of the lymph nodes. Wright, who was
rigidly logical and scientific in his thinking, became very
depressed, suffered a relapse, and was readmitted to the
hospital. This time his physician decided to try an
experiment. He told Wright that Krebiozen was every bit as
effective as it had seemed, but that some of the initial supplies
of the drug had deteriorated during shipping. He explained,
however, that he had a new highly concentrated version of the
drug and could treat Wright with this. The physician used
only plain water and went through an elaborate procedure before
injecting Wright with the placebo. "Again the results were
dramatic. Tumor masses melted, chest fluid vanished, and
Wright was quickly back on his feet and feeling great. He
remained symptom-free for another two months, but then the AMA
announced that a nationwide study of Krebiozen had found the drug
worthless for the treatment of cancer. This time Wright's
faith was completely shattered. His cancer blossomed anew
and he died two days later."
(Brono Klopfer, Psychological Variables in Human Cancer, Journal
of Prospective Techniques 31, 1957, pp. 331-40.)
(27-2) The best known sample of
the placebo response, is perhaps the case of Mr Wright,
documented in 1957 by Dr Phillip West and Dr Bruno Klopfer. Mr
Wright had advanced widespread lymphosarcoma, and as standard
treatment has failed, he was expected to live no more than a few
weeks. A then new drug (Krebiozen) was being tested as a
potential cancer cure, and on Mr Wright`s request, he was
included in the trial. Shortly after the first injection of the
drug, the patient`s tumor masses melted like snowballs on a
hot stove. Wright was soon released, apparently free of
malignancy. Two months later, shortly after the worthlessness of
the drug was being published in newspapers, Mr Wright`s tumours
returned. Dr Klopfer, suspecting that this was due to Wright`s
expectations, again involved Mr Wright, pretending to give him a
double-strength of a new, more active form of the drug, while
merely treating him with distilled water. Again the tumours
disappeared and Mr Wright was symptom-free for another two
months. Then a report from the American Medical Association
stating beyond doubt that Krebiozen was worthless, was published
in the newspapers. Wright`s tumours reappeared and he died within
two days. It is said that it was his total belief in the efficacy
of a worthless drug that mobilized a healing placebo response by
activating all the major systems of mind-body communication and
healing, namely endocrine, autonomic nervous and immune systems.
Riferimenti per questo caso:
http://webspace.quinnipiac.edu/thomas/InformedConsentPlaceboEffectACLMversion2.pdf
Rossi, EL (1986). The psychobiology of mind-body healing. (First
edition) WW Norton & Company, Inc.
Watkins, A (1997). Mind-body medicine. A clinicians guide to
psychoneuroimmunology. (First edition) Churchill &Livingston.
(28) Sarkar RR, Cancer self
remission and tumor stability-- a stochastic approach, Math
biosci 2005 Jul, 196 (1) 65
The paper aims to express the
spontaneous regression and progression of a malignant tumor
system as a prey--predator like system. The model is a three
dimensional deterministic system, consisting of tumor cells,
hunting predator cells and resting predator cells. Local
stability analysis is performed along with numerical simulations
to support the analytical findings. Moreover, the deterministic
model is extended to a stochastic one allowing random
fluctuations around the positive interior equilibrium. The
stochastic stability properties of the model are investigated
both analytically and numerically. The thresholds obtained from
our study may be helpful to control the malignant tumor growth.
(29) Hobohm U, Fever
therapy revisited, Br J Cancer 2005 feb 14, 92(3) 421
The phenomenon of spontaneous
regression and remission from cancer has been observed by many
physicians and was described in hundreds of publications.
However, suggestive clues on cause or trigger are sparse and not
substantiated by much experimental evidence. In this review,
literature is surveyed and summarised and possible causes are
discussed. At least in a larger fraction of cases a hefty
feverish infection is linked with spontaneous regression in time
and is investigated as putative trigger. Epidemiological and
immunological evidence is put into perspective.
(30) Bodey B, The
spontaneous regression of neoplasms in mammals: possible
mechanisms and their application in immunotherapy, In Vivo 1998
Jan-feb 12(1) 107
In mammalian cells, neoplastic
transformation is directly associated with the expression of
oncogenes, with the mutation, loss or simple inactivation of the
function of tumor suppressor genes, and the production of certain
growth factors. Genes for suppression of the development of the
malignant immunophenotype, as well as inhibitory growth factors
have regulatory functions within the normal processes of cell
division and differentiation. Telomerase (a ribonucleoprotein
polymerase) activation is frequently observed in various cancers.
Telomerase activation is regarded as essential for cell
immortalization and its inhibition may result in the spontaneous
regression (SR) of neoplasms. SR of neoplasms occurs when the
malignant tumor mass partially or completely disappears without
any treatment or as a result of a therapy considered inadequate
to influence systemic neoplastic disease. This definition makes
it clear that the term SR applies to neoplasms in which the
malignant disease is not necessarily cured, and to cases where
the regression may be neither complete nor permanent. A number of
possible mechanisms of SR are reviewed, with the understanding
that no single mechanism can completely account for this
phenomenon. The application of the newest immunological,
molecular biological and genetic insights for more individualized
anticancer immunotherapy (biotherapy) is also discussed.
(31) Horino T,
Spontaneous remission of small cell lung cancer: a case report
and review in the literature, lung cancer, 2006 Aug;53(2):249-52.
Epub 2006 Jun 21
Spontaneous remission (SR) of
cancer, especially of lung tumor, is a rare biological event.
Only seven cases in which small cell lung cancer (SCLC) regressed
spontaneously had been previously reported. We report here a rare
case of complete SR of SCLC in an 86-year-old man. Paraneoplastic
sensory neuronopathy (PSN) is a rare syndrome, which is
associated with malignancy such as SCLC and starts with
dysesthetic pain and numbness in the distal extremities, then
spreading all four limbs and trunk causing severe sensory ataxia.
In the previous reports, SR of SCLC is suggested to result from
surgical trauma or PSN, which may be able to enhance anti-tumoral
immunity. Our report is the case of SR of SCLC, without any
therapies nor any invasive examinations. Although the reason of
SR of SCLC in the present case is unknown, PSN could be one of
the diagnosis by exclusion.
(32) Horii R, Spontaneous " healing" of breast
cancer, Breast cancer, 2005;12(2):140-4
http://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jbcs/12/2/140/_pdf
BACKGROUND: Healing
is a phenomenon by which the intraductal component of breast
cancer disappears and is replaced by fibrous tissue. Focally
localized healing often prevents confirmation of the continuity
of intraductal carcinoma. OBJECTIVE: To clarify the
clinicopathological characteristics of breast cancer with
healing. PATIENTS AND METHODS: At our hospital, 308 patients (311
breasts) underwent breast conservation therapy without
neoadjuvant chemotherapy for breast cancer in 2000. These
surgical specimens were histopathologically investigated with 5
mm serial sections. We assessed the proportion and the
characteristics of breast cancer with healing. RESULTS: (1) The
proportion of breast cancer with healing was 7% (21/311). (2) In
the 21 patients, the mean age was 59.2 years, and the mean
diameter was 2.8 cm. (3) The histological type of the breast
cancer varied: noninvasive ductal carcinoma in 2 cases,
papillotubular carcinoma in 5, solid-tubular carcinoma in 8,
scirrhous carcinoma in 5, invasive lobular carcinoma in 1, and
Paget's disease in 1. However in all cases, the histologic type
of the intraductal carcinoma foci was the comedo/solid type and
the nuclear grade of cancer cells was high. (4) In cases with
healing, areas of healing were seen in an average of 5 (1-26)
blocks, compared with intraductal carcinoma foci in 13 blocks
(2-40). Healing was located on the nipple side of the main lesion
in 8 cases, the peripheral side in 9, and both sides in 4. In 3
cases, healing was seen at the surgical margin of the partial
mastectomy specimen. CONCLUSION: The proportion of breast cancer
cases with healing was 7% and these cases were intraductal
carcinoma of the comedo/solid type, consisting of highly
malignant cancer cells.
(33) Papac RJ,
Spontaneous regression of cancer: possible mechanisms, In Vivo,
1998 Nov-Dec;12(6):571-8
Spontaneous regression of
cancer is reported in virtually all types of human cancer,
although the greatest number of cases are reported in patients
with neuroblastoma, renal cell carcinoma, malignant melanoma and
lymhomas/leukemias. Study of patients with these diseases has
provided most of the data regarding mechanisms of spontaneous
regression. Mechanisms proposed for spontaneous regression of
human cancer include: immune mediation, tumor inhibition by
growth factors and/or cytokines, induction of differentiation,
hormonal mediation, elimination of a carcinogen, tumor necrosis
and/or angiogenesis inhibition, psychologic factors, apoptosis
and epigenetic mechanisms. Clinical observations and laboratory
studies support these concepts to a variable extent. The
induction of spontaneous regression may involve multiple
mechanisms in some cases although the end result is likely to be
either differentiation or cell death. Elucidation of the process
of spontaneous regression offers the possibility of improved
methods of treating and preventing cancer.
(34) Kaiser HE,
Spontaneous neoplastic regression: the significance of apoptosis,
In Vivo, 2000 Nov-Dec;14(6):773-88
In mammalian cells, neoplastic
transformation has a direct relationship with the expression of
oncogenes, the production of certain growth factors and with the
mutation, loss or simple inactivation of the function of tumor
suppressor genes. Genes for suppression of the development of the
malignant immunophenotype, as well as inhibitory growth factors
have regulatory functions within the normal processes of cell
division and differentiation. Telomerase (a ribonucleoprotein
polymerase) activation is frequently observed in various types of
neoplastic cell transformation. Telomerase activation is regarded
as essential for cell immortalization and its inhibition may
result in spontaneous regression (SR) of neoplasms. SR of
neoplasms occurs when the malignant tumor mass partially or
completely disappears without any treatment or as a result of a
therapy considered inadequate to influence systemic neoplastic
disease. This definition makes it clear that the term SR applies
to neoplasms in which the malignant disease is not necessarily
cured, and to cases where the regression may not be complete or
permanent. A number of possible mechanisms of SR are reviewed,
with the understanding that no single mechanism can completely
account for this phenomenon. The application of the newest
immunological, molecular biological and genetic insights for more
individualized anticancer immunotherapy (biotherapy) is also
discussed. In conclusion, of all the possible mechanisms of SR of
neoplasms, programmed cell death (PCD) or apoptosis is involved
in each. The immunological mechanism is probably the main
effector mechanism of SR in human neoplasms with its trigger
being apoptosis. The treatments of the tumor, such as with
various anti-neoplastic drugs or radiation or immunotherapy, all
include the basic mechanism of programmed cell death or
apoptosis. Without apoptosis, there is practically no tumor
regression, none of any kind.
(35) Faragher EB,
Type A stress prone behaviour and breast cancer, Psychol Med,
1990 Aug;20(3):663-70
Department of Medical Statistics, University Hospital of South
Manchester, Withington.
This quasi-prospective study of 2163 women attending
breast-screening clinics (and controls), indicates that there is
a link between personality factors and breast disease. Certain
aspects of Type A behaviour seem to be associated with
breast-disease states.
(36) Dalton SO, Depression and cancer risk: a register-based study of patients hospitalized with affective disorders, Denmark, 1969-1993, American journal epidem., 2002 Jun 15;155(12):1088-95
(37) Bryla CM, The relationship between stress and the development of breast cancer: a literature review, Oncol Nurs Forum, 1996 Apr;23(3):441-8
(38) Saul AN,
Chronic stress and susceptibility to skin cancer, J natl cancer
inst, 2005 Dec 7;97(23):1760-7
http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/97/23/1760?ijkey=9c9216b7d06ed0474b50ec0632122cdca08f851f
BACKGROUND: Studies have shown
that chronic stress or UV radiation independently suppress
immunity. Given their increasing prevalence, it is important to
understand whether and how chronic stress and UV radiation may
act together to increase susceptibility to disease. Therefore, we
investigated potential mediators of a stress-induced increase in
emergence and progression of UV-induced squamous cell carcinoma.
METHODS: SKH1 mice susceptible to UV-induced tumors were
unexposed (naive, n = 4) or exposed (n = 16) to 2240 J/m2 of UVB
radiation three times a week for 10 weeks. Half of the
UVB-exposed mice were left nonstressed (i.e., they remained in
their home cages) and the other half were chronically stressed
(i.e., restrained during weeks 4-6). UV-induced tumors were
measured weekly from week 11 through week 34, blood was collected
at week 34, and tissues were collected at week 35. mRNA
expression of interleukin (IL)-12p40, interferon (IFN)-gamma,
IL-4, IL-10, CD3epsilon, and CCL27/CTACK, the skin T cell-homing
chemokine, in dorsal skin was quantified using real-time
polymerase chain reaction. CD4+, CD8+, and CD25+ leukocytes were
counted using immunohistochemistry and flow cytometry. All
statistical tests were two-sided. RESULTS: Stressed mice had a
shorter median time to first tumor (15 versus 16.5 weeks,
difference = 1.5 weeks, 95% confidence interval [CI] = -3.0 to
3.3 weeks; P = .03) and reached 50% incidence earlier than
controls (15 weeks versus 21 weeks). Stressed mice also had lower
IFN-gamma ( mean = 0.03 versus mean = 0.07, difference = 0.04,
95% CI = 0.004 to 0.073; P = .02), CCL27/CTACK (mean = 101 versus
mean = 142, difference = 41, 95% CI = 8.1 to 74.4; P = .03), and
CD3epsilon (mean = 0.18 versus mean = 0.36, difference = 0.18,
95% CI = 0.06 to 0.30; P = .007) gene expression and lower
numbers of infiltrating CD4+ cells (mean = 9.40 versus mean =
13.7, difference = 4.3, 95% CI = 2.36 to 6.32; P = .008) than
nonstressed mice. In addition, stressed mice had more
regulatory/suppressor CD25+ cells infiltrating tumors and more
CD4+ CD25+ cells in circulation (mean = 0.36 versus mean = 0.17,
difference = 0.19, 95% CI = 0.005 to 0.38; P = .03) than
nonstressed mice. CONCLUSIONS: Chronic stress increased
susceptibility to UV-induced squamous cell carcinoma in this
mouse model by suppressing type 1 cytokines and protective T
cells and increasing regulatory/suppressor T cell numbers.
(39) Baltrusch HJ, Stress, cancer and immunity. New developments in biopsychosocial and psychoneuroimmunologic research, acta neurol (Napoli), 1991 Aug;13(4):315-27
(40) Bleiker EM -
van der Ploeg, Psychosocial factors in the etiology of breast
cancer: review of a popular link, Pat Educ Couns, 1999
Jul;37(3):201-14
Breast cancer is the most frequently occurring type of cancer in
women in the western world. The etiology of a large proportion of
breast cancers is still unexplained, and the possibility that
psychosocial factors could play a role is not ruled out. Already
in pre-Christian times, it was assumed that psychological factors
might play a significant role in the development of breast
cancer. However, studies have failed to produce conclusive
results. There is still a lack of knowledge on the relationship
between breast cancer development and psychosocial factors such
as stressful life events, coping styles, depression, and the
ability to express emotions. The results of this review show that
there is not enough evidence that psychosocial factors
like 'ways of coping' or 'non-expression of negative emotions',
play a significant role in the etiology of breast cancer.
(41) Hilakivi-Clarke L, Psychosocial factors in the development and progression of breast cancer, breast cancer res treat, 1994 Feb;29(2):141-60
(42) Cooper CL, Psychosocial stress and breast cancer: the inter-relationship between stress events, coping strategies and personality, Psychol med 1993 Aug;23(3):653-62
(43) Fox BH, The role of psychological factors in cancer incidence and prognosis, Onclology (Williston Park), 1995 Mar;9(3):245-53
(44) Schüssler G
Schubert C, The influence of psychosocial factors on the immune
system (psychoneuroimmunology) and their role for the incidence
and progression of cancer, Z psychosom Med Psychother,
2001;47(1):6-41
Psychoneuroimmunological research investigates the
influence of psychosocial factors on the immune systems. We
reviewed clinical studies dealing with the following three
topics: life events, psychological/psychopathological factors and
social support, and their influence on cellular and humoral
immune activity. There is strong evidence that stressful life
events (especially losses) have a decreasing effect on immunity.
Depression has a similar effect and may be the mediator between
life events and the immune systems. Results dealing with the
influence of social support on immune functions are still
inconclusive. In the second part, we reviewed prospective studies
concerning the role of psychosocial factors on cancer incidence
and progression. Most of the life event studies reviewed have
methodological problems, thus the results are heterogenous. There
is some evidence that psychological/psychopathological factors
can promote cancer progression. This is even more obvious in case
of insufficient social support.
(45) Reynaert C,
Psychogenesis" of cancer: between myths, misuses and
reality. Bull Cancer, 2000 Sep;87(9):655-64
Summary : Since a long time, hypothesis of links between
psychological factors and cancer, have been established in our
culture. So far, numerous researches have tempted to indicate
stress, coping facing the disease, depression or "type
C" personality as factors participating to the onset and/or
the course of the cancer. A review of those studies, mainly
retrospective, has mostly brought debated results, as well as
prospective researches including large sample of population or
people awaiting a diagnosis; therefore making oldfashioned every
area strictly "psychogenetic" of cancer at first sight.
Explicative indirect hypothesis are suggested by the
psycho-neuro-endocrino-immunology. Various researches in this
field proved that external factors such as stress, depression or
social support have significative influences on components of the
immune system which in turn influence the onset and/or the course
of the cancer. The links between psychological factors and cancer
are extremely complex, bringing numerous biological,
psychological or even sociological systems in interactions. The
psycho-neuro-endocrino-immunology constitutes an early
interdisciplinary way of mediation, capable of account for the
connections between psychology and cancer.
(46) Jadoulle V, Cancer, a defect of the psyche?, Bull Cancer, 2004 Mar;91(3):249-56
(47) Spiegel D, Kato
PM, Psychosocial influences on cancer incidence and progression,
Harv rev psychiatry, 1996 May-Jun;4(1):10-26
The impact of psychosocial
factors on the incidence and progression of cancer has become an
area that demands attention. In this article recent evidence of
psychosocial effects on cancer incidence and progression is
reviewed in the context of past research. Psychosocial factors
discussed include personality, depression, emotional expression,
social support, and stress. Mechanisms that could mediate the
relationship between psychosocial conditions and cancer incidence
and progression are also reviewed. These include alterations in
diet, exercise, and circadian cycles; variations in medical
treatment received; and physiological mechanisms such as
psychoendocrinologic and psychoneuroimmunologic effects. We
conclude that there is a nonrandom relationship among various
psychosocial factors and cancer incidence and progression that
can only partially be explained by behavioral, structural, or
biological factors. Suggestions for future research are
discussed.
(48) Lambley P,
The role of psychological processes in the aetiology and
treatment of cervical cancer: a biopsychological perspective, Br
J Med Psychol, 1993 Mar;66 ( Pt 1):43-60
Cervical cancer is one of the
most serious illnesses affecting women today, particularly in
developing societies. Despite medical advances in treatment and
the success of cervical screening programmes in detection, the
incidence of the disease is increasing. In this paper it is
argued that one of the reasons for this is that the aetiological
model employed for cervical cancer takes little account of
psychological and psychophysiological factors. Both of these
factors are now thought to play important roles in disease
processes. Research in these areas is reviewed and a new
aetiological model for cervical cancer described. This model
incorporates existing epidemiological and medical formulations
into a new multifactor framework. The implications of this model
for treatment are explored and it is suggested that psychological
interventions could play a much greater role than they have in
the past.
(49) Cann - Van
Netten, Dr William Coley and tumour regression: a place in
history or in the future, Postgrad Med J, 2003 Dec 79 (938) 672
Spontaneous tumour regression
has followed bacterial, fungal, viral, and protozoal infections.
This phenomenon inspired the development of numerous rudimentary
cancer immunotherapies, with a history spanning thousands of
years. Coley took advantage of this natural phenomenon,
developing a killed bacterial vaccine for cancer in the late
1800s. He observed that inducing a fever was crucial for tumour
regression. Unfortunately, at the present time little credence is
given to the febrile response in fighting infections-no less
cancer. Rapidly growing tumours contain large numbers of
leucocytes. These cells play a part in both defence and repair;
however, reparative functions can also support tumour growth.
Intratumoural infections may reactivate defensive functions,
causing tumour regression. Can it be a coincidence that this
method of immunotherapy has been "rediscovered"
repeatedly throughout the centuries? Clearly, Coley's approach to
cancer treatment has a place in the past, present, and future. It
offers a rare opportunity for the development of a broadly
applicable, relatively inexpensive, yet effective treatment for
cancer. Even in cases beyond the reach of conventional therapy,
there is hope.
(50) Maunsell E, Stressful life events and survival
after breast cancer, Psychosom Med, 2001 Mar-Apr;63(2):306-15
http://www.psychosomaticmedicine.org/cgi/reprint/63/2/306?ijkey=c89eedfd5ea3b5021d6d4b83a3ccfe4539246efa
OBJECTIVE: This study assessed
the relation of stressful life events with survival after breast
cancer. METHODS: This study was based on women with
histologically confirmed, newly diagnosed, localized or regional
stage breast cancer first treated in 1 of 11 Quebec City (Canada)
hospitals from 1982 through 1984. Among 765 eligible patients,
673 (88%) were interviewed 3 to 6 months after diagnosis about
the number and perceived impact of stressful events in the 5
years before diagnosis. Three scores were calculated: number of
events; number weighted by reported impact; and for almost 80% of
events, number weighted by community-derived values reflecting
adjustment required by the event. Scores were divided into
quartiles to assess possible dose-response relationships.
Survival was assessed in 1993. Hazard ratios and 95% confidence
intervals (CIs) comparing all-cause and breast cancer-specific
mortality were calculated with adjustment for age, presence of
invaded axillary nodes, adjuvant radiotherapy, and systemic
therapy (ie, chemotherapy and hormone therapy). RESULTS: When
quartiles 2, 3, and 4 were compared with the appropriate lowest
quartile, adjusted hazard ratios for all-cause mortality were
0.99 (CI = 0.70-1.38), 0.97 (CI = 0.73-1.31), and 1.04 (CI =
0.78-1.40) for number, number weighted by impact, and number
weighted by community-derived values, respectively. Results were
essentially similar for the relation between stressful life
events limited to those occurring within the 12 months before
diagnosis and overall mortality and between stressful life events
in the 5 years before diagnosis and breast cancer-specific
mortality. CONCLUSIONS: Stress was conceptualized as life events
presumed to be negative, undesirable, or to require adjustment by
the person confronting them. We found no evidence indicating that
this kind of stress during the 5 years before diagnosis
negatively affected survival among women with nonmetastatic
breast cancer. Evidence from this study and others on the lack of
effect of this type of stress on survival may be reassuring for
women living with breast cancer.
(51) Protheroe D,
Stressful life events and difficulties and onset of breast
cancer: case-control study, BMJ, 1999 Oct 16;319(7216):1027-30
OBJECTIVE: To determine the
relation between stressful life events and difficulties and the
onset of breast cancer. DESIGN: Case-control study. SETTING: 3
NHS breast clinics serving west Leeds. Participants: 399
consecutive women, aged 40-79, attending the breast clinics who
were Leeds residents. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Odds ratios of the
risk of developing breast cancer after experiencing one or more
severe life events, severe difficulties, severe 2 year
non-personal health difficulties, or severe 2 year personal
health difficulties in the 5 years before clinical presentation.
RESULTS: 332 (83%) women participated. Women diagnosed with
breast cancer were no more likely to have experienced one or more
severe life events (adjusted odds ratio 0.91, 95% confidence
interval 0.47 to 1. 81; P=0.79); one or more severe difficulties
(0.86, 0.41 to 1.81; P=0.69); a 2 year severe non-personal health
difficulty (0.53, 0.12 to 2.31; P=0.4); or a 2 year severe
personal health difficulty (2.73, 0.68 to 10.93; P=0.16) than
women diagnosed with a benign breast lump. CONCLUSION: These
findings do not support the hypothesis that severe life events or
difficulties are associated with onset of breast cancer.
(52) Lillberg K,
Stress of daily activities and risk of breast cancer: a
prospective cohort study in Finland, int j cancer, 2001 Mar
15;91(6):888-93
The belief that life stress
enhances breast cancer is common, but there are few prospective
epidemiological studies on the relationship of life stress and
breast cancer. We have investigated the association between
stress of daily activities (SDA) and breast-cancer risk in a
prospective cohort study of 10,519 Finnish women aged 18 years or
more. SDA measures a subject's own appraisal of daily stress. It
was assessed in 1975 and 1981 by a self-administered
questionnaire, which also provided information on subject
characteristics and other known breast-cancer risk factors.
Follow-up data for breast cancer from 1976 to 1996 were attained
through record linkage to the Finnish Cancer Registry. Study
subjects were divided into 3 groups based on their SDA scores in
1975: no stress (23% of subjects), some stress (68%) and severe
stress (9%). Hazard ratios (HRs) and respective 95% confidence
intervals (CIs) for incidence of breast cancer by level of SDA
were obtained from the Cox proportional hazards model. We
identified 205 incident breast cancers in the cohort.
Multivariable-adjusted HRs for breast-cancer risk were 1.00
(reference), 1.11 (95% CI 0.78-1.57) and 0.96 (95% CI 0.53-1.73)
by increasing level of stress. Neither shifting of the SDA
cut-off points nor restricting the analysis to women who reported
the same level of SDA in 1975 and 1981 materially altered the
results. We found no evidence of an association between
self-perceived daily stress and breast-cancer risk.
(53) Duijts SF,
The association between stressful life events and breast cancer
risk: a meta-analysis, int j cancer, 2003 Dec 20;107(6):1023-9
Breast cancer is the most
prevalent cancer in women in Western societies. Studies examining
the relationship between stressful life events and breast cancer
risk have produced conflicting results. The purpose of this
meta-analysis was to identify studies on this relationship,
between 1966 and December 2002, to summarize and quantify the
association and to explain the inconsistency in previous results.
Summary odds ratios and standard errors were calculated, using
random effect meta-regression analyses, for the following
categories: stressful life events, death of spouse, death of
relative or friend, personal health difficulties, nonpersonal
health difficulties, change in marital status, change in
financial status and change in environmental status. The presence
of publication bias has been explored, and sensitivity analyses
were performed to identify heterogeneity, using calculation of
the percentage of variability due to heterogeneity,
meta-regression analyses and stratification. Only the categories
stressful life events (OR = 1.77, 95% CI 1.31-2.40), death of
spouse (OR = 1.37, 95% CI 1.10-1.71) and death of relative or
friend (OR = 1.35, 95% CI 1.09-1.68) showed a statistically
significant effect. Publication bias was identified in both
stressful life events (p = 0.00) and death of relative or friend
(p = 0.02). Sensitivity analyses resulted in the identification
of heterogeneity in all categories, except death of spouse. The
results of this meta-analysis do not support an overall
association between stressful life events and breast cancer risk.
Only a modest association could be identified between death of
spouse and breast cancer risk. Copyright 2003 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
(54) Chorot P,
Life events and stress reactivity as predictors of cancer,
coronary heart disease and anxiety disorders, int j psychosom,
1994;41(1-4):34-40
The topic relative to the
differential psychobiological mechanisms between cancer and
coronary illness has been showing for the last years. In this
sense, some theoretical models which have been formulated by
relevant authors have suggested the possibility of
differentiating cancer and cardiovascular disease, both the onset
and the progression, from coping strategies, personality
variables and affective states, as well as the different
categories of psychosocial stress. Likewise, the implication of
psychological distress, such as anxiety, anger and depression for
the occurrence of somatic disease has been reported frequently.
This research was designed to analyze the psychosocial patterns
which could explain the incidence of heart disease, cancer and
anxiety based disorders. Measures of life events and stress
reactivity were obtained from a total of 109 patients diagnosed
as having breast cancer (37), infarct (37), and anxiety (35), and
from 72 normal control subjects. Our data tend to show that the
cancer group was strongly predicted by lost and illness events,
while the coronary group was more associated with work events.
The anxiety disorders group lacked a life events dimension, but
shared the same category of the infarct group. We also found a
strong relationship between depressive reactions and cancer in
contrast to the anxiety-anger variable that was more relevant in
the infarct patients. The interaction between internal and
external stress factors in the etiology of disease is also
discussed.
(55) Byrnes DM,
Stressful events, pessimism, natural killer cell cytotoxicity,
and cytotoxic/suppressor T cells in HIV+ black women at risk for
cervical cancer, Psychosom Med, 1998 Nov-Dec;60(6):714-22
OBJECTIVE: This study examines
whether stressful negative life events and pessimism were
associated with lower natural killer cell cytotoxicity (NKCC) and
T cytotoxic/suppressor cell (CD8+CD3+) percentage in black women
co-infected with human immunodeficiency virus Type 1 (HIV-1) and
human papillomavirus (HPV), a viral initiator of cervical cancer.
METHOD: Psychosocial interviews, immunological evaluations, and
cervical swabs for HPV detection and subtyping were conducted on
36 HIV+ African-American, Haitian, and Caribbean women. RESULTS:
Greater pessimism was related to lower NKCC and
cytotoxic/suppressor cells after controlling for presence/absence
of HPV Types 16 or 18, behavioral/lifestyle factors, and
subjective impact of negative life events. CONCLUSIONS: A
pessimistic attitude may be associated with immune decrements,
and possibly poorer control over HPV infection and increased risk
for future promotion of cervical dysplasia to invasive cervical
cancer in HIV+ minority women co-infected with HPV.
(56) Jasmin C, Le MG, Marty P,
Herzberg R, Psycho-Oncologic between certain psychol Group.
Evidence for a linogical factors and the risk of breast cancer in
a case control study. Ann Oncol 1990;1:22-9
Unite d'Oncogenese Appliquee,
INSERM U 268, Hopital Paul Brousse, Villejuif, France
The relationship between psychosomatic characteristics and the
risk of breast cancer was studied in women aged from 35 to 65
years, presenting with a clinically palpable breast tumor. To
permit a double-blind design, the psychosomatic evaluation
obtained by a long open-ended interview was completed before any
diagnostic procedure. On the basis of this evaluation, the
psychosomatician concluded that the patient was at high or low
risk of serious disease. Several other psychological parameters
were also recorded, and the diagnosis was then established by
cytology or histology. Nineteen of the 77 patients finally
included in the study had histologically verified breast cancer.
The relative risk (RR) of breast cancer associated with
psychosomatic factors was estimated by multivariate unconditional
logistic regression, taking into account age at interview, family
history of breast cancer, parity and age at first delivery. A
significant relationship (p = 0.02) was found between
psychosomatic prognosis and the relative risk of breast cancer.
Both the low and high risk groups identified by the
psychosomaticians had a similar mean age (46.1 versus 47.6
years). Fundamental mental structure played a predominant role in
the risk of breast cancer, since no case was observed among the
18 patients with well organized neurosis, and all the 19
malignant tumors were observed among patients with poorly
organized neurosis or psychosis (RR = 7.8, p = 0.009). In
addition, excessive self-esteem (RR = 10.0, p = 0.02), hysterical
disposition (RR = 7.5, p = 0.02), and unresolved recent grief (RR
= 8.2, p = 0.05), were found to be significantly related to the
risk of breast cancer....
(57) Scherg H,
Psychosocial factors and disease bias in breast cancer patients,
Psychosom Ned, 1987 May-Jun;49(3):302-12
The personality patterns of
cancer patients as found in retrospective case-control studies
are often suspected to be consequences of the disease. In this
study an attempt was made to remove the bias arising from the
disease itself by taking into account two indicator variables for
the subject's anticipation of the subsequently established
diagnosis. Seventy-five women with breast cancer were compared to
75 benign controls, matched in pairs for age and "reason for
consultation" (the first indicator). Relative risks of 14
psychosocial scales were estimated in turn by logistic regression
analysis for matched sets. The analysis showed 13 scales being
positively or negatively related to cancer risk in accordance
with the hypotheses. After adjusting for "fear of breast
cancer" (the second indicator), five scales showed a
significant association. In a previous report on this study,
neither indicator variable was accounted for and the associations
were generally found to be weaker, suggesting that they were
masked by the malignant and benign subjects' differences in their
degree of anticipation of a cancer diagnosis. As there were no a
priori hypotheses regarding these indicator variables, the
statistical significance of the results should be treated with
caution.
(58) Denz MD,
Psychosocial aspects of malignant melanoma, Ther Umschau, 1999
Jun;56(6):342-7
Psychosocial aspects play a
role in every stage of malignant melanoma: they are significant
in terms of sun exposure habits (primary prevention) and have an
important influence on the time lapse between the onset of
malignant melanoma and its diagnosis (secondary prevention).
Knowledge about psychosocial aspects is also necessary during the
course of illness following primary treatment as during this
phase patients make critical efforts in understanding and
adapting to their illness. These efforts in turn interact with
treatment measures and the course of the illness (tertiary
prevention). Effective psychosocial interventions are available
that can have an important impact on patients' quality of life.
Stage-appropriate disease management requires knowledge of
relevant psychosocial aspects during the course of cancer and has
practical consequences not only for future prevention measures,
but also for individual patients, physician-patient relationship
and interdisciplinary patient care.
(59) Garssen B,
On the role of immunological factors as mediators between
psychosocial factors and cancer progression, psychiatry res, 1999
Jan 18;85(1):51-61
Thirty-eight prospective
studies on the role of psychological factors in cancer initiation
and progression are reviewed. Despite the availability of many
prospective studies, there is no certainty about the role of any
specific factor. An important reason might be that the
interactions among several psychological factors, and the
interactions of psychological and biomedical risk factors, have
rarely been studied. Some evidence has been found that a low
level of social support, a tendency towards helplessness, and
repression of negative emotions are factors that promote cancer
progression. The effect of psychological factors has been more
convincingly demonstrated with respect to cancer progression than
cancer initiation, and more convincingly in intervention than in
natural history studies. Possible mechanisms mediating
associations between psychological factors and disease outcome
are discussed. The role of immunosurveillance seems modest
overall, and alternative pathways are suggested.
(60)
Kiekolt-Glaser JK, Psychoneuroimmunology and cancer: fact or
fiction? Eur j cancer, 1999 Oct;35(11):1603-7
There is substantial evidence
from both healthy populations as well as individuals with cancer
linking psychological stress with immune downregulation. This
discussion highlights natural killer (NK) cells, because of the
role that they may play in malignant disease. In addition,
distress or depression is also associated with two important
processes for carcinogenesis: poorer repair of damaged DNA, and
alterations in apoptosis. Conversely, the possibility that
psychological interventions may enhance immune function and
survival among cancer patients clearly merits further
exploration, as does the evidence suggesting that social support
may be a key psychological mediator. These studies and others
suggest that psychological or behavioural factors may influence
the incidence or progression of cancer through psychosocial
influences on immune function and other physiological pathways.
(61) Goodkin K,
Stress and hopelessness in the promotion of cervical
intraepithelial neoplasia to invasive squamous cell carcinoma of
the cervix, J Pychosom Res, 1986;30(1):67-76
Stress and hopelessness have
been associated with the development of invasive cervical cancer
by previous research. Subjects in this study were recruited from
a colposcopy clinic awaiting work-up of an abnormal pap smear and
from those admitted to an in-patient gynecology ward for cone
biopsy of the cervix or hysterectomy to treat a symptomatic
pelvic mass thought to be uterine leiomyomas. After data
collection, pathology reports and colposcopic findings were used
to determine group assignment independent of subjects' knowledge
of their diagnosis. A modest stress-promotion correlation was
derived, which was greatly enhanced by significant interactions
with low levels of cooperative coping style and for high levels
of premorbid pessimism, future despair, somatic anxiety, and life
threat reactivity. These stress-moderator interactions are
discussed in terms of immune system deficit with concomitant
enhancement of promotion of CIN to invasive squamous cell
cervical cancer.
(62) http://www.corriere.it/corrforum/corriere/Thread?forumid=256&postid=480520
(63) Cole WH,
Spontaneous regression of cancer and the importance of finding
its cause, Natl Cancer Inst Monogr, 1976 Nov, 44
A few years ago Everson and I assembled all the examples of
spontaneous regression in the world medical literature from 1900
to 1960 and added numerous cases from expriences of our friends.
Our figure was 176. We excluded squamous cell carcinoma of the
skin, leukemia, Hodgkin's disease, and a large number of cases
that did not fulfill the prerequisites of confirmed diagnosis and
no significant treatment. The four most common examples of
regression were carcinoma of the kidney (31), neuroblastoma (29),
malignant melanoma (19), and choriocarcinoma (19); these
constituted more than half the group. We did not require that the
regression be permanent because it appeared that the explanation
of temporary regression would be just as important as the cause
of permanent regression. There was no proven specific cause of
the regression, but the following mechanisms had a possible
relationship: immunologic action, elimination of carcinogens,
trauma (altering the antigen-antibody relationship), hormones,
irradiation, infection and/or fever, and drugs or chemicals. The
most applicable of these is elimination of the carcinogen.
Immunologic reactions seem to offer the best explanation, and the
potential of humoral immunity is more impressive than that of
cellular immunity.
(64) Rohdenburg, Fluctuations in the growth energy of tumors in man, with esspecial reference to spontaneous recession, 1918 J Cancer Res 1918;3:193-225
(65) Nauts HC, The beneficial effects of bacterial infections on host resistance to cancer, cancer res int 1980
(67) Cole WH, Relationship of
causative factors in spontaneous regression of cancer to
immunologic factors possibly effective in cancer, J Surg Oncol,
1976 8 (5) 391
In a book written by Everson and Cole (1966) on spontaneous
regression 176 examples of the phenomenon were encountered in the
medical literature from 1900 to 1964, supplemented by cases
referred by friends. No common denominator of explanations were
found. Various types of trauma (e.g., biopsy, incomplete
excision), transfusions, infection, hormone changes, drugs, etc.
were encountered as possible causative factors. Most significant
of all factors was encountered in the 13 examples of spontaneous
regression of the bladder; in this series regression of the tumor
occurred in 10 after transplantation of the ureters out of the
bladder. A consideration and discussion of various reactions in
human beings associated with therapeutic regressions have been
reviewed hoping to develop a correlation between the two types of
regression. At the time of publication of our monograph 9 years
ago we were unable to suggest any mechanisms which might explain
the regressions. However, since that time so many advances have
been made in immunology that it appears now that a stimulation of
the immune process might explain most of the regressions. We are
just beginning to learn a few methods of stimulating the immune
process. Use of BCG is one of the best examples of this
stimulating process; other bacterial agents, or fractions, are
known to have this action. No doubt there are innumerable others
unknown, some of which might explain spontaneous regressions. It
would appear that hormonal changes might be responsible for many
of the regressions but this author doubts it explains many. More
is known at the present time about cellular immunity than humoral
immunity, but greater possibilities surely lie in humoral
immunity. The blocking and unblocking activities developed by the
Hellstroms and associates are no doubt important. Immunoglobulins
exert a very important role in the immune process; antibodies may
consist of immunoglobulins but much more needs to be known before
this relationship can be understood. The recent report (Amery,
1975) that levamisole (given at the time of resection of the lung
for carcinoma) improves patient survival is exciting. Amery
believes the drug may prevent the hematogenous spread of the
tumor during surgery and/or may decrease the immunosuppression
caused by a major operation.
(68) Cole WH - Everson TC:
Spontaneous Regression of Cancer (WB Saunders, Philadelphia, PA)
1966
(69) Challis GB, The spontaneous
regression of cancer. A review of cases from 1900 to 1987, Acta
Oncol, 1990 29 (5) 545,
The literature on the spontaneous regression of cancer is
reviewed from 1966 to 1987 to update reviews by Everson &
Cole and by Boyd. These authors reviewed all cases of spontaneous
regression from 1900 to 1965. We then report the entire series
from 1900 to 1987. We also attempted to determine what
attributions for spontaneous regressions have been reported.
Although almost half of the authors failed to speculate or
specify a possible cause for the spontaneous regression, the
remainder postulated responsible factors such as immunological or
endocrine, surgical, necrosis, infection, or operative trauma.
The only unorthodox treatment to appear in the literature was the
psychological. We conclude that the literature on the spontaneous
regression of cancer is still unable to provide unambiguous
accounts of the mechanisms operating to affect these regressions.
(70) Shekelle R, Pschological depression and 17-year risk of death from cancer. 1981, Psychosom Med 43 p.117
(71) Antoni MH, Host moderator
variables in the promotion of cervical neoplasia--II. Dimensions
of life stress, J Psychosom Res, 1989;33(4):457-67
Controllability and
predictability have been shown to mediate the aversive impact of
life events on health. This study examined the relationship of
these parameters (along with coping style) to the promotion of
cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) to invasive squamous
cell carcinoma of the cervix. Seventy-five female patients
participated while awaiting the results of colposcopically
directed biopsy performed during work-up of an abnormal Pap
smear. The Million Behavioral Health Inventory, a modified form
of the Life Experience Survey, and a semi-structured interview
were administered before subjects learned of their biopsy
results. Subjects defined as susceptible by previous research had
positive (through generally nonsignificant) correlations between
life events and promotion while resilient subjects had negative
correlations. The relationship between controllability of life
events and CIN was moderated beneficially by a sociable and
confident style and detrimentally by an inhibited style and a
pessimistic attitude. Life event predictability did not
contribute to CIN promotion beyond the effects of
controllability.
(72) Faller H, cancer
personality" attribution--an expression of maladaptive
coping with illness?, Z Klin Psychol Psychiatr Psychother, 1996
44(1) 104
In psycho-oncology, the
concept of a "cancer-prone personality" has gained some
attention. This notion means that persons who try to stay
pseudo-normal in spite of severe life stress, suppress negative
emotions, particularly anger, and sacrifice themselves for other
people without uttering any personal demands, are at a high risk
to develop cancer. However, it has been demonstrated by previous
research that features of the cancer-prone personality could only
be found if the ill person was convinced to suffer from cancer,
irrespective of what the factual diagnosis was. Thus it can be
concluded that at least some aspects of the so called cancer
personality might be the results of coping with the belief of
having cancer. The present study had the objective to describe
causal attributions to psychosocial factors in cancer patients,
and to find out if these were connected with emotional state and
coping. N = 120 newly diagnosed lung cancer patients were
included in the study. The instruments consisted of a
semi-structured interview, a check-list of subjective causal
factors, self-reports and interviewer ratings on emotional state
and standardised questionnaires about depression and coping.
Patients who made a psychosocial causal attribution proved to
suffer from greater emotional distress, to be more depressed and
less hopeful than other patients. This difference seemed to be
mediated by a depressive way of coping with the illness
(brooding, wrangling). Thus, an attribution of the illness to
psychological factors seems indicative of a maladaptive way of
coping with illness. This result is supported by similar findings
of previous research. The question is put up to discussion if the
psychosomatic concept of a cancer personality may reflect
patients' subjective theories which in turn may be the expression
of their depressive coping modes.
(73) Petticrew M, Cancer-stress link: the truth, 1999 Nurs Times Mar 3-9 95
(74) Faller H, Prognostic value of
depressive coping and depression in survival of lung cancer
patients, Psychooncology 2004 May 13 (5) 359
The aim of this investigation was to determine whether depressive
coping and depression predict shorter survival among lung cancer
patients. We conducted a prospective study using an inception
cohort with a 3-5-year follow-up. The sample consisted of n = 59
(of n = 69 invited to participate) patients (mean age 65 years,
S.D. = 9.7; 81% male) newly diagnosed with small cell lung cancer
or non-small cell lung cancer Stage III or IV who were scheduled
for later chemotherapy and/or radiotherapy at a tertiary care
centre. Patients were investigated after their diagnosis and
before the beginning of treatment. Depressive coping and
depression were assessed using standardized self-report
questionnaires (Freiburg Questionnaire of Coping with Illness;
Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale). Depressive coping was
associated with shorter survival (hazard ratio 1.75, 95%
confidence interval 1.04-2.93, p = 0.034) after adjusting for
age, sex, stage, histological classification, and Karnofsky
performance status but not treatment type, using the Cox
proportional hazards regression. Depression, however, was not
linked with survival (hazard ratio 1.05, 95% confidence interval
0.98-1.13, p = 0.18). To conclude, the prognostic value of
depressive coping was partially confirmed, warranting further
examination of the robustness of this relationship.
(75) Wulsin LR, A systematic
review of the mortality of depression, Psychosom Med, 1999 Jan 61
(1) 18,
OBJECTIVE: The literature on the mortality of depression was
assessed with respect to five issues: 1) strength of evidence for
increased mortality, 2) controlling for mediating factors, 3) the
contribution of suicide, 4) variation across sample types, and 5)
possible mechanisms. METHOD: All relevant English language
databases from 1966 to 1996 were searched for reviews and studies
that included 1) a formal assessment of depressive symptoms or
disorders, 2) death rates or risks, and 3) an appropriate
comparison group. RESULTS: There were 57 studies found; 29 (51%)
were positive, 13 (23%) negative, and 15 (26%) mixed. Twenty-one
studies (37%) ranked among the better studies on the strength of
evidence scale used in this study, but there are too few
comparable, well-controlled studies to provide a sound estimate
of the mortality risk associated with depression. Only six
studies controlled for more than one of the four major mediating
factors. Suicide accounted for less than 20% of the deaths in
psychiatric samples, and less than 1% in medical and community
samples. Depression seems to increase the risk of death by
cardiovascular disease, especially in men, but depression does
not seem to increase the risk of death by cancer. Variability in
methods prevents a more rigorous meta-analysis of risk.
CONCLUSION: The studies linking depression to early death are
poorly controlled, but they suggest that depression substantially
increases the risk of death, especially death by unnatural causes
and cardiovascular disease. Future well-controlled studies of
high risk groups may guide efforts to develop treatments that
reduce the mortality risk of depression.
(76) Tschuschke el al,
Associations between coping and survival time of adult leukemia
patients receiving allogeneic bone marrow transplantation:
results of a prospective study, J Psychosom Res 2001 50, 277
BACKGROUND: To investigate associations between coping strategies
and length of survival in a sample of 52 adult leukemia patients
receiving allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). METHODS:
52 adult patients, diagnosed with acute (AML) and chronic myeloid
leukemia (CML) admitted for allogeneic BMT to a university
hospital BMT unit in preparation for a transplantation of
genotypically matched HLA donor marrow, were interviewed
immediately after informed consent and prior to preparatory
treatment for transplantation. Semistructured interviews were
conducted and recorded for analysis to assess coping styles and
were evaluated by a new content analytic coping measure [Ulm
Coping Manual (UCM)]. Patients were a random sample of all
eligible patients on the BMT unit between May 1990 and May 1994.
RESULTS: Complete audiotaped interviews were rated by blind
raters, employing a newly developed content analysis for the
identification of patients' coping strategies. Multivariate
analysis using a Cox model revealed three pretransplant variables
that demonstrated a statistically significant influence on 5-year
survival: Stage of Disease at transplant (P < .012),
Distraction (P < .007), and Fighting Spirit as coping
modalities (P < .013). CONCLUSIONS: The results of this
prospective study document the impact of certain psychological
variables, notably coping style on survival with BMT. This
suggests the necessity of utilizing psychosocial interventions to
address stress and anxiety in patients awaiting transplantation
in order to reduce anxieties and to employ more effective coping
techniques to deal more appropriately with their situation and to
enhance Fighting Spirit. The effects on survival of such
psychosocial interventions need to be tested in a randomized
controlled study.
(77) Faller H, Causal attribution
and adaptation among lung cancer patients, J Psychosom Res, 1995
38 (5) 619,
The aim of the present study
was to describe lung cancer patients' causal attributions and
examine their associations with adaptation. Methods were based on
semi-structured interview, content analysis, self-reports,
interviewer ratings and standardized questionnaires. 'Smoking
cigarettes' and 'toxins in the work place' were the most commonly
mentioned possible causes. Patients who made a psychosocial
causal attribution suffered greater emotional distress, were more
depressed, and less hopeful than other patients. They were also
more likely to be rated as showing a maladaptive way of coping
with illness. The implications of these findings for psychosocial
care are discussed.
(78) Helgesson O, Self-reported
stress levels predict subsequent breast cancer in a cohort of
Swedish women, Eur J Cancer Prev, 2003 12(5) 377,
The association between stress and breast cancer has been
studied, mostly using case-control designs, but rarely examined
prospectively. The purpose of this paper is to describe the role
of stress as a predictor of subsequent breast cancer. A
representative cohort of 1,462 Swedish women aged 38-60 years
were followed for 24 years. Stress experience at a baseline
examination in 1968-69 was analysed in relation to incidence of
breast cancer with proportional hazards regression. Women
reporting experience of stress during the five years preceding
the first examination displayed a two-fold rate of breast cancer
compared with women reporting no stress (age-adjusted relative
risk 2.1; 95% CI [1.2-3.7]). This association was independent of
potential confounders including reproductive and lifestyle
factors. In conclusion, the significant, positive relationship
between stress and breast cancer in this prospective study is
based on information that is unbiased with respect to knowledge
of disease, and can be regarded as more valid than results drawn
from case-control studies.
(79) Nielsen NR, Self reported
stress and risk of breast cancer: prospective cohort study, BMJ
2005 sept 10 331(7516)
OBJECTIVE: To assess the relation between self reported intensity
and frequency of stress and first time incidence of primary
breast cancer. DESIGN: Prospective cohort study with 18 years of
follow-up. SETTING: Copenhagen City heart study, Denmark.
PARTICIPANTS: The 6689 women participating in the Copenhagen City
heart study were asked about their perceived level of stress at
baseline in 1981-3. These women were followed until 1999 in the
Danish nationwide cancer registry, with < 0.1% loss to
follow-up. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: First time incidence of primary
breast cancer. RESULTS: During follow-up 251 women were diagnosed
with breast cancer. After adjustment for confounders, women with
high levels of stress had a hazard ratio of 0.60 (95% confidence
interval 0.37 to 0.97) for breast cancer compared with women with
low levels of stress. Furthermore, for each increase in stress
level on a six point stress scale an 8% lower risk of primary
breast cancer was found (hazard ratio 0.92, 0.85 to 0.99). This
association seemed to be stable over time and was particularly
pronounced in women receiving hormone therapy. CONCLUSION: High
endogenous concentrations of oestrogen are a known risk factor
for breast cancer, and impairment of oestrogen synthesis induced
by chronic stress may explain a lower incidence of breast cancer
in women with high stress. Impairment of normal body function
should not, however, be considered a healthy response, and the
cumulative health consequences of stress may be disadvantageous.
(80) Greer S, Psychological
response to breast cancer: effect on outcome, Lancet 1979 oct
13(2)
A prospective, multidisciplinary, 5-year study of 69 consecutive
female patients with early (T0,1N0,1M0) breast cancer was
conducted. Patients' psychological responses to the diagnosis of
cancer were assessed 3 months postoperatively. These responses
were related to outcome 5 years after operation. Recurrence-free
survival was significantly common among patients who had
initially reacted to cancer by denial or who had a fighting
spirit than among patients who had responded with stoic
acceptance or feelings of helplessness and hopelessness.
(81) Hislop TG, The prognostic
significance of psychosocial factors in women with breast cancer,
Chron Dis 1987 40(7) 729,
One hundred and thirty three recently diagnosed breast cancer
patients completed a self-administered questionnaire which
measured 16 psychosocial variables. After 4 years, three
variables (expressive activities at home, extroversion, low
anger) were significant prognostic factors for overall survival
independent of clinical and other psychosocial factors; likewise
three variables (expressive activities at home, expressive
activities away from home, low cognitive disturbance) were
significant independent prognostic factors for disease-free
survival. These findings support the prognostic importance of the
social emotional network.
(82) Buddeberg C, Are coping
strategies related to disease outcome in early breast cancer? J
Psychosom Res 1996 mar 40(3) 255,
A consecutive series of 107
women with early breast cancer were investigated for coping
strategies and disease outcome 5 to 6 years after primary
surgical treatment (mastectomy or lumpectomy). Coping was
assessed several times during a 3-year investigation period by
the Zurich and Freiburg Questionnaires of Coping with Illness
(ZQCI, FQCI). Data analysis revealed no significant correlations
between coping strategies and the target variable "death
from breast cancer". However, significant relations were
found between postsurgical tumour size (p < or = 0.01),
positive histological node status (p < or = 0.01) and death
from breast cancer. The results of a discriminant analysis also
indicated that somatic parameters are more important for the
course of breast cancer disease than psychological aspects of
coping. The role of psychosocial variables for the outcome of
cancer disease remains unclear and further studies in this field
are necessary.
(83) Giraldi T, Psychosocial
factors and breast cancer: a 6-year Italian follow-up study,
Psychother Psychosom 1997 66(5) 229,
BACKGROUND: Over the last 20 years contradictory results have
been obtained as regards to the role of psychosocial factors in
favouring the onset of breast cancer and/or in influencing
disease progression. METHODS: The present study prospectively
investigated the association between psychosocial variables and
breast cancer in 95 out-patients. Within 3 months from the
diagnosis the patients completed a series of questionnaires to
evaluate psychological disturbances, emotional repression,
adjustment to cancer, social support and occurrence of life
events in the past. At a distance of 6 years from the first
assessment, the patients' charts were re-examined in order to
evaluate the course of cancer. RESULTS: A higher volume of
primary tumour at surgery was shown in patients who had had
stressful events in the 6 months preceding cancer diagnosis. At
follow-up, no relationship was found between psychosocial
variables and the course of disease. The analysis of the
frequency of relapses and deaths, and the survival analysis
indicated that positivity of loco-regional lymph nodes,
infiltrating histotype of the tumour and tumour stage were the
only significant predictors of the time of death. CONCLUSIONS:
The study suggests that clinical and biological rather than
psychosocial factors exert a major role in breast cancer
progression.
(84) Watson M, Influence of psychological response on survival in breast cancer: a population-based cohort study, Lancet, 1999 Oct 16;354(9187):1331-6, BACKGROUND: The psychological response to breast cancer, such as a fighting spirit or an attitude of helplessness and hopelessness toward the disease, has been suggested as a prognostic factor with an influence on survival. We have investigated the effect of psychological response on disease outcome in a large cohort of women with early-stage breast cancer. METHODS: 578 women with early-stage breast cancer were enrolled in a prospective survival study. Psychological response was measured by the mental adjustment to cancer (MAC) scale, the Courtauld emotional control (CEC) scale, and the hospital anxiety and depression (HAD) scale 4-12 weeks and 12 months after diagnosis. The women were followed up for at least 5 years. Cox's proportional-hazards regression was used to obtain the hazard ratios for the measures of psychological response, with adjustment for known clinical factors associated with survival. FINDINGS: At 5 years, 395 women were alive and without relapse, 50 were alive with relapse, and 133 had died. There was a significantly increased risk of death from all causes by 5 years in women with a high score on the HAD scale category of depression (hazard ratio 3.59 [95% CI 1.39-9.24]). There was a significantly increased risk of relapse or death at 5 years in women with high scores on the helplessness and hopelessness category of the MAC scale compared with those with a low score in this category (1.55 [1.07-2.25]). There were no significant results found for the category of "fighting spirit". INTERPRETATION: For 5-year event-free survival a high helplessness/hopelessness score has a moderate but detrimental effect. A high score for depression is linked to a significantly reduced chance of survival; however, this result is based on a small number of patients and should be interpreted with caution.
(85) Reynolds P, Use of coping
strategies and breast cancer survival: results from the
Black/White Cancer Survival Study, Am J Epidemiol 2000 nov 15
152(10) 940,
This analysis was designed to evaluate the association between
coping strategies and breast cancer survival among Black and
White women in a large population-based study. A total of 442
Black and 405 White US women diagnosed with invasive breast
cancer during 1985-1986 and actively followed for survival
through 1994 were administered a modified Folkman and Lazarus
Ways of Coping questionnaire. Coping strategies were
characterized via factor analyses of the responses. Hazard ratios
associated with coping strategies were estimated using Cox
proportional hazards models, with adjustment for age, race, tumor
stage, study location, tumor hormone responsiveness, comorbidity,
health insurance status, smoking, relative body weight, and
alcohol consumption. Emotion-focused coping strategies were
significantly associated with survival. Expression of emotion was
associated with better survival (hazard ratio = 0.6; 95%
confidence interval: 0.4, 0.9). When it was considered jointly
with the presence or absence of perceived emotional support,
women reporting low levels of both emotional expression and
perceived emotional support experienced poorer survival than
women reporting high levels of both (hazard ratio = 2.5; 95%
confidence interval: 1.7, 3.7). Similar risk relations were
evident for Blacks and Whites and for patients with early and
late stage disease. These results suggest that the opportunity
for emotional expression may help improve survival among patients
with invasive breast cancer.
(86) Goodwin PJ, The effect of
group psychosocial support on survival in metastatic breast
cancer, NEJM, 2001 Dec 13;345(24):1719-26
BACKGROUND: Supportive-expressive group therapy has been reported
to prolong survival among women with metastatic breast cancer.
However, in recent studies, various psychosocial interventions
have not prolonged survival. METHODS: In a multicenter trial, we
randomly assigned 235 women with metastatic breast cancer who
were expected to survive at least three months in a 2:1 ratio to
an intervention group that participated in weekly
supportive-expressive group therapy (158 women) or to a control
group that received no such intervention (77 women). All the
women received educational materials and any medical or
psychosocial care that was deemed necessary. The primary outcome
was survival; psychosocial function was assessed by self-reported
questionnaires. RESULTS: Women assigned to supportive-expressive
therapy had greater improvement in psychological symptoms and
reported less pain (P=0.04) than women in the control group. A
significant interaction of treatment-group assignment with
base-line psychological score was found (P</=0.003 for the
comparison of mood variables; P=0.04 for the comparison of pain);
women who were more distressed benefited, whereas those who were
less distressed did not. The psychological intervention did not
prolong survival (median survival, 17.9 months in the
intervention group and 17.6 months in the control group; hazard
ratio for death according to the univariate analysis, 1.06 [95
percent confidence interval, 0.78 to 1.45]; hazard ratio
according to the multivariate analysis, 1.23 [95 percent
confidence interval, 0.88 to 1.72]). CONCLUSIONS:
Supportive-expressive group therapy does not prolong
survival in women with metastatic breast cancer. It
improves mood and the perception of pain, particularly in women
who are initially more distressed.
(87) Goodwin PJ, Health-related
quality of life and psychosocial status in breast cancer
prognosis: analysis of multiple variables, J Clin Oncol 2004 oct
15 22(20),
PURPOSE: Evidence that psychosocial status and health-related
quality of life (HRQOL) are associated with breast cancer (BC)
outcomes is weak and inconsistent. We examined prognostic effects
of these factors in a prospective cohort study. PATIENTS AND
METHODS: Three hundred ninety-seven women with surgically
resected T1 to T3, N0/N1, M0 BC completed the European
Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life
Questionnaire (Core 30 items), Profile of Mood States,
Psychosocial Adjustment to Illness Scale, Impact of Events Scale,
Mental Adjustment to Cancer Scale, and the Courtauld Emotional
Control Scale 2 months after diagnosis and 1 year later. Data on
tumor-related factors, treatment, and outcomes were obtained
prospectively from medical records, and Cox survival analyses
were performed. RESULTS: Mean age was 52.0 +/- 9.9 years. Two
hundred twenty-five women had T1, 136 women had T2, 16 women had
T3, and 20 women had TX tumors; 127 were N1. One hundred thirteen
women received adjuvant chemotherapy, 130 received hormone
therapy, 45 received both, and 109 received neither. We
investigated 140 prognostic associations; four were found to be
statistically significant at a P value of </= .05 (three fewer
than expected by chance). Two were in the hypothesized direction
of effect, and two were in the opposite direction. All arose from
measurements 1 year after diagnosis, which were most susceptible
to confounding by treatment. There was no evidence of consistency
of associations across outcomes or questionnaires. These results
are in keeping with chance as the explanation for our
statistically significant findings. CONCLUSION: HRQOL and
psychosocial status at diagnosis and 1 year later are not
associated with medical outcome in women with early-stage BC.
(88) Spiegel D, Effect of
psychosocial treatment on survival of patients with metastatic
breast cancer, Lancet, 1989 Oct 14;2(8668):888-91
The effect of psychosocial intervention on time of survival of 86
patients with metastatic breast cancer was studied prospectively.
The 1 year intervention consisted of weekly supportive group
therapy with self-hypnosis for pain. Both the treatment (n = 50)
and control groups (n = 36) had routine oncological care. At 10
year follow-up, only 3 of the patients were alive, and death
records were obtained for the other 83. Survival from time of
randomisation and onset of intervention was a mean 36.6 (SD 37.6)
months in the intervention group compared with 18.9 (10.8) months
in the control group, a significant difference. Survival plots
indicated that divergence in survival began at 20 months after
entry, or 8 months after intervention ended.
(90) Kissen DM Eysenck HJ, Personality in male lung cancer patients, J Psychosom Res, 1962 apr-june 6 123
(91) Kroenke CH, Caregiving
stress, endogenous sex steroid hormone levels, and breast cancer
incidence, Am J Epidemiol 2004 june 1 159(11) 1019,
Stress is hypothesized to be a risk factor for breast cancer. The
authors examined associations of hours of, and self-reported
levels of stress from, informal caregiving with prospective
breast cancer incidence. Cross-sectional analyses of caregiving
and endogenous sex steroid hormones were also conducted. In 1992
or 1996, 69,886 US women from the Nurses' Health Study, aged
46-71 years at baseline, answered questions on informal
caregiving; 1,700 incident breast cancer cases accrued over
follow-up to 2000. A subset of 665 postmenopausal women not
taking exogenous hormones returned a blood sample in 1990.
Numbers of hours of care provided to an ill adult or to a child
were each summed and analyzed as 0 (reference), 1-14, and
>/=15 per week. Cox proportional hazards models were used in
prospective analyses and linear models in cross-sectional
analyses. High numbers of caregiving hours and self-reported
stress did not predict a higher incidence of breast cancer.
However, compared with women providing no adult care, women
providing >/=15 hours of adult care (median, 54) had
significantly lower levels of estradiol (geometric mean, 9.21
pg/ml vs. 7.46 pg/ml (95% confidence interval: 6.36, 8.76)) and
bioavailable estradiol (geometric mean, 1.86 pg/ml vs. 1.35 pg/ml
(95% confidence interval: 1.00, 1.82)). Stress from caregiving
did not appear to increase breast cancer risk.
(92) Kvikstad A, Widowhood and
divorce in relation to overall survival among middle-aged
Norwegian women with cancer, Br J Cancer 1995 june 71(6) 1343,
The aim of the study was to examine the relations between
widowhood and divorce and overall survival among women with
cancer. All Norwegian women born between 1935 and 1954, and
diagnosed with cancer between 1966 and 1990, were followed up
until 1991. In all, 14,231 cases were followed up for a median
length of approximately 4.5 years (mean = 6 years), and 4311
women died during follow-up. In addition to overall cancer,
separate analyses have been made for cancer at specific sites.
Widows had a risk of dying which was nearly identical to that of
married women for all sites except colorectal cancer, for which
widows had a 2-fold increased death rate compared with married
women. Divorced women had an overall increased hazard ratio of
1.17 (95% CI 1.07-1.27), which was confined to cancer of the
breast, lung and cervix. With few clear exceptions women with
children had a better survival than nulliparous women (overall
hazard ratio = 0.80, 95% CI 0.74-0.87).
(93) Kvikstad A, Risk and
prognosis of cancer in middle-aged women who have experienced the
death of a child. Int J Cancer, 1996 july 17 67(2) 165,
First, we studied the relative risk of cancer among women born
between 1935 and 1954 who had experienced a child's death,
compared with women without this experience. Second, we examined
whether survival was any different between cancer patients in the
2 groups. The study was a population-based nested case-control
study that included 14,669 cancer cases and 29,750 age-matched
controls. The women who were included as incident cases were
further analyzed using Cox regression in a study of total
survival. The overall relative risk of cancer among women who had
lost a child was nearly identical to that of women who had not
lost a child (OR = 0.96, 95% confidence interval 0.87-1.07),
after adjustment for age and parity. In the analysis of specific
cancer sites, there was no difference in relative risk between
the 2 groups. In relation to cancer survival, we found that
patients who had lost a child had an overall risk of dying that
was nearly identical to patients who had not had this experience
(HR = 1.08, 95% confidence interval 0.92-1.26), after adjustment
for age and stage at diagnosis. For specific sites of cancer, the
results also showed no difference in survival between the 2
groups. In conclusion, risk and survival of cancer were not
different among women who had experienced the death of a child
from the risk and survival among women without this experience.
(94) Wirsching M, Prebioptic psychological characteristics of breast cancer patients, Psychother Psychosom, 1985 43(2) 69-76, 63 women were examined the day before breast biopsy using psychological ratings, speech analysis and questionnaire testings. Ratings revealed differences (benign vs. malignant, a = 5%) in 8 of 10 scales, cancer patients being inaccessible, altruistic, suppressing feelings, rationalizing and harmonizing. The biopsy's result was predicted in 75% of all cases. Questionnaire testing showed differences in 7 of 16 scales. It proved cancer patients to be more dependent, anxious, aggressive, health-conscious, family-bound and antisexual. A discriminant analysis correctly identified 77% of cancer and 87% of benign patients. Speech analysis (Gottschalk-Gleser) revealed only minor differences: fewer aggressive and more anxious utterances from cancer patients. Conclusions are drawn for the care and treatment of breast cancer patients.
(95) Shrock D, Effects of a
psychosocial intervention on survival among patients with stage I
breast and prostate cancer: a matched case-control study, Altern
Ther Health Med, 1999 May;5(3):49-55
CONTEXT: Psychosocial
factors have been linked to the development and progression of
cancer and shown to be relevant in cancer care. However, the
evidence that psychosocial interventions affect cancer survival
is less conclusive. Few methodologically sound studies have
addressed this issue. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effects of a
6-week psychosocial intervention on survival among patients with
stage I breast and prostate cancer. DESIGN: Matched case-control.
SETTING: 3 rural hospitals or cancer centers in central
Pennsylvania. PATIENTS: 21 breast and 29 prostate stage I cancer
patients (treatment group) matched with 74 breast and 65 prostate
stage I cancer patients from the same hospitals who did not
receive the intervention (control group). INTERVENTION: Six
2-hour health psychology classes conducted by a licensed staff
psychologist. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Survival time was compared
between the 2 groups and with national norms. RESULTS: The
intervention group lived significantly longer than did matched
controls. At 4- to 7-year follow-up (median = 4.2 years), none of
the breast cancer patients in the intervention group died,
whereas 12% of those in the control group died. Twice as many
matched-control prostate cancer patients died compared with those
in the intervention group (28% vs 14%). Control group survival
was similar to national norms. CONCLUSIONS: These results are
consistent with prior clinical trials and suggest that short-term
psychosocial interventions that encourage the expression of
emotions, provide social support, and teach coping skills can
influence survival among cancer patients. However, self-selection
bias cannot be ruled out as an alternative explanation for the
results. These interventions merit further consideration and
research.
(96) Greer S, Adjuvant
psychological therapy for patients with cancer: a prospective
randomised trial, BMJ, 1992 Mar 14;304(6828):675-80
OBJECTIVE--To determine the
effect of adjuvant psychological therapy on the quality of life
of patients with cancer. DESIGN--Prospective randomised
controlled trial comparing the quality of life of patients
receiving psychological therapy with that of patients receiving
no therapy, measured before therapy, at eight weeks, and at four
months of follow up. SETTING--CRC Psychological Medicine Group of
Royal Marsden Hospital. PATIENTS--174 patients aged 18-74
attending hospital with a confirmed diagnosis of malignant
disease, a life expectancy of at least 12 months, or scores on
various measures of psychological morbidity above previously
defined cut off points. INTERVENTION--Adjuvant psychological
therapy, a brief, problem focused, cognitive-behavioural
treatment programme specifically designed for the needs of
individual cancer patients. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--Hospital
anxiety and depression scale, mental adjustment to cancer scale,
Rotterdam symptom checklist, psychosocial adjustment to illness
scale. RESULTS--156 (90%) patients completed the eight week
trial; follow up data at four months were obtained for 137
patients (79%). At eight weeks, patients receiving therapy had
significantly higher scores than control patients on fighting
spirit and significantly lower scores on helplessness, anxious
preoccupation, and fatalism; anxiety; psychological symptoms; and
on orientation towards health care. These differences indicated
improvement in each case. At four months, patients receiving
therapy had significantly lower scores than controls on anxiety;
psychological symptoms; and psychological distress. Clinically,
the proportion of severely anxious patients dropped from 46% at
baseline to 20% at eight weeks and 20% at four months in the
therapy group and from 48% to 41% and to 43% respectively among
controls. The proportion of patients with depression was 40% at
baseline, 13% at eight weeks, and 18% at four months in the
therapy group and 30%, 29%, and 23% respectively in controls.
CONCLUSIONS--Adjuvant psychological therapy produces significant
improvement in various measures of psychological distress among
cancer patients. The effect of therapy observed at eight weeks
persists in some but not all measures at four month follow up.
(97) Fallowfield LJ, Truth may hurt but deceit
hurts more: communication in palliative care, Palliat Med, 2002
Jul;16(4):297-303
Healthcare
professionals often censor their information giving to patients
in an attempt to protect them from potentially hurtful, sad or
bad news. There is a commonly expressed belief that what people
do not know does not harm them. Analysis of doctor and
nurse/patient interactions reveals that this well-intentioned but
misguided assumption about human behaviour is present at all
stages of cancer care. Less than honest disclosure is seen from
the moment that a patient reports symptoms, to the confirmation
of diagnosis, during discussions about the therapeutic benefits
of treatment, at relapse and terminal illness. This desire to
shield patients from the reality of their situation usually
creates even greater difficulties for patients, their relatives
and friends and other members of the healthcare team. Although
the motivation behind economy with the truth is often well meant,
a conspiracy of silence usually results in a heightened state of
fear, anxiety and confusion--not one of calm and equanimity.
Ambiguous or deliberately misleading information may afford
short-term benefits while things continue to go well, but denies
individuals and their families opportunities to reorganize and
adapt their lives towards the attainment of more achievable
goals, realistic hopes and aspirations. In this paper, some
examples and consequences of accidental, deliberate, if
well-meaning, attempts to disguise the truth from patients, taken
verbatim from interviews, are given, together with cases of
unintentional deception or misunderstandings created by the use
of ambiguous language. We also provide evidence from research
studies showing that although truth hurts, deceit may well hurt
more. 'I think the best physician is the one who has the
providence to tell to the patients according to his knowledge the
present situation, what has happened before, and what is going to
happen in the future' (Hippocrates).
(98) Der beste Arzt scheint mir der zu sein, der sich auf Voraussicht versteht. Denn wenn er den gegenwärtigen und den ihm vorhergegangenen und den küfftigen Stand einer Krankheit schon vorher erkennt und den Kranken vorhersagt und ihnen erklärt, was sie unterlassen haben, dann werden sie ihm vertrauen, weil er ihren Zustand besser als sie selber erkennt, sodass die Menschen es wagen, sich dem Arzt anzuvertrauen. Ihre Therapie wird er aber am richtigsten vornehmen, wenn er aus dem gegenwärtigen Stand ihrer Krankheit deren künftigen Verlauf vorhersagt. Dal Corpus Hippocraticum di Ipocrate.
(99) Tiersma ES, Psychosocial
factors and the grade of cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia: a
semi-prospective study, Gynecol Oncol, 2004 Feb;92(2):603-10
OBJECTIVE: To study the influence of psychosocial factors on the
grade of cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia. METHODS: The
influence of psychosocial factors on the grade of cervical
intra-epithelial neoplasia (CIN) was studied in a group of 342
patients with an abnormal cervical smear. Participants completed
a set of questionnaires after colposcopy directed biopsy before
knowing the biopsy result. Negatively rated life events, social
support, and coping style were studied in relation to distress
and grade of CIN. Infection with human papillomavirus (HPV) types
was controlled for, as well as sick role bias caused by suspicion
of having cervical cancer and distress due to the abnormal
cervical smear. RESULTS: Negatively rated life events, lack of
social support, and emotional coping were significant predictors
for level of distress. No significant relationship was found,
however, between the psychosocial factors and grade of CIN.
CONCLUSION: No support was found for an influence of negatively
rated life events, social support, coping style, and distress on
grade of CIN.
(100) Tiersma ES, Psychosocial
factors and the course of cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia: a
prospective study, Gynecol Oncol, 2005 Jun;97(3):879-86
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the influence of psychosocial factors
on the course of cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia (CIN).
METHODS: A group of 93 patients with CIN 1 or 2 was followed for
2.25 years by half-yearly colposcopy and cytology.
Negatively-rated life events, social support, and coping style
were studied in relation to distress during follow-up and in
relation to time till progression and regression of CIN. Human
papillomavirus (HPV) infection was controlled for as well as sick
role bias caused by suspicion of having cervical cancer and
distress due to the abnormal cervical smear. RESULTS: During
follow-up, progression was found in 20 patients (22%), stable
disease in 22 patients (24%), and regression in 51 patients
(55%). Negatively-rated life events and lack of social support
predicted distress longitudinally. No association was found
between progression or regression of CIN and negatively-rated
life events, lack of social support, coping style, and distress.
CONCLUSION: We found no evidence that psychosocial factors
influence the course of CIN.
(101) Temoshok LR, Change is
complex: rethinking research on psychosocial interventions and
cancer, Integr Cancer Ther, 2002 Jun;1(2):135-45
The widely discussed 1989
study by Spiegel and colleagues, which suggested that a
psychosocial group intervention affected survival in metastatic
breast cancer, was not replicated by Goodwin and colleagues in
2001. We analyze methodological issues in both studies, including
issues of sampling, randomization, interpretation, and the
adequacy and validity of psychosocial constructs and measures to
assess hypothesized ingredients of change. The notion of
psychogenicity is introduced, conceived as the ability of
psychosocial interventions to elicit changes hypothesized to be
linked to desired medical outcomes. These considerations lead to
the conclusion that there is insufficient evidence to be able to
generalize from either study for or against the notion that
psychosocial interventions can affect survival in breast cancer.
The failure to incorporate into research designs a comprehensive
understanding of how coping patterns and related factors may
interact with psychosocial interventions to influence cancer
progression, and to address hypothesized mediating mechanisms is
discussed. Finally, strategies are proposed for future
biopsychosocial and intervention research in the field of
biopsychooncology.
(102) Ross L, Mind and cancer:
does psychosocial intervention improve survival and psychological
well-being? Eur j cancer, 2002 Jul;38(11):1447-57
The aim of this review was to
evaluate the scientific evidence for an effect of psychosocial
intervention on survival from cancer and well-being and in
particular on anxiety and depression. A literature search yielded
43 randomised studies of psychosocial intervention. Four of the
eight studies in which survival was assessed showed a significant
effect, and the effect on anxiety and depression was also
inconsistent, indicating three possible explanations: (i) only
some of the intervention strategies affect prognosis and/or
well-being and in only certain patient groups; (ii) the effect
was weak, so that inconsistent results were found in the
generally small study populations; or (iii) the effect was
diluted by the inclusion of unselected patient groups rather than
being restricted to patients in need of psychosocial support.
Thus, large-scale studies with sound methods are needed in which
eligible patients are screened for distress. Meanwhile, the
question of whether psychosocial intervention among cancer
patients has a beneficial effect remains unresolved.
(103) Edwards AG, Psychological
interventions for women with metastatic breast cancer, Cochrane
Database Syst Rev, 2004;(2):CD004253
BACKGROUND: There have been
conflicting results from systematic reviews of psychological
interventions for patients with cancer, some showing benefits for
patients and others not. One early study appeared to show
significant survival benefits as well as psychological benefits
from a psychological intervention given to women with metastatic
breast cancer. Some further studies have been undertaken, again
with conflicting results. OBJECTIVES: To assess the effects of
psychological interventions (educational, individual cognitive
behavioural or psychotherapeutic, or group support) on
psychological and survival outcomes for women with metastatic
breast cancer. SEARCH STRATEGY: We searched the Cochrane Breast
Cancer Group Trials Register (September 2003), the Cochrane
Central Register of Controlled Trials (The Cochrane Library,
Issue 4, 2003), MEDLINE (1966-October 2003), CancerLit
(1983-2000), CINAHL (1982-October 2003), PsycInfo (1974-November
2003), and SIGLE (1980-November 2003). SELECTION CRITERIA:
Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of psychological
interventions for women with metastatic breast cancer. Studies
were included even if they were not 'intention to treat', owing
to the nature of the patient group under study and the likely
high loss of follow-up data. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Data
were extracted independently by two reviewers. Data about the
nature and setting of the intervention, and the relevant outcome
data were extracted, along with items relating to methodological
quality. MAIN RESULTS: Five primary studies were identified, all
group psychological interventions. Two of these were cognitive
behavioural interventions and three evaluated support-expressive
group therapy. The five studies of group psychological therapies
for women with metastatic breast cancer showed very limited
evidence of benefit arising from these interventions. Although
there was evidence of short-term benefit for some psychological
outcomes, in general these were not sustained at follow-up. A
clearer pattern of psychological outcomes could not be discerned
as a wide variety of outcome measures and durations of follow-up
were used in the included studies. The possible longer survival
times in women allocated to receive psychological intervention in
the early study have not been replicated in the subsequent four
studies (including one by members of the first study group), and
overall the effects of these interventions on survival are not
statistically significant (for example, odds ratio for 5 year
survival 0.83 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.53 - 1.28).
REVIEWERS' CONCLUSIONS: There is insufficient evidence to
advocate that group psychological therapies (either cognitive
behavioural or supportive-expressive) should be made available to
all women diagnosed with metastatic breast cancer. Any benefits
of the interventions are only evident for some of the
psychological outcomes and in the short term. The possibility of
the interventions causing harm is not ruled out by the available
data.
(104) Fox BH, A hypothesis about
Spiegel et al.'s 1989 paper on Psychosocial intervention and
breast cancer survival, Psychooncology, 1998 Sep-Oct;7(5):361-70
In a randomized prospective
study of 86 metastatic breast cancer patients by Spiegel et al.
in 1989, the 50 who took part in a group psychosocial
intervention survived on average 18 months longer than the 36
controls who did not. Because the control survival curve looked
unusually steep, lacking an expected right-skewed tail, both
curves were compared with that of a population from the same
region having metastatic breast cancer. When transformed to
life-table format, the curves of the control sample and the
regional population, neither group having had an intervention,
were almost identical for a year, and differed strikingly after
20 months. This led to the hypothesis that the 12 control
patients surviving for more than 20 months were an extremely
aberrant sample, being subject to the strong biasing influence of
possible confounders, of which a considerable number are known,
but not including those accounted for in the study. Corollaries
to the hypothesis are that the intervention had no effect; that
the intervention curve was in fact equivalent to a control curve
with mild sampling departure from that of the regional
population; and that, therefore, the repetition of the study now
under way would not yield confirmation of the 1989 study, but
rather, would support the hypothesis and the first two
corollaries.
(105) Jim HS, Strategies used in
coping with a cancer diagnosis predict meaning in life for
survivors, Health Psychol, 2006 Nov;25(6):753-61
The search for meaning in life
is part of the human experience. A negative life event may
threaten perceptions about meaning in life, such as the
benevolence of the world and one's sense of harmony and peace.
The authors examined the longitudinal relationship between
women's coping with a diagnosis of breast cancer and their
self-reported meaning in life 2 years later. Multiple regression
analyses revealed that positive strategies for coping predicted
significant variance in the sense of meaning in life--feelings of
inner peace, satisfaction with one's current life and the future,
and spirituality and faith--and the absence of such strategies
predicted reports of loss of meaning and confusion (ps < .01).
The importance and process of finding meaning in the context of a
life stressor are discussed.
(106) Basak S, A Fourth IkappaB
Protein within the NF-kappaB Signaling Module, Cell 2007 jan 26
128(2) 369,
Inflammatory NF-kappaB/RelA
activation is mediated by the three canonical inhibitors,
IkappaBalpha, -beta, and -varepsilon. We report here the
characterization of a fourth inhibitor, nfkappab2/p100, that
forms two distinct inhibitory complexes with RelA, one of which
mediates developmental NF-kappaB activation. Our genetic evidence
confirms that p100 is required and sufficient as a fourth IkappaB
protein for noncanonical NF-kappaB signaling downstream of NIK
and IKK1. We develop a mathematical model of the
four-IkappaB-containing NF-kappaB signaling module to account for
NF-kappaB/RelA:p50 activation in response to inflammatory and
developmental stimuli and find signaling crosstalk between them
that determines gene-expression programs. Further combined
computational and experimental studies reveal that mutant cells
with altered balances between canonical and noncanonical IkappaB
proteins may exhibit inappropriate inflammatory gene expression
in response to developmental signals. Our results have important
implications for physiological and pathological scenarios in
which inflammatory and developmental signals converge.
(107) http://www.psicologia-dinamica.it/psysito/psonco/oncologia.htm
(108) Page GG, Pre-operative
versus postoperative administration of morphine: impact on the
neuroendocrine, behavioural, and metastatic-enhancing effects of
surgery, Br J Anaesth 1998 81(2) 216,
We have previously shown that
the pre- and postoperative administration of an analgesic dose of
morphine attenuated the tumour-enhancing effects of surgery. This
study was undertaken to assess the relative role and exclusive
importance of pre- versus postoperative morphine administration
on neuroendocrine, metastatic, and behavioural outcomes of
surgery in Fischer 344 rats. The natural killer (NK) sensitive
mammary adenocarcinoma cell line, MADB106, was used in a lung
clearance assay to assess host resistance to metastasis. Either
morphine or its vehicle was administered to all rats at three
times: (1) 30 min before surgery (8 mg kg-1, in saline); (2)
immediately after surgery in a slow release suspension (SRS, 4 mg
kg-1); and (3) 5 h after surgery at the time of tumour cell
inoculation (2 mg kg-1, in SRS). Five surgery groups underwent an
experimental laparotomy with halothane anaesthesia and received
either the vehicle at all three times or morphine in one of four
different regimens: before surgery only, at all three times,
after surgery only at times 2 and 3, and after surgery total at
times 2 and 3 with the preoperative dose added at time 2. Two
control groups underwent anaesthesia alone and received either
morphine or the vehicle at all three times. Surgery resulted in a
twofold increase in tumour cell retention, which was
significantly attenuated by all four morphine treatment regimens
(P < 0.05). Furthermore, the two surgery groups that were
treated with morphine preoperatively appeared to derive greater
benefit; whereas the preoperatively treated groups exhibited a
65-70% attenuation of surgery-induced increases in tumour cell
retention, only a 50% attenuation was evident in the two groups
treated postoperatively. Surgery significantly reduced rearing
behaviour and morphine reversed this effect such that most
morphine-treated surgery groups exhibited similar levels of
rearing behaviour as was observed in the unoperated animals
throughout the 4-h postoperative observation period. Morphine
treatment also significantly attenuated surgery-induced increases
in plasma corticosterone concentrations assessed at 5 h after
surgery. If such relationships hold in humans, these findings
support the suggestion that the pre-surgical administration of
morphine is key in optimizing its beneficial effects on
surgery-induced increases in metastasis.
(109) Page GG, The role of LGL/NK
cells in surgery-induced promotion of metastasis and its
attenuation by morphine, Brain Behav Immun 1994 8(3) 241,
Painful stress such as surgery
has been shown both to suppress immune function and to promote
metastasis, although the degree to which alterations in immunity
underlies the tumor-enhancing effects of surgery remains unclear.
We recently reported that an experimental laparotomy results in a
twofold increase in the number of lung metastases following iv
injection of MADB106 tumor cells, a natural killer (NK)-sensitive
mammary adenocarcinoma cell line, syngeneic to the Fischer 344
rats we studied. Further, the administration of an analgesic dose
of morphine prevented these metastatic-enhancing effects of
surgery. The aim of the present study was to investigate the role
of NK cells in both the metastatic-enhancing effects of surgery
and the attenuation of these effects by morphine. Using a simple
2 x 2 experimental design (surgery with anesthesia vs anesthesia
only, and morphine vs vehicle), we found that surgery resulted in
a decrease in both whole blood NK cytotoxic activity and number
of circulating LGL/NK cells assessed 4 h postoperatively. In a
second experiment involving an 18-h lung clearance assay, we used
the mAb 3.2.3 to deplete rats of LGL/NK cells with the following
rationale: if LGL/NK cells are necessary to mediate an event,
then in their absence, that event should not occur. Normal and
LGL/NK-depleted animals were assigned to the same four
experimental groups, and radiolabeled MADB106 tumor cells were
injected iv 4 h after surgery. In normal animals, there was a
significant interaction between surgery and morphine such that
morphine attenuated the surgery-induced increase in tumor cell
retention without affecting tumor cell retention in the
anesthesia groups. In the LGL/NK-depleted animals, however,
although the tumor-enhancing effects of surgery remained evident,
morphine did not mitigate this outcome. These results suggest
that: (a) both LGL/NK cell activity and other factors independent
of LGL/NK cells play a role in the surgery-induced increase in
tumor cell retention; and (b) LGL/NK cells play a critical role
in morphine's attenuating effects on this outcome. Finally, these
results reinforce concern about the pathogenic consequences of
unrelieved pain.
(110) Page GG, Morphine attenuates
surgery-induced enhancement of metastatic colonization in rats,
Pain 1993 54(1) 21,
Painful stressors such as
surgery have been shown both to suppress immune function and to
enhance tumor development. Whether the immune system mediates the
tumor-enhancing effects of surgery remains unclear. Moreover, the
role of postoperative pain has been largely ignored in such
studies. To explore these issues, we used the MADB106 tumor, a
mammary adenocarcinoma syngeneic to the subjects of this study
(Fischer 344 rats) and known to be sensitive to natural killer
(NK) cell activity. We found that surgery enhanced metastatic
colonization and that this tumor-enhancing effect occurred only
during the time in which the MADB106 tumor is sensitive to NK
control. These results support the hypothesis that suppression of
NK cell activity mediates the surgery-induced enhancement of
metastatic colonization. Further, we found that an analgesic dose
of morphine blocked the surgery-induced increase in metastasis
without affecting metastasis in unoperated animals. These
findings suggest that postoperative pain is a critical factor in
promoting metastatic spread. If a similar relationship between
pain and metastasis occurs in humans, then pain control must be
considered a vital component of postoperative care.
(111) Gaspani L, The analgesic
drug tramadol prevents the effect of surgery on natural killer
cell activity and metastatic colonization in rats, J Neuroimmunol
2002 129(1-2) 18-24,
Surgery stress has been shown
to be associated in rat with decreased natural killer (NK) cell
activity and enhancement of tumor metastasis. We have previously
shown that the analgesic drug tramadol stimulates NK activity
both in the rodent and in the human. In the present study, we
analyze, in the rat, tramadol ability to prevent the effect of
experimental surgery on NK activity and on the enhancement of
metastatic diffusion to the lung of the NK sensitive tumor model
MADB106. The administration of tramadol (20 and 40 mg/kg) before
and after laparatomy significantly blocked the enhancement of
lung metastasis induced by surgery. In contrast, the
administration of 10 mg/kg of morphine was not able to modify
this enhancement. The modulation of NK activity seemed to play a
central role in the effect of tramadol on MADB106 cells. In fact,
both doses of tramadol were able to prevent surgery-induced NK
activity suppression, while the drug significantly increased NK
activity in normal non-operated animals. Morphine, that in normal
rats significantly decreased NK cytotoxicity, did not prevent
surgery-induced immunosuppression. The good analgesic efficacy of
tramadol combined with its intrinsic immunostimulatory properties
suggests that this analgesic drug can be particularly indicated
in the control of peri-operative pain in cancer patients.
(112) Shavit Y, Effects of
fentanyl on natural killer cell activity and on resistance to
tumor metastasis in rats. Dose and timing study,
Neuroimmunomodulation 2004 11(4) 255,
OBJECTIVES: Opiates, which
serve an integral role in anesthesia, suppress immune function,
particularly natural killer cell cytotoxicity (NKCC). NK cells
play an important role in tumor and metastasis surveillance. We
reported that large-dose fentanyl anesthesia induced prolonged
suppression of NKCC in patients undergoing abdominal surgery. The
immune modulatory effects of opiates may depend on the
interaction between dose and time of administration. The present
study examined the effects of different doses of fentanyl,
administered at different time points relative to tumor
inoculation, on NKCC and on experimental tumor metastasis in
rats. METHODS: Fischer 344 rats were injected with low or high
doses of fentanyl, 6 or 2 h before, simultaneously with or 1 h
after being inoculated intravenously with MADB106 tumor cells.
Lung tumor retention (LTR) was assessed 4 h after, and lung tumor
metastases were counted 3 weeks after tumor inoculation. NKCC was
assessed 1 h after the fentanyl injection. RESULTS: At all time
points, except 6 h before tumor inoculation, fentanyl (0.1-0.3
mg/kg) induced a dose-dependent increase in MADB106 LTR (2.3- to
74-fold). An intermediate dose of fentanyl (0.15 mg/kg) doubled
the number of lung metastasis, and, within animal, suppressed
NKCC and increased MADB106 LTR in a correlated manner.
CONCLUSION: These findings indicate that fentanyl suppresses NKCC
and increases the risk of tumor metastasis. Suppression of NK
cells at a time when surgery may induce tumor dissemination can
prove to be critical to the spread of metastases. It is suggested
that the acute administration of a moderate dose of opiates
during surgery should be applied cautiously, particularly in
cancer patients.
(113) Page GG, Increased
surgery-induced metastasis and suppressed natural killer cell
activity during proestrus/estrus in rats, Breast Cancer Res
Threat 1997 45(2) 159,
We have previously reported
sex- and estrous-related differences in host resistance to the
metastatic development of a mammary adenocarcinoma cell line,
MADB106, in the Fischer 344 (F344) rat. In other studies, we
found that surgery suppressed natural killer (NK) cell activity
and increased the NK-sensitive metastatic development of MADB106
tumor cells. The current study was designed to explore whether
sex or estrous phase at the time of surgery impacts the degree of
such deleterious effects of surgery. Such estrous effects could
be related to an ongoing clinical debate regarding the importance
of the timing of breast cancer surgery with the menstrual cycle
in premenopausal women. Mature F344 males and cycling females
underwent either experimental laparotomy with halothane
anesthesia, halothane anesthesia alone, or were untreated. Five
hours after surgery, animals either were injected with
radiolabeled MADB106 tumor cells and assessed for lung tumor cell
retention 12 hours later, or underwent blood withdrawal for in
vitro assessment of NK cell activity. MADB106 tumor cells
metastasize only to the lungs, and lung tumor cell retention is:
a) an early indicator of the number of metastases that would
develop weeks later, and b) highly sensitive to in vivo levels of
NK activity. This mammary adenocarcinoma cell line is syngeneic
to the inbred F344 strain of rats used in our studies, thus
constituting a model for breast cancer metastasis. The results
indicated that sex, estrous phase, and surgery interacted in
their effects on NK cell activity and tumor metastasis. MADB106
lung tumor cell retention was increased by surgery in both sexes
(2- to 3-fold) compared to the anesthesia only and control
groups. This increase, however, was significantly greater in
proestrus/estrus (P/E) females than in metestrus/diestrus (M/D)
females. Among the control animals, females in P/E exhibited
significantly less NK cytotoxic activity compared to the males,
and the NK activity exhibited by females in M/D was between these
two groups. Surgery suppressed NK cytotoxic activity to a similar
level in all groups. Possible implications of these findings for
the surgical care of women with breast cancer are discussed.
(114) Besedovsky HO, Psychoneuroimmunology and cancer:
fifteenth Sapporo Cancer Seminar, Cancer res, 1996 Sep
15;56(18):4278-81
http://cancerres.aacrjournals.org/cgi/reprint/56/18/4278?ijkey=f9e6ec7bd08e32d5a719b5b2b21441f363b22767&keytype2=tf_ipsecsha
(115) Sacerdote P, Opioids and the
immune system, Palliat Med 2006;20 Suppl 1:s9-15
Opioid compounds such as morphine produce powerful analgesia that
is effective in treating various types of pain. In addition to
their therapeutic efficacy, opioids can produce several well
known adverse events, and, as has recently been recognized, can
interfere with the immune response. The immunomodulatory
activities of morphine have been characterized in animal and
human studies. Morphine can decrease the effectiveness of several
functions of both natural and adaptive immunity, and
significantly reduces cellular immunity. Indeed, in animal
studies morphine is consistently associated with increased
morbidity and mortality due to infection and worsening of cancer.
However, from several animal studies it emerges that not all
opioids induce the same immunosuppressive effects, and evaluating
each opioid's profile is important for appropriate analgesic
selection. Buprenorphine is a potent opioid that is frequently
prescribed for chronic pain. Acute intracerebroventricular
administration of buprenorphine has been shown in rats not to
affect cellular immune responses, while a statistically
significant inhibition of the immune response was observed with
morphine. In mouse studies, chronic administration of
buprenorphine led to immune parameters important for
antimicrobial responses or for anti-tumour surveillance
(lymphoproliferation, natural killer (NK)-lymphocyte activity,
cytokine production, lymphocyte number) being unaffected. In
contrast, levels of these immune markers were significantly
reduced when the potent micro-agonist fentanyl was administered,
but recovered after longer periods as tolerance developed.
Because the intrinsic immunosuppressive activity varies between
individual opioids, predicting the outcome on immunity can be
difficult. To study this, the effects of morphine, fentanyl and
buprenorphine on NK-lymphocyte activity depressed by experimental
surgery were examined in rats. Treating animals immediately after
surgery with equianalgesic doses of morphine and buprenorphine
significantly reduced surgery-induced immunosuppression. However,
buprenorphine reverted NK-lymphocyte activity to preoperative
levels, while in morphine-treated rats NK-lymphocyte activity was
ameliorated, although not completely. In contrast, fentanyl did
not prevent immunosuppression induced by surgery. Overall, from
several animal studies it emerges that buprenorphine has the more
favourable profile, being a potent analgesic devoid of intrinsic
immunosuppressive activity.
(116) Beilin B, Effects of
anesthesia based on large versus small doses of fentanyl on
natural killer cell cytotoxicity in the perioperative period,
Anesth Analg 1996 Mar;82(3):492-7,
Surgical stress and general anesthesia suppress immune functions,
including natural killer cell cytotoxicity (NKCC). This
suppression could be attributable, at least in part, to opiates.
We have previously shown that large-dose fentanyl administration
suppressed NKCC in rats. The present study sought to compare the
effects of two anesthetic protocols, based on large- (LDFA)
versus small (SDFA)-dose fentanyl anesthesia on NKCC in the
perioperative period. Forty patients were included in this study;
half were assigned to each protocol of anesthesia. In each
anesthetic group, half the patients were undergoing surgery for
malignant diseases, and half for benign conditions. Blood samples
were collected during the perioperative period. NKCC was assessed
using the chromium release assay. Initially, both types of
anesthesia similarly suppressed NKCC, with a peak effect 24 h
after surgery. The two types of anesthesia, however, differed in
the rate of recovery of NKCC suppression. By the second
postoperative day, NKCC returned to control values in the SDFA
patients, whereas NKCC was still significantly suppressed after
LDFA. These results indicate that LDFA causes prolonged
suppression of NK cell function. Whether this suppression might
have a long-term impact on the overall outcome, especially in
cancer patients, remains to be determined.
(118) Brand SR, The effect of
maternal PTSD following in utero trauma exposure on behavior and
temperament in the 9-month-old infant.
In view of evidence of in
utero glucocorticoid programming, and our prior observation of
lower cortisol levels in 9-month-old infants of mothers with
posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) compared to mothers without
PTSD, we undertook an examination of the effect of in utero
maternal stress, as determined by PTSD symptom severity, and
maternal cortisol levels on behavioral outcomes in the infant.
Methods: Ninety-eight pregnant women directly exposed to the
World Trade Center (WTC) collapse on 9/11 provided salivary
cortisol samples and completed a PTSD symptom questionnaire and a
behavior rating scale to measure infant temperament, including
distress to limitations, and response to novelty. Results:
Mothers who developed PTSD in response to 9/11 had lower morning
and evening salivary cortisol levels, compared to mothers who did
not develop PTSD. Maternal morning cortisol levels were inversely
related to their rating of infant distress and response to
novelty (i.e., loud noises, new foods, unfamiliar people). Also,
mothers who had PTSD rated their infants as having greater
distress to novelty than did mothers without PTSD (t = 2.77, df =
61, P = 0.007). Conclusion: Longitudinal studies are needed to
determine how the association between maternal PTSD symptoms and
cortisol levels and infant temperament reflect genetic and/or
epigenetic mechanisms of intergenerational transmission.
(119) Yehuda R, Transgenerational
effects of posttraumatic stress disorder in babies of mothers
exposed to the World Trade Center attacks during pregnancy, J
Clin Endocrin Metab 2005 Jul;90(7):4115-8. Epub 2005 May 3
http://jcem.endojournals.org/cgi/reprint/90/7/4115?ijkey=3fb94906118ae5ce99eaee74d30221b9e54bd4f1
CONTEXT: Reduced cortisol levels have been linked with
vulnerability to posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and the
risk factor of parental PTSD in adult offspring of Holocaust
survivors. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to report on
the relationship between maternal PTSD symptoms and salivary
cortisol levels in infants of mothers directly exposed to the
World Trade Center collapse on September 11, 2001 during
pregnancy. DESIGN: Mothers (n = 38) collected salivary cortisol
samples from themselves and their 1-yr-old babies at awakening
and at bedtime. RESULTS: Lower cortisol levels were observed in
both mothers (F = 5.15, df = 1, 34; P = 0.030) and babies of
mothers (F = 8.0, df = 1, 29; P = 0.008) who developed PTSD in
response to September 11 compared with mothers who did not
develop PTSD and their babies. Lower cortisol levels were most
apparent in babies born to mothers with PTSD exposed in their
third trimesters. CONCLUSIONS: The data suggest that effects of
maternal PTSD related to cortisol can be observed very early in
the life of the offspring and underscore the relevance of in
utero contributors to putative biological risk for PTSD.
(120) Bierer LM, Clinical
correlates of 24-h cortisol and norepinephrine excretion among
subjects seeking treatment following the world trade center
attacks on 9/11, Ann NY Acad Sci 2006 Jul;1071:514-20
Whereas trauma-associated
arousal has been linked fairly consistently with elevations in
both glucocorticoids and catecholamines, neuroendocrine
correlates of hyperarousal in the context of posttraumatic stress
disorder (PTSD) have been more variable. Further, neuroendocrine
predictors of the development of PTSD following trauma have been
related to prior exposure, and data from several laboratories
suggests that hyperarousal may develop in a neuroendocrine milieu
of relatively diminished basal glucocorticoid secretion. METHODS:
In this article we examined 24-h cortisol and norepinephrine
excretion in 42 treatment-seeking survivors of the 9/11 World
Trade Center (WTC) attacks, 32 of whom met criteria for PTSD, and
15 of whom met criteria for major depression, at the time of
evaluation; 14 of the 15 subjects meeting criteria for major
depression also suffered from PTSD. RESULTS: PTSD subjects' 24-h
cortisol excretion (46.3 +/- 20.0 microL/dL) was lower than that
of the non-PTSD cohort (72.2 +/- 22.4 microL/dL; t = 3.18, df =
37, P = 0.003), and 24-h urinary cortisol was negatively
correlated with the experience of the WTC attacks as a
Criterion-A event (r = -0.427, P = 0.007), and with self-rated
avoidance (r = -0.466, P = 0.003) and total score (r = -0.398, P
= 0.012) on the PTSD Symptom Scale (PSS). In contrast, 24-h
norepinephrine excretion was not associated with the development
of PTSD or with PTSD-related symptoms, but was negatively
correlated with days since 9/11 at the time of evaluation (r =
-0.393, P = 0.015). DISCUSSION: The latter finding suggests a
relationship of norepinephrine to a dimension of stress-related
arousal not captured by the symptom-rating scales chosen for this
study to reflect symptoms related to PTSD and other
neuropsychiatric disorders, but instead, of one to that of the
sudden multidimensional life disruption suffered by the WTC
survivors that applied for treatment. These data also confirm, in
a naturalistic sample, the previously observed negative
association of urinary cortisol excretion with development of
PTSD in the aftermath of severe trauma exposure.
(121) Yehuda R, Low urinary
cortisol excretion in Holocaust survivors with posttraumatic
stress disorder, Am J Psychiatry 1995 Jul;152(7):982-6
OBJECTIVE: The authors'
objective was to compare the urinary cortisol excretion of
Holocaust survivors with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (N
= 22) to that of Holocaust survivors without PTSD (N = 25) and
comparison subjects not exposed to the Holocaust (N = 15).
METHOD: Twenty-four-hour urine samples were collected, and the
following day, subjects were evaluated for the presence and
severity of past and current PTSD and other psychiatric
conditions. RESULTS: Holocaust survivors with PTSD showed
significantly lower mean 24-hour urinary cortisol excretion than
the two groups of subjects without PTSD. Multiple correlation
analysis revealed a significant relationship between cortisol
levels and severity of PTSD that was due to a substantial
association with scores on the avoidance subscale. CONCLUSIONS:
The present findings replicate the authors' previous observation
of low urinary cortisol excretion in combat veterans with PTSD
and extend these findings to a non-treatment-seeking civilian
group. The results also demonstrate that low cortisol levels are
associated with PTSD symptoms of a clinically significant nature,
rather than occurring as a result of exposure to trauma per se,
and that low cortisol levels may persist for decades following
exposure to trauma among individuals with chronic PTSD.
(122) Yehuda R, Cortisol levels in
adult offspring of Holocaust survivors: relation to PTSD symptom
severity in the parent and child, Psychoneuroendocrinology 2002
Jan-Feb;27(1-2):171-80,
We have previously
demonstrated lower mean 24-h urinary cortisol excretion in adult
offspring of Holocaust survivors with parental posttraumatic
stress disorder (and lifetime PTSD), compared to offspring
without parental PTSD, and to demographically similar comparison
subjects. In the current study, we re-analyze data from our
previously published report, plus four new subjects, to further
examine the relationship between cortisol and severity of PTSD
symptoms in offspring and their parents. We also examine the
contribution of current depressive disorder to cortisol levels.
Two-way analysis of variance revealed lifetime PTSD to be
associated with significantly lower cortisol levels, while
depressive disorder was associated with higher cortisol levels.
The presence of parental PTSD was associated with lower cortisol
excretion in the offspring only if both parents were affected.
There were significant negative correlations between severity of
parental PTSD and offspring urinary cortisol excretion, and
between severity of offspring PTSD symptoms and urinary cortisol
levels. The findings amplify our earlier descriptions of children
of Holocaust survivors with PTSD as a sample 'at risk' for PTSD
by demonstrating relationships between lowered cortisol excretion
in these offspring and their experience of their parents' PTSD
symptoms.
(123) Wolff MS, Exposures among
pregnant women near the World Trade Center site on 11 September
2001, Environ Health Perspect 2005 Jun;113(6):739-48,
We have characterized
environmental exposures among 187 women who were pregnant, were
at or near the World Trade Center (WTC) on or soon after 11
September 2001, and are enrolled in a prospective cohort study of
health effects. Exposures were assessed by estimating time spent
in five zones around the WTC and by developing an exposure index
(EI) based on plume reconstruction modeling. The daily
reconstructed dust levels were correlated with levels of
particulate matter < or = 2.5 microm in aerodynamic diameter
(PM2.5; r = 0.68) or PM10 (r = 0.73-0.93) reported from 26
September through 8 October 2001 at four of six sites near the
WTC whose data we examined. Biomarkers were measured in a subset.
Most (71%) of these women were located within eight blocks of the
WTC at 0900 hr on 11 September, and 12 women were in one of the
two WTC towers. Daily EIs were determined to be highest
immediately after 11 September and became much lower but remained
highly variable over the next 4 weeks. The weekly summary EI was
associated strongly with women's perception of air quality from
week 2 to week 4 after the collapse (p < 0.0001). The highest
levels of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon-deoxyribonucleic acid
(PAH-DNA) adducts were seen among women whose blood was collected
sooner after 11 September, but levels showed no significant
associations with EI or other potential WTC exposure sources.
Lead and cobalt in urine were weakly correlated with sigmaEI, but
not among samples collected closest to 11 September. Plasma OC
levels were low. The median polychlorinated biphenyl level (sum
of congeners 118, 138, 153, 180) was 84 ng/g lipid and had a
nonsignificant positive association with sigmaEI (p > 0.05).
1,2,3,4,6,7,8-Heptachlorodibenzodioxin levels (median, 30 pg/g
lipid) were similar to levels reported in WTC-exposed
firefighters but were not associated with EI. This report
indicates intense bystander exposure after the WTC collapse and
provides information about nonoccupational exposures among a
vulnerable population of pregnant women.
(124) Rayne S, Using exterior
building surface films to assess human exposure and health risks
from PCDD/Fs in New York City, USA, after the World Trade Center
attacks, J Hazard Mater 2005 Dec 9;127(1-3):33-9
Concentrations of tetra- through octa-chlorinated
dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans (PCDD/Fs) were determined in
exterior window films from Manhattan and Brooklyn in New York
City (NYC), USA, 6 weeks after the World Trade Center (WTC)
attacks of 11 September 2001. High concentrations of the
2,3,7,8-substituted congeners (P(2378)CDD/Fs) were observed, at
levels up to 6600 pg-TEQ g(-1) nearest the WTC site. An
equilibrium partitioning model was developed to reconstruct total
gas + particle-phase atmospheric concentrations of P(2378)CDD/Fs
at each site. The reconstructed atmospheric and window film
concentrations were subsequently used in a preliminary human
health risk assessment to estimate the potential cancer and
non-cancer risks posed to residents of lower Manhattan from these
contaminants over the 6 week exposure period between the WTC
attacks and sampling dates. Residents of lower Manhattan appear
to have a slightly elevated cancer risk (up to 1.6%
increase over background) and increased P(2378)CDD/F
body burden (up to 8.0% increase over background) because of
above-background exposure to high concentrations of P(2378)CDD/Fs
produced from the WTC attacks during the short period between 11
September 2001, and window film sampling 6 weeks later.
(125) http://www.corriere.it/Primo_Piano/Cronache/2007/03_Marzo/11/veronesi.shtml 11.3.07, U. Veronesi: Il ricordo dello scienziato, Laura Dubini un simbolo della lotta al cancro
(126) http://www.meb.uni-bonn.de/cancernet/600317.html National Cancer Institute: Psychological Stress and Cancer
(127) http://www.aerzteblatt.de/v4/archiv/artikeldruck.asp?id=49834 Sonnenmos, Marion: Psychosoziale Aspekte onkologischer Erkrankungen: Der Einfluss der Psyche ist sekundär
(129) http://www.tumorzentrum-tuebingen.de/Schwarz_Vortrag_Patiententag2007.pdf Schwarz R: (2007) Psychologische Faktoren bei Krebserkrankungen
da aggiungere:
(130) Nielsen NR, Stress and
breast cancer: a systematic update on the current knowledge. Nat
Clin Pract Oncol 2006 Nov;3(11):612-20
A vast body of research has
been carried out to examine the relationship between
psychological stress and the risk of breast cancer. Previous
reviews on this issue have mainly focused on stressful life
events and have included both prospective and retrospective
studies. The results from these reviews have revealed conflicting
data. We evaluate whether stressful life events, work-related
stress, or perceived global stress are differentially associated
with breast cancer incidence and breast cancer relapse in
prospective studies. Systematic and explicit methods were used to
identify, select, and critically appraise relevant studies. The
substantial variability in the manner in which stress was
conceptualized and measured did not allow for the calculation of
a quantitative summary estimate for the association between
stress and breast cancer. Despite the heterogeneity in the
results obtained, it is concluded that stress does not seem to
increase the risk of breast cancer incidence. Whether stress
affects the progression of breast cancer is still unclear.
Studies with more thorough adjustment for confounding factors and
larger studies on stress and breast cancer relapse are required
to address this issue.
(131) Bergelt C, Stressful life
events and cancer risk. Br J Cancer 2006 Dec 4;95(11):1579-81
In a prospective cohort study
in Denmark of 8736 randomly selected people, no evidence was
found among 1011 subjects who developed cancer that self-reported
stressful major life events had increased their risk for cancer.
Lavori non esaminati:
Barrios A.A., & Kroger W.S.. (1975). Hypnosis as a tool in a fight against the cancer. J. Hol. Health, 1, 71-80.
Antonovsky, A.: Unraveling the mystery of health. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco 1987.
Levy S. M. (1984). Emotions and progression of cancer : a review. Advances : Journal of the Institute for the Advancement of Health, hiver, 10-15.
Cooper CL, Faragher EB. Psychosocial stress and breast cancer: the inter-relationship between stress events, coping strategies and personality. Psychol Med 1993;23:653-62
Dreyer L, Cancer risk of patients discharged with acute myocardial infarct, Epidemiology, 1998 Mar;9(2):178-83
Fawzy, F., Fawzy, N., Arndt, L., Pasnau, R. (1995) Critical review of psychosocial interventions in cancer care. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry, 52, 100-113.Fawzy, F., Fawzy, N. (1998) Group therapy in the cancer setting. J Psychosom Res 45, 3, 191-200
Fox, B. (1998) Psychosocial factors in cancer incidence and prognosis. In: In: J. Holland (ed) Psychooncology, p. 110-124. Oxford University Press New York.
Goodwin PJ, Leszcz M, Ennis M, Koopmans J, Vincent L, Guther H, Drysdale E, Hundleby M, Chochinov HM, Navarro M, Speca M, Hunter J (2001) The effect of group psychosocial support on survival in metastatic breast cancer. N Engl J Med 345(24):1719-1726
Geyer S. Life events prior to manifestation of breast cancer: a limited prospective study covering eight years before diagnosis. J Psychosom Res 1991;35:355-63
Holland, J.C. (2002). History of Psycho-Oncology: overcoming attitudinal and conceptual barriers. Psychosomatic Medicine, 64, 206-221.
Kiss, A. (1995): Psychosocial/psychotherapeutic interventions in cancer patients: consensus statment. Support Care Cancer 3, 217-218
Lewis CE, O'Sullivan C, Barraclough J, eds. The psychoimmunology of cancer. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994
Newell SA, Sanson-Fisher RW, Savolainen NJ (2002) Systematic review of psychological therapies for cancer patients: overview and recommendation for future research. J Natl Cancer Inst. 17; 94 (8): 558-84
NHMRC National Health and Medical Research Council (1999). Psychosocial practice guidelines: information, support and counselling for women with breast cancer. Canberra, Australia, Http://www.health.gov.au:80/nhmrc/publications/synopses/cp61syn.htm
Petticrew M Bell R,
Influence of psychological coping on survival and recurrence in
people with cancer: systematic review, BMJ, 2002 Nov 9;325(7372)
link: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?tool=pubmed&pubmedid=12424165
Schwarz R: Seelische
Einflüsse auf Entstehung und Verlauf onkologischer Erkrankungen.
Dt. Hirntumorhilfe/Brainstorm 2005; 1: 2022.
Schwarz R: Die Krebspersönlichkeit Mythen und
Forschungsresultate. Psychoneuro 2004; 4: 201207.
Michael Spöttel: Vergebliche Hoffnung. Der Mythos von sanften und natürlichen Krebstherapien. Alibri Verlag, Aschaffenburg 2006 (libro)
JuliusHackethal: 1980
"Keine Angst vor Krebs" (libro)
...Naturgegeben seien nur »gutartige Haustierkrebse«, die durch
körpereigene Abwehrkräfte in Schach gehalten würden und
dementsprechend nicht behandelt werden müssten. Werde der
»Haustierkrebs« allerdings seelisch und/oder körperlich
misshandelt, werde ein »Raubtierkrebs« daraus. So sei Krebs in
erster Linie eine »Krankheit der Seele«: Ein seelisch Gesunder
sei niemals krebskrank. "Raubtierkrebs ist die biologische
Gottesstrafe für jahrzehntelange Sünden gegen die Gesundheit,
für Gesundheitslaster. Gott ist die Natur, Naturgesetze sind
unabänderliche Gottesgesetze", schreibt Hackethal. Ergo:
Krebs ist eine Strafe für ein Fehlverhalten wider die als
göttlich erachtete Natur (oder vielmehr gegen das, was Hackethal
für natürlich hält). Mit christlicher Heilslehre hat Hackethal
zwar nichts im Sinn. Der Mensch sei von dem "Naturgott"
für die Welt, nicht für Himmel oder Hölle geschaffen. Dennoch
ist er von der Unsterblichkeit der Seele überzeugt: Diese lebe
in den Kindern weiter. Und: Krebs könne auf Kinder und Enkel
vererbt werden: »Die nach dem Tod per Seelenwanderung auf die
Kinder übergegangene Seele büßt für ungesühnte Sünden
weiter." Ähnliche Empfehlungen präsentiert Hackethal
im Rahmen seiner »Eubios-Strategie«. Er setzt auf viel
Bewegung, abwechslungsreiche Kost, wenig Alkohol, Tabak, Kaffee,
Tee, viel frische Luft, ausreichend Schlaf (wichtig: zwei Stunden
vor Mitternacht), Gelassenheit, usw. Und: viel Sex und viel
Liebe! Da der »Fortpflanzungstrieb« der stärkste Trieb der
Seele sei, bestehe eine »besonders enge Wechselbeziehung«
zwischen Fortpflanzungsorganen und Krebs. Ein intensives Sexual-
und Liebesleben, ist sich Hackethal sicher, macht nicht nur
Spaß, sondern dient überdies der Krebsprävention. Niemals
würden, glaubt Hackethal, derart vernünftig lebende Menschen an
Krebs sterben. Die Eubios-Strategie wirke präventiv, die
körpereigenen Abwehrkräfte würden mobilisiert. Im akuten
Zustand einer Erkrankung müssten die Abwehrkräfte erst recht
gestärkt werden, denn »Rückbildungen von Krebsherden beruhen
(
) auf körpereigenen Abwehrkräften«. Jeder
Krebsverdächtige sollte, spricht Hackethal, erst einmal weit weg
in Urlaub fahren und die »starke(n) Krebsheilkräfte« eines
Reizklimas auf sich wirken lassen. Anschließend stehen
Entgiftungskuren auf dem Plan, insbesondere Schwitzkuren.
Besonders wichtig sei aber das Sonnenbaden, möglichst nackt,
denn: »Der potenteste Krebshemmer ist wahrscheinlich die
Sonne«, da der Pigmentstoff Melanin direkt Krebs hemmend wirke.
Warum aber, fragt sich Hackethal, bekommen auch schwarzhäutige
Menschen Organkrebse? Seine Antwort lautet: Schwarze verfügten
zwar über mehr Melanin, dies sei jedoch weniger mobil als das
sehr mobile Melanin der gebräunten Weißen. Nur im
alleräußersten Notfall dürften chirurgische Maßnahmen
gewählt werden. Beide Kritiker der orthodoxen Medizin legen
Frisch-Fromm-Fröhlich-Frei-Programme vor. Der Unterschied: Nach
Windstosser soll ein asketischer Lebensstil den Menschen
erlösen, Hackethal plädiert für Hedonismus.
Coyne JC: Psychotherapy and survival in
cancer: The conflict between hope and evidence, Psychol Bull,
2007 May;133(3):367-94
Despite contradictory
findings, the belief that psychotherapy promotes survival in
people who have been diagnosed with cancer has persisted since
the seminal study by D. Spiegel, J. R. Bloom, H. C. Kramer, and
E. Gottheil (1989). The current authors provide a systematic
critical review of the relevant literature. In doing so, they
introduce some considerations in the design, interpretation of
results, and reporting of clinical trials that have not been
sufficiently appreciated in the behavioral sciences. They note
endemic problems in this literature. No randomized clinical trial
designed with survival as a primary endpoint and in which
psychotherapy was not confounded with medical care has yielded a
positive effect. Among the implications of the review is that an
adequately powered study examining effects of psychotherapy on
survival after a diagnosis of cancer would require resources that
are not justified by the strength of the available evidence. ((c)
2007 APA, all rights reserved).
Cunningham AJ: A randomized controlled
trial of the effects of group psychological therapy on survival
in women with metastatic breast cancer, Psychooncology 1998
Nov-Dec;7(6):508-17
In order to test the effect of
a psychological intervention on survival from cancer, 66 women
with metastatic breast cancer, all receiving standard medical
care, were randomly assigned into two groups; one group (n = 30)
attended the psychological intervention, consisting of 35 weekly,
2 h sessions of supportive plus cognitive behavioral therapy; the
control group (n = 36) received only a home study cognitive
behavioral package. No significant difference was found in
survival post-randomization between the groups as assessed by a
log rank test 5 years after the commencement of the study. As
expected, several prognostic factors were significant predictors
of survival: metastatic site, hormonal receptor status, and
chemotherapy prior to randomization. While many personal and
demographic variables did not influence survival, there was a
significant effect of self-reported exercise (possibly due to
better health). A small subgroup of intervention subjects who
attended outside support groups also survived significantly
longer than those who did not. The strengths and limitations of
the present study are discussed, and the results contrasted with
those of a well known study by Spiegel et al. (Spiegel, D.,
Bloom, J.R., Kraemer, H.C. and Gottheil, E. (1989) Lancet ii,
888-891). We propose that a different experimental design
(correlative) may be needed to show any effect of self-help
behaviors and psychological attributes in a small minority of
patients.
Cunningham AJ: How psychological therapy
may prolong survival in cancer patients: new evidence and a
simple theory, Integr Cancer Ther 2004 Sep;3(3):214-29
This article presents new data
and attempts to draw together converging lines of evidence on the
mental attributes that may favor prolonged survival in the face
of metastatic cancer. The authors interviewed 10 individuals with
medically incurable cancers who had outlived their prognoses by
from 2.2 to 12.5 years (and have all survived, a further 2 more
years in most cases, between interview and publication). The
authors derived, by qualitative analysis, a number of themes
common to most or all of them. Three major qualities emerged:
"authenticity," or a clear understanding of what was
important in one's life; "autonomy," the perceived
freedom to shape life around what was valued; and
"acceptance," a perceived change in mental state to
enhanced self-esteem, greater tolerance for and emotional
closeness to others, and an affective experience described as
more peaceful and joyous. Previous descriptions of
"remarkable survivors" have suffered from a serious
limitation: the research to date has not clarified to what extent
they differed psychologically from their many peers who did not
survive. The authors attempted to address this question in 2
ways. Six of the subjects were part of a protocol (the Healing
Journey study) in which patients belonged to a larger group, all
of whom were medically assessed prospectively, by an expert
panel. A prediction of the likely duration of survival was made
for each of the patients in this study, and it could be shown
that those who subsequently survived were not a random sample of
the whole but displayed a much higher degree of early involvement
in their psychological self-help than did most of their
nonsurviving peers. They also compared long survivors with 2
other groups: 6 individuals with similar diseases who had not yet
received psychological help and 6 individuals from the Healing
Journey study whose survival duration was at the lower end of the
whole group. The patients in these comparison groups also lacked
many of the most salient qualities identified among the long
survivors. Many of the attributes found in the long survivors
were, however, also noted in the earlier reports of remarkable
survivors in the literature, which suggests that the observations
may be generalizable. Putting these joint findings together with
the early work of Temoshok on "type C" adaptation as a
risk factor for cancer, one can see that there is a mirrored
symmetry between the psychological patterns possibly promoting
disease and the changed adaptations that may lead to longer
survival in some cases. The authors arrive at a commonsense
hypothesis: to the extent that the progression of cancer, or
other chronic disease, is favored by a distorted psychological
adaptation such as type C, healing may be assisted by a reversal
of that adaptation--in the case of cancer, toward greater
authenticity of thought and action.
Goodkin K, Psychoneuroimmunological aspects
of disease progression among women with human
papillomavirus-associated cervical dysplasia and human
immunodeficiency virus type 1 co-infection, Int J Psychiatry Med,
1993;23(2):119-48
OBJECTIVE: Psychosocial
associations have been observed with level of cervical dysplasia
or "pre-cancer" and invasive cervical cancer [related
to human papillomavirus (HPV) infection].
Psychoneuroimmunological relationships have been observed in
human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) infection, which is
being described in an increasing number of women. Our objective
was to review these relationships regarding effects that might be
expected in HIV-1 and HPV co-infected women. METHOD: This review
was based on a Medline literature search supplemented by a manual
search of selected journals unrepresented in that database.
RESULTS: Relationships of psychosocial factors and level of
cervical dysplasia were similarly observed with reference to
immunological and health status in asymptomatic and early
symptomatic HIV-1 infected homosexual men, suggesting that a
potentiating effect may occur in HIV-1 and HPV co-infected women.
Consistency of relationships across studies appeared to be
enhanced by the use of a biopsychosocial model integrating the
effects of life stressors, social support and coping style as
well as psychiatric disorders. CONCLUSIONS: Research is indicated
on the relationships between psychosocial factors, immunological
status and clinical health status in this group of women. Because
of the high prevalence of psychosocial risk factors for chronic
psychological distress in these women and the known immunological
and health status decrements occurring with progression of these
two infections, a clinical screening program based on the
biopsychosocial model is recommended as a means of secondary
prevention. If effective in generating treatment referrals, such
a program would likely improve quality of life and could aid in
the determination of relationships with immunological and health
status as well.
Byrnes DM, Stressful events, pessimism,
natural killer cell cytotoxicity, and cytotoxic/suppressor T
cells in HIV+ black women at risk for cervical cancer, Psychom
Med 1998 Nov-Dec;60(6):714-22
OBJECTIVE: This study examines
whether stressful negative life events and pessimism were
associated with lower natural killer cell cytotoxicity (NKCC) and
T cytotoxic/suppressor cell (CD8+CD3+) percentage in black women
co-infected with human immunodeficiency virus Type 1 (HIV-1) and
human papillomavirus (HPV), a viral initiator of cervical cancer.
METHOD: Psychosocial interviews, immunological evaluations, and
cervical swabs for HPV detection and subtyping were conducted on
36 HIV+ African-American, Haitian, and Caribbean women. RESULTS:
Greater pessimism was related to lower NKCC and
cytotoxic/suppressor cells after controlling for presence/absence
of HPV Types 16 or 18, behavioral/lifestyle factors, and
subjective impact of negative life events. CONCLUSIONS: A
pessimistic attitude may be associated with immune decrements,
and possibly poorer control over HPV infection and increased risk
for future promotion of cervical dysplasia to invasive cervical
cancer in HIV+ minority women co-infected with HPV.
Krongrad A, Marriage and mortality in
prostate cancer, J Urol 1996 Nov;156(5):1696-70,
PURPOSE: We evaluated the
association of marital status and survival in patients with
prostate cancer. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Using the 146,979
prostate cancer patients of the 1973 to 1990 public use tape of
the Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results program we
performed survival analysis and multivariate proportional hazards
modeling to estimate the relative risk of mortality. RESULTS:
Married patients had significantly longer median survival than
those who were divorced, single, separated or widowed. In models
that controlled for age, stage, race and treatment, married
patients had a significantly lower risk of mortality than those
who were divorced, single, separated or widowed. CONCLUSIONS:
Several hypothetical models can explain the association of
marital status and mortality in men with prostate cancer. The
most attractive model relies on the putative salutary effects of
being married on social support and/or mood. A social support and
depressed mood model of mortality raises the possibility that in
prostate cancer quality of life determines quantity of life.
Understanding the relationships among marital status, social
support, mood and mortality could open the way to rational
strategies for postponing death in men with prostate cancer.
Gore JL: Marriage and mortality in bladder
carcinoma, Cancer 2005 Sep 15;104(6):1188-94,
BACKGROUND: Being married
confers significant benefits in survival for patients with a
variety of chronic conditions including breast and prostate
carcinoma. The authors attempted to determine whether marital
status is associated with survival in patients undergoing radical
cystectomy for bladder carcinoma. METHODS: The authors identified
7262 subjects from the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End
Results public-use database who underwent radical cystectomy for
transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder. They performed
survival analyses using Kaplan-Meier estimates and Cox
proportional hazards models. The authors created multivariate
models to evaluate the independent association between marital
status and survival, controlling for pathologic stage, lymph node
status, age, race/ethnicity, and gender. RESULTS: Married
subjects were older and more often male, white, and had earlier
disease stage at diagnosis. Married subjects had significantly
better survival than did single or widowed subjects (P <
0.001), and married subjects revealed a trend toward better
survival than separated/divorced subjects (P = 0.20).
Multivariate modeling revealed that compared with single
subjects, those who were married had better survival, independent
of age at the time of diagnosis, gender, race/ethnicity, disease
stage, and lymph node status (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS:
Marriage was associated with improved survival in patients with
bladder carcinoma, independent of other factors known to
influence mortality in this population. Although the mechanisms
underlying this survival advantage are unknown, possibilities
include differences in cancer screening, risk behaviors, and
access to medical care. The interaction between psychosocial
factors and the body's immune function may further explain the
differential survival in this cohort. Copyright 2005 American
Cancer Society.
Burke MA: Stress and the development of breast cancer: a persistent and popular link despite contrary evidence, Cancer 1997 Mar 1;79(5):1055-9,
Bleiker EM, Psychosocial factors in the
etiology of breast cancer: review of a popular link, Patient Educ
Couns 1999 Jul;37(3):201-14,
Breast cancer is the most frequently occurring type of cancer in
women in the western world. The etiology of a large proportion of
breast cancers is still unexplained, and the possibility that
psychosocial factors could play a role is not ruled out. Already
in pre-Christian times, it was assumed that psychological factors
might play a significant role in the development of breast
cancer. However, studies have failed to produce conclusive
results. There is still a lack of knowledge on the relationship
between breast cancer development and psychosocial factors such
as stressful life events, coping styles, depression, and the
ability to express emotions. The results of this review show that
there is not enough evidence that psychosocial factors like 'ways
of coping' or 'non-expression of negative emotions', play a
significant role in the etiology of breast cancer.
Byrnes DM, Stressful events, pessimism,
natural killer cell cytotoxicity, and cytotoxic/suppressor T
cells in HIV+ black women at risk for cervical cancer, Psychosom
Med 1998 Nov-Dec;60(6):714-22,
OBJECTIVE: This study examines
whether stressful negative life events and pessimism were
associated with lower natural killer cell cytotoxicity (NKCC) and
T cytotoxic/suppressor cell (CD8+CD3+) percentage in black women
co-infected with human immunodeficiency virus Type 1 (HIV-1) and
human papillomavirus (HPV), a viral initiator of cervical cancer.
METHOD: Psychosocial interviews, immunological evaluations, and
cervical swabs for HPV detection and subtyping were conducted on
36 HIV+ African-American, Haitian, and Caribbean women. RESULTS:
Greater pessimism was related to lower NKCC and
cytotoxic/suppressor cells after controlling for presence/absence
of HPV Types 16 or 18, behavioral/lifestyle factors, and
subjective impact of negative life events. CONCLUSIONS: A
pessimistic attitude may be associated with immune decrements,
and possibly poorer control over HPV infection and increased risk
for future promotion of cervical dysplasia to invasive cervical
cancer in HIV+ minority women co-infected with HPV.
Garssen B: On the role of immunological
factors as mediators between psychosocial factors and cancer
progression, Psychiatry Res 1999 Jan 18;85(1):51-61,
Thirty-eight prospective studies on the role of psychological
factors in cancer initiation and progression are reviewed.
Despite the availability of many prospective studies, there is no
certainty about the role of any specific factor. An important
reason might be that the interactions among several psychological
factors, and the interactions of psychological and biomedical
risk factors, have rarely been studied. Some evidence has been
found that a low level of social support, a tendency towards
helplessness, and repression of negative emotions are factors
that promote cancer progression. The effect of psychological
factors has been more convincingly demonstrated with respect to
cancer progression than cancer initiation, and more convincingly
in intervention than in natural history studies. Possible
mechanisms mediating associations between psychological factors
and disease outcome are discussed. The role of immunosurveillance
seems modest overall, and alternative pathways are suggested.
Garssen B: Psychological factors and cancer
development: evidence after 30 years of research, Clin Rsychol
Rev 2004 Jul;24(3):315-38,
The question whether
psychological factors affect cancer development has intrigued
both researchers and patients. This review critically summarizes
the findings of studies that have tried to answer this question
in the past 30 years. Earlier reviews, including meta-analyses,
covered only a limited number of studies, and included studies
with a questionable design (group-comparison, cross-sectional or
semiprospective design). This review comprises only longitudinal,
truly prospective studies (N=70). It was concluded that there is
not any psychological factor for which an influence on cancer
development has been convincingly demonstrated in a series of
studies. Only in terms of 'an influence that cannot be totally
dismissed,' some factors emerged as 'most promising':
helplessness and repression seemed to contribute to an
unfavorable prognosis, while denial/minimizing seemed to be
associated with a favorable prognosis. Some, but even less
convincing evidence, was found that having experienced loss
events, a low level of social support, and chronic depression
predict an unfavorable prognosis. The influences of life events
(other than loss events), negative emotional states, fighting
spirit, stoic acceptance/fatalism, active coping, personality
factors, and locus of control are minor or absent. A
methodological shortcoming is not to have investigated the
interactive effect of psychological factors, demographic, and
biomedical risk factors.
Temoshok L, Personality, coping style,
emotion and cancer: towards an integrative model, Cancer Surv
1987;6(3):545-67,
What this paper attempts, which may be different than previous
reviews of the literature regarding the role of certain
psychosocial factors and cancer initiation/progression, is to
propose a model wherein seemingly discrepant findings may be
integrated and understood. For this task, a representative but
not an exhaustive review of studies was conducted, which revealed
surprising consistencies, given the heterogeneity of designs,
measures and cancer sites. Evidence converges on a constellation
of factors that appears to predispose some individuals to develop
cancer more readily or to progress more quickly through its
stages. These factors include (a) certain personality traits or
coping styles, which were discussed under the rubric of 'Type C';
(b) difficulty in expressing emotions; and (c) an attitude or
tendency toward helplessness/hopelessness. Next, illustrative
discrepancies across studies were presented. In order to make
sense of these seemingly discrepant results, a process model of
coping style and psychological-physiological homoeostasis was
proposed. This model may be used to understand why some studies
have found that Type C is associated with cancer outcome
measures, while others have found that helplessness/hopelessness
or emotional expression is related to outcome. We would expect
that these differences are attributable to the point in the
cancer and coping process at which psychological assessment was
conducted.
Gross J: Emotional expression in cancer
onset and progression, Soc Sci Med 1989;28(12):1239-48,
Despite the intensive
biomedical research in oncology since World War II, recent
studies show a steady increase in age-adjusted mortality for all
kinds of cancer. This findings gives impetus to the efforts of
researchers who have adopted the biopsychosocial model.
Systematic research using such a model has shown several
psychosocial factors to be associated with cancer onset and
progression, and Temoshok has recently suggested a theoretical
model which unifies these findings. In this paper, I consider the
evidence that one of these psychosocial factors, emotional
expression, may be directly involved in cancer onset and
progression. I review 18 relevant studies, discuss how one might
operationalize the term 'emotional expression', and make 12
suggestions for future research.
Temoshok LR: Change is complex: rethinking research on psychosocial interventions and cancer, Integr Cancer Ther 2002 Jun;1(2):135-45, The widely discussed 1989 study by Spiegel and colleagues, which suggested that a psychosocial group intervention affected survival in metastatic breast cancer, was not replicated by Goodwin and colleagues in 2001. We analyze methodological issues in both studies, including issues of sampling, randomization, interpretation, and the adequacy and validity of psychosocial constructs and measures to assess hypothesized ingredients of change. The notion of psychogenicity is introduced, conceived as the ability of psychosocial interventions to elicit changes hypothesized to be linked to desired medical outcomes. These considerations lead to the conclusion that there is insufficient evidence to be able to generalize from either study for or against the notion that psychosocial interventions can affect survival in breast cancer. The failure to incorporate into research designs a comprehensive understanding of how coping patterns and related factors may interact with psychosocial interventions to influence cancer progression, and to address hypothesized mediating mechanisms is discussed. Finally, strategies are proposed for future biopsychosocial and intervention research in the field of biopsychooncology.
Temoshok LR, Rethinking research on
psychosocial interventions in biopsychosocial oncology: an essay
written in honor of the scholarly contributions of Bernard H.
Fox, Psychooncology 2004 Jul;13(7):460-7.
In his best known contribution
to the field of psychooncology, the late Dr Bernard H. Fox
applied his breadth of scholarship in biopsychosocial cancer
epidemiology to address the question of whether and to what
extent stress and other psychosocial factors may contribute to
cancer risk. Less well known but equally important to the field
is his incisive critique of the 1989 study by Spiegel et al. on
survival time of patients with metastatic breast cancer following
a psychosocial intervention. This essay represents an attempt to
take Fox's line of thought to the next logical level of
rethinking research on psychosocial interventions in
biopsychosocial oncology. Following an analysis of the inadequacy
of randomized clinical trials (RCT) to evaluate the causal
effects of psychosocial interventions on cancer outcomes and
distinguish these from mere prediction, an integrated RCT design
is suggested to take into account the psychogenicity of a given
intervention, potential mediating mechanisms, and individual
differences that could help illuminate hypothesized causal
processes linking an experimental intervention and cancer
outcomes. Copyright 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
http://www.ipos-society.org/professionals/meetings-ed/core-curriculum/communication/it/player.html
Ptacek JT, Health care providers'
perspectives on breaking bad news to patients. Crit Care Nurs Q,
2000 Aug;23(2):51-9
This article reports the results of an investigation designed to
obtain descriptive information about what typically transpires in
bad news transactions between patients and physicians. A sample
of 115 health care providers who were attending a 1-day workshop
on palliative care issues responded to questions regarding bad
news transactions between physicians and patients. Results
indicated that giving the news in person, giving the news in a
private place, having patient support providers present, and
using a warm and caring tone are highly typical of bad news
transactions, whereas exploring patient emotional reactions,
relying on touch, delivering the news at the patient's pace, and
providing written information are less typical. Nurses and
physicians diverged in the perceptions about what typically
transpires, suggesting that studies focusing only on physician
reports or recommendations may be misleading. These data also
point to the need to obtain other views of bad news transactions,
and they argue for research designed to assess the relation
between actual patient-physician encounters and subsequent
patient-related outcomes.
Kaplan SH, Impact of the doctor-patient
relationship: breaking bad news review of literature, JAMA 1996
276 496,
OBJECTIVE: To review the literature on breaking bad news while
highlighting its limitations and describing a theoretical model
from which the bad news process can be understood and studied.
DATA SOURCES: Sources were obtained through the MEDLINE database,
using "bad news" as the primary descriptor and limiting
the sources to English-language articles published since 1985.
STUDY SELECTION AND EXTRACTION: All articles dealing specifically
with bad news were examined. These works included letters,
opinions, reviews, and empirical studies. Recommendations from
these articles were examined, sorted into discrete categories,
and summarized. DATA SYNTHESIS: The 13 most consistently
mentioned recommendations (eg, delivering the news at the
patient's pace, conveying some hope, and giving the news with
empathy) were examined. CONCLUSION: Although much has been
written on the topic of breaking bad news, the literature is in
need of empirical work. Research should begin with the simple
question of whether how the news is conveyed accounts for
variance in adjustment before moving to more specific questions
about which aspects of conveying bad news are most beneficial. It
is suggested that the bad news process can be understood from the
transactional approach to stress and coping.
Farber NJ, The good news about giving bad
news to patients, J Gen Intern Med 2002 Dec;17(12):914-22,
BACKGROUND: There are few data available on how physicians inform
patients about bad news. We surveyed internists about how they
convey this information. METHODS: We surveyed internists about
their activities in giving bad news to patients. One set of
questions was about activities for the emotional support of the
patient (11 items), and the other was about activities for
creating a supportive environment for delivering bad news (9
items). The impact of demographic factors on the performance of
emotionally supportive items, environmentally supportive items,
and on the number of minutes reportedly spent delivering news was
analyzed by analysis of variance and multiple regression
analysis. RESULTS: More than half of the internists reported that
they always or frequently performed 10 of the 11 emotionally
supportive items and 6 of the 9 environmentally supportive items
while giving bad news to patients. The average time reportedly
spent in giving bad news was 27 minutes. Although training in
giving bad news had a significant impact on the number of
emotionally supportive items reported (P <.05), only 25% of
respondents had any previous training in this area. Being older,
a woman, unmarried, and having a history of major illness were
also associated with reporting a greater number of emotionally
supportive activities. CONCLUSIONS: Internists report that they
inform patients of bad news appropriately. Some deficiencies
exist, specifically in discussing prognosis and referral of
patients to support groups. Physician educational efforts should
include discussion of prognosis with patients as well as the
availability of support groups.
link: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?tool=pubmed&pubmedid=12472927
Silliman RA, The impact of age, marital
status, and physician-patient interactions on the care of older
women with breast carcinoma, Cancer 1997 Oct 1;80(7):1326-34,
Understanding why older women with breast carcinoma do not
receive definitive treatment is critical if disparities in
mortality between younger and older women are to be reduced. With
this in mind, the authors studied 302 women age > or =55 years
with early stage breast carcinoma. Data were collected from
surgical records and in telephone interviews with the women. The
main outcome was receipt of definitive primary tumor therapy,
defined either as modified radical mastectomy or as
breast-conserving surgery with axillary dissection followed by
radiation therapy. The majority (56%) of the women underwent
breast-conserving surgery and axillary dissection followed by
radiation therapy. After statistical control for four variables (comorbidity, physical function, tumor size, and
lymph node status), patients' ages, marital status, and the
number of times breast carcinoma specialists discussed treatment
options were significantly associated with the receipt of
definitive primary tumor therapy. The authors concluded that when
older women have been newly diagnosed with breast carcinoma and
there is clinical uncertainty as to the most appropriate
therapies, patients may be better served if they are offered
choices from among definitive therapies. In discussing therapies
with them, physicians must be sensitive to their fears and
concerns about the monetary costs and functional consequences of
treatment in relation to the expected benefits.
Bahnson CB: Stress and cancer: The state of the art,
Psychosomatics 21: 975-981, 1980,
Although it has been repeatedly recognized from antiquity that
melancholy and grief may precede the development of cancer, a
body of evidence has now accumulated of a common personal
background and personality makeup in many cancer patients. A
recurrent theme is a feeling of loneliness and hopelessness
stemming from the lack of a protected and loving childhood. Such
persons harbor chronic underlying feelings of depletion,
emptiness, and resentment because they are unloved. Development
of a personality marked by self-containment, inhibition,
rigidity, repression, and regression precedes cancer, which may
involve somatic (cellular) "regression." The author
surveys the literature and provides an illustrative case report
to support his hypothesis.
Christine Reynaert, « Psychogenèse » du cancer : entre mythes, abus et réalité, Bulletin du Cancer Vol 87 numero 9 655 sept 2000. testo integrale: http://www.john-libbey-eurotext.fr/fr/revues/medecine/bdc/e-docs/00/01/13/99/article.md?type=text.html
Vedi anche: Quirino Zangrilla: Cancro e psiche: tra intervento scientifico e posizione di onnipotenza
prima version: 8.2.2007
ultima modificazione: 1.5.2007
questo testo è protetto dallo copyright
suggerimenti, errori d'italiano,
critica construttiva: forum http://www.transgallaxys.com/~kanzlerzwo/board.php?boardid=235 (in italiano)
contatto: italix @ transgallaxys.com